|Statics of evaluation and Ranking|
|Information about this title|
|Japan Released:1999 Bessatsu Young Magazine |
- ▼Sorted by:Newness
2010/02/25 Not favorite comment [Original Japanese review]
by カマス (Skip) Provider: 14876 Host:14958 Browser: 8737
Attractiveness of the sea, the appeal of Zamami Island is transmitted.
Tempo is good overall in the first half, subject is also unified by diving and is very easy to read.
In the second half, I put too many elements and it is not gathered.
Since hints are not collected, the cutoff feeling is sharp.
From the first half to the middle stage it is fun and easy to read.
On the other hand, the latter half to the endings can not finish pleasantly leaving a mystery.
I wanted to diving and explain in various places.
2009/10/02 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by リーカ (Skip) Provider: 53692 Host:53728 Browser: 6399
I can understand a little about the fun of diving.
The scale is reasonably large.
There is a brilliant color illustration heavily using .CG.
I can not distinguish between people. Both men and women have the same face. Girls and women also face the same face.
People (especially hero and heroine) are unattractive.
Especially regarding the heroine, it is impossible to understand what the author thinks of such a character thinking of what is violent, dirty residents, poor cooks, family members, self-defeating, etc.
There are many contradictions and hints that have not been collected. Was it a censor?
Diving, love comedy, SF, suspense and so on? It pushes in too much and it works thinly in reverse.
Descriptions of diving and ruins are good, but the sense of censoring is drifting because all the things such as the mystery of the behavior of the whales, the purpose of the military, the fate of the hero's family, etc. are completed without being drawn.