|Statics of evaluation and Ranking|
|Information about this title|
|Japan Released:2008/09/22(Mon) Weekly Shonen Jump / End:2009/02/09 |
- ▼Sorted by:Newness
2016/05/16 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by 塩キャラメル (Skip) Provider: 45022 Host:44877 Browser: 10196
I think that it is probably the representative of the only jump medical comic book at this moment, if magazine comes with super doctor K and champion comes with blackjack in a genre called juvenile medical manga.
The biggest point that distinguishes it from other medical dramas is the concept of 'treating people' s disease while being chased by the organization '.
The royal road thing that each team struggle to save the patient in front of me is different,
Female females have not yet been penetrated, and in the era when medical devices are not developed mainly, even in technology,
A pair of boys and girls who are still less than 20 years old have taken advantage of the experience cultivated in "Byblos = patient's blood clothes record", refusing the root of suffering in females and saving the life of precious persons Regardless,
Pazu and Rosari, who were always inquisitories from the Church's Order of the Church because of the absence of back shields like the Pope, in the streets, while escaping their persistent pursuit,
Because I had to encourage patients' treatment, it was a lot of trouble.
Particularly in the scene that the eyes went to, the place where Paz finishes the operation of Rosalie successfully and grabs joy while crying as "I am very happy" to the vision of my father who was asked "How is the mood of saving the patient"?
And, "Public surgery" who went up to the church to prove that he or she was the doctor most readers most likely saw at that time.
Furthermore, because he was injured in the "transmitter", he operated the myself.
The members of the church, including the Pope, were fueling the readers with a classic unpleasant behavior of the publication magazine, but since the backbone revealed at the end was drawn, the place that was not simply an unpleasant role was impressive did.
(〓〓〓In particular, regarding the Pope, the process that leads to the last story in the final volume (3 volumes) is carefully drawn)
The point that I did not reach the "full mark" by one step was that it did not fit in with the magazine too much or only 18 episodes were cut off,
There was also indigestion.The entire work was serious and somewhat heavy air as there was almost no gag,
I was reading medical supreme "Super Doctor K" in the medical genre first, so the impact and gags released from that work are burning,
Mr. Pazu, who is also the main character, is not bad at all, but initially he has a small face of displeasure,
In the reading edition, although the personality was completed, since the eyes were dead and the race was not related to the reaction,
Like KAZUYA, I felt that it was not kind of having the traction (= explosive power?) Enough to pull the surroundings including readers.
Personally, I wanted to thoroughly look through my eyes for about a year.
As a final note, I thought that I wanted to see Paz and Rosalie who came out of the sequel and became adults,
I thought that they wanted to jump out of the frame of the work and meet with various medical teachers.
As a doctor as well as a person, it will surely be a stimulation in a good meaning and should be able to rise the stairs of further height.
Toki (Hokuto Shinken to Medicine), Lee Pylon (Kampo Medicine and Master of Monkey Fist), Tex, Furzenberg (Gundam X).
........................ Sometimes it may be good to see a teacher.
............ Amiba, Faust (Guilty gear).
2014/12/28 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by TCC (Skip) Provider: 2134 Host:1944 Browser: 7420
Although it seems that this was also a short term censoring, it was probably the best among Mr. Inoue Mizushi's WJ series manga.
Although it seems to have been challenged with a medieval fantasy set in medieval Europe, the skill which was above the average from the debut time was improving, and there is also a story in which a boy who made a big cob on the face appeared However, I think that it was easy to explain intractable diseases and their knowledge of treatment methods. (Indeed, although there were aspects like conscious of blackjack)
The main character who was a boy who did not depend on anything at first, Buzz was well depicted as growing until it had the appropriate competence, and Rosari who had contact with his executed father also had a habit of saying " I thought that it was a contemporary thing with Mi ?, but at the beginning it seemed to be thrusting in, but it was also that it had a role as a mood maker not not only in charge of the escort staff such as the position of the bus, but also not heavy the atmosphere of the place . However, as for the story that the boy of a guest and his childhood friend girls became huge because of the tumor, there were tears such as tears, and there were also people from the anti-protagonists.
It was unsatisfactory that it was stereotypical like Caligula which crushed Laura's foot which was also an exclusive doctor of the above-mentioned boy, Vitellius which had been accustomed heretics to heretics.
Still, I do not think that it was a manga that will be terminated with 3 volumes of paperbook, but maybe I misunderstood a magazine to put on in the first place. If you changed the setting such as raising the age of the hero a little more and serialized in the youth magazine it would have continued for a longer time. It was Mr. Utsui who was unable to demonstrate his abilities in WJ, but after that, I wrote a series of serial cartoons in different magazines, that experience was never wasteful. Evaluation is "normal".
2014/11/01 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by かぷ (Skip) Provider: 13716 Host:13580 Browser: 5989
I am impressed with the thorough swing of jumping works that also brings medical items to the world of fantasy and battle
If you have modern medical technology set in the Middle Ages, it is inevitable that you will be abused with a devil or be honored with God, but it is inevitable that you will be somewhat frustrated by the public opinion operation of the Church, but I want to save men Acting straight in the desire to act straight is a well-deserved growing tone that will become a suitable person to inherit Asclepios in rescuing a patient that is suited to the hero
As a medical item, the reality based on the era is far from "Jin", and in the human drama it does not become the cornerstone of "Blackjack".
However, the growth of the heart that follows my belief and the feature of the battle feel that it was a proper jump comic and the misery of the battle is in an important position, but the combination also has a difficult path along with the strength The figure which opens up was hot above all!
For Inuzu Mr. Suzuki is also a series that will make me think "Finally Kita" at the third work It is a little disappointing for the end with just three volumes. Evaluation is [good] I will
2012/12/16 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by からあげ (Skip) Provider: 17582 Host:17455 Browser: 5233
The main character Buzz and its followers Misery 's character
Trivia on the diseases included everywhere
Character, story, theme and not good overall like a jump
I think that it was very interesting.
In the world where the medieval religion has power it was attracted to the theme of the main characters fighting against adversity.
The story was also concerned with the weekly weekly continuation, and the impression that it was able to collect the hints stretched everywhere, but it got together well though it was closed.
If we think that the last round of pros and cons is also the depiction of the growth of the hero, it can be said that it was a very beautiful last.
It can be asserted that it is a medical manga boasting the perfection degree of one of the jumps.
2011/10/20 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by こおりやま (Skip) Provider: 27461 Host:27383 Browser: 11131
Stable drawing power, character drawing ability.
A novel theme called medieval medical comics. It also includes elements such as discrimination, so it does not seem like a juvenile in a good sense.
It is interesting to see it even though it is not said that the character is unique. Furthermore, each one has a belief and can have empathy with the behavior of the character.
Directing ability. Goose bumps stood when Palais died.
In the view of the world the time consideration (possibly) was done, and there were many talks that will be beneficial in the surgical part.
Beginning with the summary of the last, the composition is high.
Impression that it was too plain in the journal called jump.
I loved you, I was cheering every week.
It was an unusual theme in jumping, I also liked the character and liked the picture. And it was brought to Palais at a stroke by the staging of the dead story. I am addicted to it.
In short-term terminated cartoons it will be the perfection of the top class. Perhaps it would have been a long-term series unless you start serializing the year of 2008 jump.
It was a very disappointing work that many things to learn were cut off. Still I thought things that I finished cleanly were a driftstone veteran.
It is a recommended work. I will make the evaluation very good.
Next time you want a young magazine to publish a hit work.
2011/10/12 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by オモプラッタ (Skip) Provider: 15333 Host:15371 Browser: 6358
The storm of the heresy of the Inquisition at the early modern period in Europe was still the most intense, yet I could represent well the era when the existence of a doctor was seen in a prejudiced eyes, and the hero who advances and the pretty followers are attractive while suffering in it It is drawn.
I still can not understand why this manga faced a problem of termination.
Is not it because it did not match the trend of the magazine called Weekly Shonen Jump?
I'd like you to get revenge per super jump or SQ.
2010/09/29 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by soka (Skip) Provider: 4702 Host:4471 Browser: 9207
A gentle but bearish story that the hero who is unconfident about himself now is empowered to medical treatment while fighting the prejudice and misunderstanding of the people around him, cures the partner's mind and body, and the viewer is inspired.
The reaction of the hero 's growth with the main heroine and sub - character that is inspired by it The heroine is a nice girl, but as a result he is somewhat lazy and somewhat high pressure.
The story and painting power are stable.
Even if discontinuation is early, places that are not miscellaneous are also nice.
Short serialization period Because it was not a jumping direction, it is a work that has been aborted indefinitely.
However, Sunday and magazine have more high-quality medical cartoons than this, and the hurdle is high, champion is ... subtle.
Then it was correct answer that posted in the jump after preparing a short story.
Although the serialization period is short, it is a very good work. The leading character of reading is also interesting, but this one is better.
Believing that it jumped to the reader for a while, it gave a good influence, the evaluation was raised.
2010/05/01 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by 多菜化 (Skip) Provider: 15448 Host:15542 Browser: 9578
The picture was also polite and it was very good with medical theme as the theme.
I hope this work was not a jump. Then I think that it continued for a long time.
Rosalie was cute.
2010/04/29 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by 十傑集 (Skip) Provider: 36209 Host:36373 Browser: 6425
Regrettable ... a very regretful work. If the posted magazine is not a juvenile jump, it may be because it was a jump so it dared to post it.
Perhaps the aim of this work was not antithesis to "DEATH NOTE".
The story that the main character of Got hand cured cure for any seriously ill patient in medical cartoon seemed to be injured, but in the times when the powers of the Papacy were overwhelming,
Treatment to be treated as heretics (Although it was first surgery but there was no sterilization depiction?) I was sorry, but I was just about halfway for a later event
It was brilliantly drawn into the figure of the hero who saves lives while being suppressed by power (= just the life).
It seems that the initial idea was to develop people's ideas and eventually change the world by accumulating things to save lives.
(It really seems like a desato to get the signature of the patient who treated the blood-length notes)
Descriptions of buzz, palais, caligula are exquisite for characters.
Buzz was the hero who really feels the weight of life.
Palais who is the life-sized character of the reader is inspired by Buzz, accompanying, helping Buzz and Rosari while licking for heretic, and losing his life ....
I was brilliantly depicting the reality that there is a life that can not be saved by any doctor (which is why life is precious!).
And Caligula killed Palais. The revenge of Buzz to him who thinks only as garbage, such as heretic life is like the hero who respects life.
And, until the middle of the three volumes was "best" without drawings, themes, stories and no complaints, but it is closed?
At the end, the story is forcibly folded and it is unknown after the fleeing caligula, the paret is not actually ... you know.
I think that "DEATH NOTE" is not complaining if it is put together by volume 6, 7, but this work wanted about 5 or 6 volumes.
2009/11/23 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by ボルガ (Skip) Provider: 26120 Host:26214 Browser: 7898
How to make characters. Story composition. Settings etc are polite and high level.
Rosari is not too cheeky, it is finished in a balanced heroine.
The time consideration is done well.
The background of the character is drawn carefully. Even Caligula of the villain can sympathize.
While it is a story for adults, he does not overlook juvenile cartoon elements such as hero's growth and pure friendship.
The way of making the last is just a supernatural work. Succeeded in the Vitellius of the black curtain, all the hints are collected and finished in a pleasant last.
Perhaps it was finished in a better work unless we tried to match it to a boy's magazine.
Originally a work by a talented author, the quality was very high. I am very good work by helping the skill of how to fasten the last because it is short.
Since this author is leaving masterpieces of gems such as "Cain" "Forest" "Asclepius" at the end, this is the last thing to do with jumping at the end, I want you to do the series in youth magazine.
2009/11/09 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by tokumei (Skip) Provider: 29855 Host:29889 Browser: 11074
This is a nice work. I was pretty good. Of course still.
It was definitely a masterpiece unless there was a censor.
Being likable to the hero and the heroine.
(Buzz tends to be a bearish boy, but I think that I am a very kind one.
Personally think that there is no other pure and gentle hero like buzz.
Rosaly is a girl who likes it. Actually I like it more than Buzz. I do not particularly care about that tone)
(Medical theme: There is freshness, surgical scenes must see)
(It seems to be very high, it is said that it is said to be plain, but better than cartoons that are sold only with pictures)
(Impression that people understand the pain, I think that they are doing the best personality among cartoonists)
Absent. can not find.
However, I think that compatibility with jumping was bad after all.
I do not know why such a good work is cut off.
You can really understand the current state that beautiful things are transient (overstated?).
Very good, close to the best.
2009/10/23 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by 莉紗 (Skip) Provider: 479 Host:461 Browser: 11101
I liked this cartoon, since the jump started !!!
I did not like the picture, but the content is great with a good tempo,
Buzz is doing my best !! It is a cartoon that I want to cheer for!
,,, Was not it good to continue a bit more ??
Later, it was nice that the person who was stabbed protecting Buzz from the middle way lives last.
If the way to write characters' face is a bit more cool or cute,
I wonder if the popularity of women was also gathered?
2009/10/09 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by ルサンチマン (Skip) Provider: 19107 Host:19235 Browser: 10862
Just "Hidden masterpiece".
The medieval world view was well drawn,
A description about medical is also perfect.
Although the serialization was short, there was also no tired of deployment.
I liked the heroine 's rosary in characters.
Become the first patient of the hero's surgery,
Fighting instead of the hero, it was an all - rounder heroine.
Regrettably, the main character would have been plain.
(I also thought that it was absolutely bad at jumping)
I was watching the figure growing rapidly ..
However, evaluation is very good because it is considerably good work inside of myself.
2009/09/23 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by grozy (Skip) Provider: 6001 Host:5987 Browser: 9224
Personally I loved rosary.
It was good that weak Buzz gradually and gradually grows strongly.
It was good as a boy's manga.
However, it was not like "Shonen Jump".
The picture was probably not a fad of this time.
I think Inoue is a person who strongly believes in human conscience.
I think that "Boy's manga" is better.
However, if you touch "medicine", "history of domineering of the church"
I think I wanted to express more ugly humanity.
But I think that it would be better if they were young magazines.
I read this work and thought like this.
Human content always has contradiction.
It does not look directly at the dirty ugly ones in their human beings,
I will not admit, I will not, so the truth can not be found.
The boy wants to believe.
I want to make dreams to humans. So this work was good with this.
It was a work that a human being dreams of.
But this is not true.
As mentioned at the beginning of the work,
"Church" holds tremendous power, many innocent people
It is stigmatized as "heretic" and is subjected to a fire.
There was such a time indeed.
And also in modern times, such things are done in places where it is hard to see.
There are people who do not blindly punish, but who are executing punitive not easy to understand by third parties.
It was a misunderstanding way of saying.
It is not that "the church"
"A person who seems to be right at first sight" is that.
2009/09/23 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by momizima (Skip) Provider: 21154 Host:20978 Browser: 8759
The heroine is good. (Followers and doctors)
The main character of the final chapter was very charming as a character.
The last way to put together was very good. A streak ran unexpectedly.
The time to understand the background of the story was too long.
(Because the subject matter is difficult contents, it was unsuitable for a jump requested for immediate effect.)
I personally like it very much.
I think that the idea of 〓〓〓〓〓he author always shines, including past works.
However, it is a problem to say that it was not for the jumping direction as expected by other evaluators.
Personally I would like to keep on leaving this way and let me know about the jump.
2009/09/21 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by 三橋廉 (Skip) Provider: 29568 Host:29554 Browser: 9573
A picture, a good feeling of empathy of the hero.
The story is well done.
It was not serialized in Sunday, magazine, etc. which is difficult to understand the last round and the first round.
Perhaps my expectation was that I could not understand the first times,
I think that the number of people reading about elementary school students, junior high school students, etc. got separated and fewer people read it as soon as they came off.
However, I think that readers will be willing to read such contents as magazines, sundays and so on.
But, in magazine, there is God hand shine, so I think that it is reasonable to serialize with Sunday.
Well I like Asclepios, so at the best.
2009/08/06 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by ZJ (Skip) Provider: 29426 Host:29502 Browser: 7136
picture. Story. Everything was good
It was not possible to continue the series in a juvenile having only a bad sense of sense
It was more interesting than a dress and I saw it first
2009/07/22 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by 山口21号 (Skip) Provider: 19847 Host:19729 Browser: 6794(Mobile)
The picture is beautiful
. Surgical scene
Characters of a heroine
The compatibility with the jump was too bad
Character of the main character
The story is heavy
It is good that the picture is beautiful and the surgical scene is real.
However, I think that it was inevitable to end the crown because the direction is too different from the jump that emphasizes momentum and so on, so the hero is hard to empathize with hetare.
Because it should have been a big hit if it was serialized with jump square etc. It is very regretful.
I will evaluate the highest.
2009/07/15 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by T.K.G (Skip) Provider: 23556 Host:23573 Browser: 10588
The picture is beautiful,
There was attraction to the operation scene.
The story also goes well,
Character is not good.
I mistook the way of personality.
I could not accept everyone.
Although it is not enough to buy a book,
It was like a hidden masterpiece.
Evaluation is good.
2009/05/26 Favorite comment [Original Japanese review]
by コジコジ (Skip) Provider: 49173 Host:49223 Browser: 8456
It was a baptized story.
Especially the excitement of the climax, I think there is only what is said to be a hidden masterpiece.
There is sense of urgency in the operation scene.
I could not like the characters' characters.
I think that it is difficult for a hero to have a boy to accept.
Also how the assistant speaks ...
It is a pity that the story is interesting.
I am very sorry that I was cut off just because the excitement of the last stage was good.
Comprehensive evaluation is "good"
2009/04/27 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by マヨラー (Skip) Provider: 18003 Host:17837 Browser: 2153(Mobile)
Clear, beautiful picture.
The depictions of the characters' emotions are fine.
How to summarize the final story is Great!
Hints of foreshadowing are also attractive.
If I do not buy it, I do not know why Palais was alive.
2009/04/09 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by ロクマ (Skip) Provider: 18595 Host:18730 Browser: 9572
I edited it.
The picture is beautiful.
Jump is a rare genre.
I do not think in the final story ...
I do not remember my name. The name of the main character suffers ...
It's not for children.
The author is not suited for jumping, is not it?
Even though it is funny comics, the reader is not following me.
It's a waste.
The author is quite fond of human beings.
Even when I finish it will control me with Mr. Oishi ...
I really like that so I hope next time will succeed. Because it does not have to be a jump.
2009/04/07 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by ぴか (Skip) Provider: 4631 Host:4352 Browser: 5599
"Saddest fate" In the third series work by Mr. Inoue Mizushi, it was very regrettable that the series ended individually.
Drawing. Character. Constituent ability. Practice. Comment at the end of the book (haha) ...... None of the necessary abilities are necessary for making authors have manga,
I think the quality of the work itself is top class among the jump series.
(Although the author is not so young anymore, I was surprised to see the evidence of progress certainly from the previous work)
I think that the growing process of the main character Buzz which is drawn carefully is very boy's magazine,
"Asclepius" has many charming and individual character rich characters compared with Mr. Inoue's past works.
(Rosaly. Palais etc ...)
Also, although it is a sombre work, a gaze is prepared firmly every week, only deployment that is worrisome for the next week.
Although the theme of a juvenile-like difficult subject called "medicine" is the subject, the level of explanation and description is full-fledged and reality,
Although it is very easy to understand with ingenuity such as "snake column", it makes me feel the author's skill though understanding is not difficult.
And we must admire the hints of hints and the skill of collecting it in the latter half of the work.
Especially in the last round, many hints remained, the priority ranking correctly drawn things that can be done correctly, it gave me a refreshing summary.
Although it is an aborted work, there is no impossibility of being forcibly pushing the deployment, and it is finished as a fine work in a splendid manner.
..., and throughout the whole story there were few good noticeable disadvantages only in good places,
As I was able to enjoy this work consistently and very much, as mentioned above, the series end is very sad ... ... ...
Unfortunately, I think that it was also a cartoon that can not be helped even if it was terminated. . .
Is this still a popular work for "Weekly Shonen Jump"?
I felt the ingenuity to put out the author's "boys' magazine", and indeed the color was stronger than in the past work,
Still it is unlikely that a series of dark evolution after the beginning of the early stages of surgery and midfield will be received by elementary and junior high school students of the main reader of "jump" ....
It seems that it does not matter and I personally think that it is an unexpectedly important element in the manga magazine below juvenile magazine,
Professor Inoue's comic is concerned about "difficulty in remembering the name of the character".
It seems to be because there are many characters whose source name is actually a historical figure,
Even so, the main characters 'Buzz' and 'Palais' suffering seems to be a problem.
I think that memorizing the name is the first step of attachment attachment to that character.
After all, since all three series serialized by this has become short-term censoring, it may be that there is no opportunity already in "Weekly Shonen Jump"
I think that Mr. Inoue is a very wonderful manga artist, so I also want to focus on future activities.
(Not only comics but also comic books entertain readers with contest with Mr. Oishi etc, and also likability was very high even at comment)
Something, I think that it will surely become Taisei if large weapons can be made.
Evaluation is "very good".
Including the point that was a cartoon not received in a juvenile magazine, and expectation of Professor Inoue's next work, the top is not chosen.
2009/04/06 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by ヒロシゲ (Skip) Provider: 29567 Host:29641 Browser: 8455
One of the works that became the prey of the current jump if I think now.
The theme is good for jumping. Moreover, the drawing power is high and the contents are good as it is. I just thought that I do not need to emphasize the elements of the battle. Although it seems that this is not the intention of the author. I feel like I was aiming for readers on the editing side. It is speculation to the last.
It was not so bad although it could not be evaluated so much as it came to an early stage.
Speaking of bad things, the author chose a place to jump.
2009/04/05 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by かげろう (Skip) Provider: 21846 Host:21769 Browser: 2135(Mobile)
Stable drawing power. Creating an unexpected talk.
Nothing in particular
For juvenile magazines it was a popular theme with a heavy theme, but content can be enjoyed enough
2009/03/01 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by ボンバイェイ (Skip) Provider: 7718 Host:7503 Browser: 9207
It is certainly not a bad manga.
Medical treatment by jumping was also nice, so this author's picture is beautiful.
But, it is true that many of them are not interesting, as they are all closed off.
This time also the main character is a bad personality on medicine.
Well, it's not a kind of continuing content, but I wanted this to continue.
Evaluation is "good".
2009/02/27 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by 目ぐすり (Skip) Provider: 6271 Host:5937 Browser: 9326
It was very well organized.
Drawing. The quality of the composition etc. was stable and high.
I have been looking forward to it fairly weekly after entering open surgery.
I confused it to the confession of the poster Lee of the last episode.
The opening part was plain. I thought that it would not continue until then ...
It is slightly negative that the setting of God's eyes did not come out much.
I think that it is a writer of an unusual type that is getting better every time it is serialized.
I think that it became quite a masterpiece though it is plain but this time I expect it for the next work.
2009/02/27 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by しずな (Skip) Provider: 7696 Host:7311 Browser: 5234
There is nothing.
Rapid ... too gross ... (crying
Reading that manga was fear.
2009/02/26 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by ホワイトサイド (Skip) Provider: 38880 Host:38872 Browser: 6287
Medical manga by jumping.
Flow of talk.
It was not somewhat jumping oriented.
Although I enjoyed myself, it was a somewhat difficult manga from the reader layer of the jump.
I am sorry that it was cut off.