Comics total pnts rank Rank 2,492in 8,857 titlesTotal 3 / Deviation 49.46
Comics rank of 2005 Rank 109in 370 titles
Statics of evaluation and Ranking
Reviews' statics
Post review by myself
Picture2.00(Very good)1
Hot heart0%0/1
Shed tears0%0/1
Made me think0%0/1
Learned something0%0/1
Information about this title

Sin Midorikawa
Monthly Shonen Sirius
Japan Released:2005 Monthly Shonen Sirius
Recently views
  Limit by opinioin
Search in this page

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post your review to English version, please click here.
2010/02/25 Normal comment [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 10018 Host:9890 Browser: 8176
[good point]
The picture is beautiful.
I am looking forward to having a little inclusion in the setting of the hero.
Because it is a royal road fantasy, it does not become an unexpected development.

[Bad point]
The sentences in the dialogue and the sentences in the background, etc. Anyway, the setting difficulty to see with a lot of sentences is in vain (in addition there are many settings which are written only in the outbound character introduction) There should be at least what should be grasped It is difficult to understand.
The frequency of publication is slow. As a matter of fact, it is too late for an episode to end. There is a slightly dull feeling

[Slightly anxious point]
When the teachers' past talks will begin in earnest when nothing at all will not be visible

It is often said that this one is better suited for one picture.
However, I do not dislike talking while talking about it, and I like the hero's child, so I am waiting for many years thinking that as soon as I enter into the calendar and develop variously, I will w

2009/08/12 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 13611 Host:13603 Browser: 10588
[good point]
That fine and delicate line is peculiar to illustrator and can not be managed by man in manga field

[Bad point]
Because of usual Ashi-san, we can not get there, badly

[Comprehensive evaluation]
I also love her painting at Sirius at first sight, but I can not imagine anyone's monkey to that picture at first glance (bitter smile and also writes with Shikoshiko alone as a stroke in the first few months of the series) It is such a result ... Physically the body is broken, it is tendonitis

Although this work has a slight dislike of masturbation, I think that it is a wonderful work including characters and the world view still.

It is common sense to make a professional illustrator to draw cartoons. But she certainly succeeded the insane request with factual strength and deep root, honestly respect ... Peko-chan.
Please think in the opposite eye. Whether many manga artists who do not have design knowledge, skills, and Hetta can successfully succeed as illustrators.

Personally to Sirius Editorial department, even if it clears up, there is a sombrerous grudge ... Although there is a little bruising, the foresight that I made debut as Mimakawa Shin as a cartoonist is amazing, I will praise you (lol Even the continuing Sirius direction would be better than Jump SQ ... lousy.

2009/06/18 Favorite comment [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 5099 Host:5205 Browser: 6342
I first thought about the beauty of the picture. The contents are fantasy and want to evaluate the story. However, the original does not proceed quite easily, only one book is out in a year. From the reader I would like to complain about the slow progress, but there is no other choice because there is work as a tenosynovitis and illustrator. I would like to expect how much it will entertain us.

2008/01/27 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 14505 Host:14271 Browser: 6391
It is a fantasy comic series serialized in the monthly boy Sirius.
While the setting is a magic school, while setting the falling skill that the hero can not use magic, actually there is a magical talent (in fact, it may be different from talent), it is a pretty royal story and lacks new taste.
Well, it may be that I can read it with confidence.

As for the picture it is very good ... But it is hard to see. The author has only an illustrator as a professional and draws a really good picture. Color is really beautiful. But I can not say that it is suitable for manga.
Afterwards, because the author suffers from tenosynovitis, it is also a drawback that the serial pace is slow.

Well, it is a manga I am quite looking forward to saying anything personally.