[Comics]Island

  • Friendship
RSS
Other media: Anime:ISLAND
Comics total pnts rank Rank 7,083in 8,221 titlesTotal -2 / Deviation 47.96
Comics rank of 2006 Rank 329in 388 titles
Statics of evaluation and Ranking
Reviews' statics
Post review by myself
Picture1.00(Good)2
Character/Setting-0.50(Normal)2
Story-1.00(Bad)2
Friendship100%2/2
Sad50%1/2
Moral50%1/2
Made me think50%1/2
Sexy0%0/2
Cute0%0/2
Hot heart0%0/2
Brave0%0/2
Shed tears0%0/2
Beautiful0%0/2
Romantic0%0/2
Scareful0%0/2
Shocked0%0/2
Enjoyed0%0/2
Cool0%0/2
Learned something0%0/2
Impressed0%0/2
Interesting0%0/2
Funny0%0/2
Poll
Information about this title

Naoshi Komi
SHUEISHA
Japan Released:2006/12 Akamaru Jump
3,91811
Recently views
2311100111
  Limit by opinioin
Search in this page

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post your review to English version, please click here.
2014/11/02 Very Bad(-2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 14043 Host:13846 Browser: 7455
It was a reading that was also included in the double art book.

Although I was talking about a pastor like King past the beginning, I do not clearly know whether it is a nickname "Mal" or a real name (?) If I thought that the girl was enjoying reading, Islay, who had jumped in front of her, was a boyish sister , Was the view of the world a hint from Europe's castle wall city and the future boys Conan, etc. Sharing roles properly for each sex,
It seems I was able to live, but it looked like a "bird in the basket".

The conversation between the mother's mother and the elder was looking at the figure of such two people, but the conversation of the elders became an important hint, but "I wish to wake up someday" as a "dream" and "reality" "Hope" "was probably the big theme of this work. It seems that the quality of the world was certainly more than it from that time certainly such a theme that it is not easy to understand strangely, and a strange little different world view.

However, on the other hand, it is honest "I do it again", but Islay tears away blatantly when I was informed of the "reality" I did from the temporary elder, and Mr. Mal sees it as a sort of quarrel with "I do not like Islay" Human portrayals such as doing were level below mediocrity on the top. Lastly such "hope" was also felt and Islah "get excited"
Although it was shed a joyful tears, even if the view of the world and the theme of the point of view is good, it was totally overwhelmed by this. A little. It was scanty to be transmitted.

Well, since it is an early work of the author, it seems to be cruel to see with a very high hurdle,
I was honestly questioning whether it was a cartoon that could win an award. Even Nisekoi who saw it on the animated version did not think that he would like to read the original work by all means, but this work also evaluates "very bad".




Top Page top MetaSeachJP Works