Comics total pnts rank Rank 8,745in 9,044 titlesTotal -10 / Deviation 45.60
Comics rank of 1974 Rank 39in 39 titles
Statics of evaluation and Ranking
Reviews' statics
Post review by myself
Character/Setting-2.00(Very bad)1
Hot heart0%0/1
Shed tears0%0/1
Made me think0%0/1
Learned something0%0/1
Information about this title

Sadao Shoji
The Mainichi Daily News (Mainichi Shimbun)
The Mainichi Newspapers Co.,Ltd.
Japan Released:1974/04
Recently views
  Limit by opinioin
Search in this page

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post your review to English version, please click here.
2012/03/28 Very Bad(-2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 15458 Host:15408 Browser: 7541
It is not interesting 4-frame manga that I often saw in the newspaper.
Although it is the atmosphere like Sazae or Kobo-chan, I do not really understand the name of the character, and it is characterized by not being so interesting no matter what it is.
I do not feel like it, it does not seem like a serial work for many years.
Is it interesting in the early days, etc. for such reasons that the series lasted and it came to not be able to be pulled out over time ... Is it such a feeling?
In other newspapers, more interesting manga familiar with modern day is on it, so reading is often there.

Or, the picture is too similar to actual Kobo - chan.
I think that you can understand how delicious this manga is at the point in time when the person is behind but this one is minor.

2009/11/03 Very Bad(-2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 4532 Host:4359 Browser: 6211
It's about a year since I started reading, perhaps it was fun when I was not familiar with it ....

(1) Biased enough to classify a lot of neta in "current news", "food" and "word play".

Current affairs story ... Because it is a newspaper manga, it is not bad for itself,
Even so, just by picking it up as a story, are you going to have finished your work?
I feel weird enough to think.

Food ... Is it because the name goes as an educational essayist, there are many stories related to food. Although it does not complain if it is interesting, I'm fed up with only things that are disappointing while bringing in my specialty field.

Language play ... Just praised, coined word, just practiced the etymology of saying, etc. Especially when coined,
Just linking similar words, I can not feel particularly sophisticated.

Moreover, although it is felt much in the last word game, I am also worried that it is scattered that it does not form a body as a four-frame manga to be expanded with an entrance consolidation. More to say,
There is no need to draw a picture, just conversation is enough. I will finish with Kozo (which is also childish).

(2) Illustration of a poorly developed food intestine, Illustrations of illustration got interested and I tried hand-colored manga too,
If it says a little, I close my eyes, but as I am from Waseda, I am from Momaki, the manga is the main business ...
Poor enough picture to doubt whether it is true or not. There are few backgrounds, people center.
And even for that person, when you bend your arms, hold something in your hands, you are already in the state of drawing elementary school students.

If gag is also not interesting, picture is poor,
So it's no wonder that we are serializing more than 10,000 times.

2008/03/26 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 54140 Host:54143 Browser: 4184
Current affairs story always deviates a little bit and uses the same topic.
Sometimes it seems occasionally that the point of view is good, but the punch line is too dirty.
Also, there are too many unnatural points in the words and reactions of the characters.
(Whatever you think, you are saying rude things, those who said you also said no response)
To be honest, I want to ask the author who I am thinking about where it's interesting

2007/07/26 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 12661 Host:12703 Browser: 2893(Mobile)
Oh, this.

It is a cartoon serialized everyday since I was born.

Despite falling down the story, cooking has not been done well. For example, is it just vegetable juice that has just been boiled?

Indeed, a cheapest leave is gone.

But it was satisfied with that at the same time as it was small, and if it is not enough then it is lonesome so it is the worst ....

But Yumi Morishita manga is far better quality.

2007/07/26 Very Bad(-2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 19923 Host:20012 Browser: 3162
I'm really sorry. It is a tough evaluation.

Whichever you look from where you are too honorable. There are things that have gags, but it's not fun. In the short frame of 4 frames, there is no importance that the momentum like sputtering is important.

To be clear, where to enjoy is a mystery.
I do not know better than to have a funny part.
It is a mysterious manga in various meanings

2007/07/26 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 41276 Host:41321 Browser: 5234
Normal office worker, Assatte and his daily life ...
Although it will be explained as "an ordinary salaried worker"
Sense of characters, a cold gag that is going to be spreading, which is going to deviate greatly from the sense of "ordinary Japanese"
It is not a daily newspaper cartoon, an unusual world.

[good point]
Personally none.

[Bad point]
From the early morning, furiously boring, or reading meaningless manga, the vitality of the day with anger does not come up.
Current affairs story gains masculinity of processing, gentle to texture, everyday gag,
Deki who doubts the author's gag sense. It seems to be only a bad joke that expansion and punch which is meaningless are developed flatly and extremely. Is this a cartoon of avant-garde art system?
In the four-panel cartoon of the major newspaper morning edition (including evening publications), it is not amusing to excel. The halfway end which does not even function as a nonsense comic,
It is like embodying the Mainichi Shimbun.
Sometimes when I read the Mainichi newspaper, I read this book and compare it with the article and make a new reminder that "After all I am out of focus or out of place".
Although it is not said to be the worst in the history of newspaper cartoons, the Mainichi Shimbun is too terrible that a terrible boring newspaper manga lasted along with the evening paper.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
"worst". My most disliked newspaper cartoon. Actually I did not know it at all,
It seems there was a thread to hit this work even on certain bulletin boards. Did not I dislike not only myself? Tokai also has a story saying that the food essay is good,
I have read a few books in the past but this myself is a mine. I eat a lot of things vigorously, but there is nothing new with novelties. I could not understand the storytelling was interesting and I could not understand what was being evaluated. Or was it just a struggle for what I read. And apart from the essay criticism,
It is totally entertaining. Gag, Deng, Hot from Wit Why is this manga on the newspaper what is far away? Before being a "newspaper cartoon", is this a cartoon?
I am surprised that the boring question of even the fundamental question of being bored is boring. Boring like torture,
It takes patience to go out daily.