• Beautiful
  • Romantic
  • Made me think
Comics total pnts rank Rank 8,017in 9,010 titlesTotal -2 / Deviation 48.00
Comics rank of 2013 Rank 243in 282 titles
Statics of evaluation and Ranking
Reviews' statics
Post review by myself
Story2.00(Very good)2
Character/Setting1.50(Very good)2
Made me think100%2/2
Hot heart0%0/2
Shed tears0%0/2
Learned something0%0/2
Information about this title

Shinichi Sakamoto
Japan Released:2013/01/31(Thu) Weekly Young Jump / End:2015/04/16
Official sites
1. https://youngjump.jp/innocent/ (Translation)
Recently views
  Limit by opinioin
Search in this page

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post your review to English version, please click here.
2016/11/13 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 10004 Host:10170 Browser: 9959
The skill is amazing but overall it was terrible and the characters were only abnormally characterized in a bad way and I felt like blaspheming Versailles.
I do not know well what I want to do.
If it is a work set in the same Versailles it is better for the belly rose to have contents

2016/04/24 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 13075 Host:12998 Browser: 5171
[good point]
In the early days Charles who is drawn by momentum in the theme.Henri Sanson is a character that draws an interesting picture as a topic and executes an execution and a style of match matches

[Bad point]
As soon as I got to know a woman, the thought of the hero gets messed up.
The author does not deeply face the hero. Feeling that I could not handle the original theme nor throw it out.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
It seemed to be a lonely person, but the hero. It is a bad habit of the author that I mess up with the story of sex when I get stuck in the theme of the work theme.
Honestly, I can only think that the author could not catch the innocent executor Charles and ran away.
You can not do the Inaru sang rouge or you can not paint Charles.

2016/04/24 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 33396 Host:33432 Browser: 5187
It is a level of the level which can be tolerated even if it is said to be the top class in Japan, but it is a medieval Europe where the style is gloomy and it feels ruined, and France before the French Revolution seems to be the stage, Is it the greatest disadvantage that the narrowness of choice is the biggest disadvantage?

It is also the marriage position of Charles' s sister who seems to be able to sympathize barely, and has become a style which can not feel catharsis for the attitude based on historical fact as creation.

It is good or bad, it is a work of professional favorite. Evaluation is "good" I will.

2015/05/19 Favorite comment [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 16701 Host:16706 Browser: 8949
The skill has been outstanding, not only realistically, not only skillfully but also beauty and sense, it has been able to express the gorgeous atmosphere of the times before and after the French Revolution,
The unusual theme of executor clan Sanson family and the strange behavior of the character boldly arranging historical figures,
Is it a theme that criticism of discrimination is the theme, centering on executives seen with fascinating prejudice like fancy production like kabuki? Where the LGBT depiction is positively adopted also matches the world now To have

Charle of the hero Henry Sanson began to be in a state for the desperation reason that he had finished experience with a woman though it was a gentle character who opposed the death penalty at the beginning, sneaky acts are becoming noticeable While trying something, arguing in the justice, it turned into a violent character on the back and forth,
It may be that he wants to draw a place where a pure person goes dirty but he is a hero who is hard to empathize to read

A rival executor drawn to contrast with Charles.Marie Joseph is also a sister of a different family of Charles,
In history it arranges a little wisdom record and is almost brutal personality of the original character state,
Although it may have been made to appear as a villain which can also say sweet Charles's character, Marie Joseph who should be a villain at a rival is cruel but brave and frank personality, so it is far more attractive character than Charlle of the hero As a result, the phenomenon that Charles becomes air is occurring

It is a good thing that there are attractive characters, but it is not unlikely that a person's model character whose history is the subject matter and whose record is less conspicuous than the hero seems to lack the balance Because the picture is real but the content is intense like this, it is like a musical series of video games absolutely not recommended for those who are seeking historical cartoons faithful to historical materials, so seeking serious historical manga It seems that the presence of Marie Joseph is unacceptable when reading

Real oriented.It is a movie style, no effect sound is drawn and fragmentary lines and spreads.The expressions of expression of the picture character which used many large coma are also many expression of expression,
It has been expressed as appealing to the senses and has become a wonderful personality,
Because I omit descriptive lines, I am not good at telling the circumstances and people's emotions from the situation where the ability to read from the situation and the expression of a person is required by the reader and the expression of the person, things to be explained in words in detail I do not know what I do not understand at all what someone like prefers! This may be a gag cartoon ??

Personally I like the style that picks this person,
I'm looking forward to seeing how to paint the French Revolution and I support a lot of characters I like