[Comics]Another

  • Scareful
  • Made me think
RSS
Other media: Anime:Another / Literature:Another / JP movie:Another
Comics total pnts rank Rank 1,225in 8,400 titlesTotal 9 / Deviation 51.16
Comics rank of 2010 Rank 21in 303 titles
Statics of evaluation and Ranking
Reviews' statics
Post review by myself
Story2.50(Best)4
Character/Setting1.75(Very good)4
Picture1.50(Very good)4
Scareful50%2/4
Made me think50%2/4
Cute25%1/4
Sad25%1/4
Shocked25%1/4
Learned something25%1/4
Interesting25%1/4
Sexy0%0/4
Hot heart0%0/4
Brave0%0/4
Shed tears0%0/4
Beautiful0%0/4
Romantic0%0/4
Moral0%0/4
Friendship0%0/4
Enjoyed0%0/4
Cool0%0/4
Impressed0%0/4
Funny0%0/4
Poll
Information about this title

Yukito Ayatsuji
Hiro Kiyohara
Kadokawa Shoten Publishing Co.,Ltd.
Japan Released:2010/04/03(Sat) Young Ace / End:2011/12/03
Official sites
1. http://www.kadokawa.co.jp/another/ (Translation)
12,97599
Recently views
4425023214
  Limit by opinioin
Search in this page

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post your review to English version, please click here.
2014/03/27 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 44839 Host:44804 Browser: 10424
[good point]
Charadaticza
High drawing power
I firmly reproduce the eeriness of the original
[Bad point]
Nothing in particular
[Comprehensive evaluation]
it's the best

2013/10/14 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 4438 Host:4492 Browser: 6157
I think that it is a work that could be done well with comicalization

I was also able to produce a scare scene with patterns that I only can do with comic books, and I was able to collect hints that could become liver.
While arranging the original settings, arrangements were added, and Akazawa's setting, which was originated from this comicalization and was also handed over to the animation version, will also achieve growth and transformation to characters until it symbolizes another animated version Another It will be

If you like Akasawa's favorite anata, survival route, please come and have this manga version. The result is different only because it alone is worth reading, but this time it was meaningful and worthy to trace the original and accomplish it

2013/03/31 Very Bad(-2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 37829 Host:37615 Browser: 5345
Although I liked the original,
The manga version was not good.

Something wrong with the characters was not done well,
Despite the ability, although the expression of the characters did not convey much of the emotional ups and downs, I was simply bored while reading.

In this case the movie version was still more interesting.

2013/03/21 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 18589 Host:18685 Browser: 5345
[good point]
Because such a psychological story is not easy, it was nice to have fun.
It is short as 4 volumes until completion, but I think that this is the perfect goal-in so as not to lose its content (laugh)
The painting ability to find a dark feeling was also good.

[Bad point]
I think that the characteristic of the hero was thin, but I do not mind so much because this is the important point of the whole story.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
There were scary scenes in various ways, but relief which was relieved at completion was amazing.

2012/04/16 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 15458 Host:15408 Browser: 7541
The picture is really beautiful. To the extent, it seems that it was not serialized before the TV animation broadcast (the main character's face is like a different person).
It is too high quality to say that it was made before becoming famous ah.
The expression of the person is also very good, and the hair quality looks awesome and beautiful.
Sometimes a gaggy scene goes in, but it is suitable for many people to see, not so much as to make you feel uncomfortable.

Anime, the treatment of characters and life and death also differ from novels.
The ending itself is the same, but the process to that end is slightly different.
The representative one is the point where Akasawa survived.
I was glad because it was a character I wanted to survive and want to survive.

Only the novel remains. I want to read cheaply if I get it ....

2012/03/18 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 20513 Host:20666 Browser: 5345
[good point]
The picture is beautiful!
The story is funny The nature of the sound is funny Akasawa's way of going crazy is not half-ended
[Bad point]
Animation is subtle but does not matter to manga


2012/02/17 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 16079 Host:15997 Browser: 4868
〓〓nime viewing, original unread, spoilerous description〓〓
[good point]
Three pairs of curses, mysterious girl Misaki Namizaki (I think it is attractive as a heroine, but just an animated version can do it well), what is the dead?
Attracted to the world view such as

As for the mystery element, it seems that the original is a famous mystery novelist 's original with hints pasting and collecting.
The true identity of the dead seems to be a narrative trick, but there is unexpectedness in a way that is clever in manga version,
This seems to affect the animation version as well

There is also fear as a horror that the painting power is consistent and the atmosphere is made. Different from animation, it is good to think that the thought of the hero is drawn properly It is understood that it is quite terrible

[Bad point]
When you think finely, you can see the roughness. Although it is a magnificent view of the world, although there are dead people out every year, this school has an explanation as to why the school is not a problem, but explanation of the class to the hero is abnormally slow after all

Gag element to enter on the way. It is unnecessary for this work. It is considerably decreasing by animation

In the end there are few mystery parts, horror works. The cause of the cause of the incident is not unknown about 26 years ago Misaki also (unknown though it seems that Misaki of 26 years ago and the mother of the hero seemed to be related, the story became multilayered Not)
Its resolutions were also thrown so it ended up coping temporarily in this year It was not clear how far it was on the way Indefinitely making a horror or not clear it was good, but in the end it was a little shoulder watermelon that the major part was a horror I can not deny, I think that it was better that the reasoning part increased more.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Recent works of famous mystery novelists who are talking about being animated recently, becoming a movie and becoming a topic.
I could not wait to watch anime halfway and read the comic book version but I enjoyed it. However, if you think about various things and read it, the complaints to the punch that you mentioned in a bad point that it was a horror eventually remain honest. Evaluation is "good".

2012/01/15 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 25392 Host:25501 Browser: 4788
For the time being, I read it as a work by Mr. Ono Umi no husband.
I read about two novels in the museum series, but I did not have much impression ...
This impressive impression ... ...
I was able to read it quite happily until about 1 volume, 2 volumes, but it turned out to be Gudaguda from about three volumes
Volume of 4 volumes .....
The surprise was surprising, but it seems like the last thing that seems to be something anything.
I can not convince you, but since it is troublesome, I got an impression that ended with "Well, this kind of monkey".
I am sorry that the first initiative was good.

2011/02/23 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 19261 Host:19080 Browser: 12025
I have not read a novel. It is a completely entered manga.

[good point]
Serious development The mystery itself is the backbone of the work, and it is the way of enjoying this work together with the main character, "What is happening now, what is going to happen from now on? Because of that style I can not read anything at all and it has always been developed to be hit by a sense of urgency, I like to read such a work very much I enjoy reading it.

It was originally a fan though I've read the past paintings of painter of this painting work, but I feel that the picture is suitable for the style like this work.
I am in charge of the cover of many novels (it is not a light novel) and one piece is quite a thing, but the manga is also carefully drawn for every one coat.

[Bad point]
If I can not get on the flow of the work, I'm just bored.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Personally I was able to enjoy it considerably. Since I have only one volume of paperbook yet, I would like to look forward to the continuation.

Evaluation is [very good].




↑Top