Comics total pnts rank Rank 2,984in 9,005 titlesTotal 3 / Deviation 49.49
Comics rank of 1990 Rank 71in 147 titles
Statics of evaluation and Ranking
Reviews' statics
Post review by myself
Information about this title

Japan Released:1990 Monthly Shonen Jump / End:1992
Recently views
  Limit by opinioin
Search in this page

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post your review to English version, please click here.
2011/06/21 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 22515 Host:22633 Browser: 9365
I wanted the contents to inflate a bit more. The heroine 's Takigawa Yuuko is not able to find the direction of the actual work as much as it is, it is a work that is difficult to evaluate even though it is ended by choosing death easily from a grudge against Yuuko Takigawa.

After all it is not a love story nor a mystery but a feeling that it has become a work of a different color that does not have a deep emotion against the thing called "the death of a heroine".

2011/04/12 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 3744 Host:3957 Browser: 9466
Is this work acceptable as a mystery thing?
It feels too weak that it feels too weak It felt that Yuuko's meaningful setting was simply being made out as a small story and no double line felt to be a fun story. Especially it is exciting as a love story Not necessarily ... I can not get a triangle relationship, it is a halfway feeling in everything

At that time, when I was a child who did not know love at all, these adult ladies were sometimes longing for you I remember being particularly excited at a transfer student However, now when I read calmly and read back considerably There is impossible setting, too much setting, there are many settings etc. that are likely to occur

I am sorry that none of the painting power is regrettable It is quite easy to see but if it is a little better you may have been able to empathize the character

The picture is a bit better.
Organize the settings a little more
Take care of the story (Frame division?)
If there was such as it may have cried in the last round

Difference in target age, I think there are differences of times etc., but this is my impression

2011/04/01 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 24214 Host:24210 Browser: 7703
Mr. Yamada Kenji 's love story comic series serialized by monthly juvenile jump in 90 to 92 years. Second grade 's second grader' s "Natsume Hiroyuki" encounters a mysterious girl "Yuko Takigawa" standing on the coast with an unexpected look at summer vacation beach camps. In the summer I thought of committing suicide she would smile and return. In the second term she moves into Natsume's class. To Natsume and Yuko, youth traveling round about with Natsume 's childhood friend' Aikawa Chisa 'and Tennis' s Date Man `Toho Tohru' runs round.

This work is drawn in a story setting that is common as a love drama such as encounter with mysterious girl and development involving triangle relation, and includes similar elements such as "Kimagure Orange Road" and "Miyuki" etc. It's finished in content. A boy in the middle of youth encounters a mysterious girl in the summer vacation, then transferred to his class, then forming a triangular relationship with her childhood friend, becoming obsessed, in a positional sense "Kimagure Orange Road ", but in Kimagure there is the purpose of nurturing love, there is light first, but in this work it is a dark content of the feeling of carrying a shadow of thought of a person in a melancholy.

The main character 's "Natsume Hiroyuki" goes straight when I think, but it was a bit like a clumsy (not a psychedelic) ordinary boys, it was a feeling of splitting together `Kasuga Kasuke' and 'Wakamatsu Masato' together . The mysterious girl "Yuko Takigawa" was 'Ayukawa Madoka' everywhere except that there is no hope of living with illness. Natsume 's childhood friend' Aikawa Chisato 'was rather rather' Wakamatsu Miyuki '. `Toho Tojo 'was a good Datee boy who is often a part of this love comedy, that was it.

The story is that Natsume met on a beach at the summer vacation and she got transferred to the Natsume class and became a youth drama-like development involving Chita and the surroundings, which is a setting of a common love comedy Yuuko is sick and has no desire to live, only life to live wandering around time, there is a lot of fun but there is a place where how warm Natsume boy contacts her is the real pleasure. That kind of thing I could not bear with that kind of thing, but this work may have wanted to appeal what something to live by drawing Natsume and Yuko. As a result, Yukko will be the last to do without worrying about Natsume.

This work is a love story with a rather dark feeling in content, and finally it ends in the shocking form of Yuuko's death due to the death, but overall I think that it is well completed as a story, so evaluation is good]. It is a boys' man who is mainly composed of happy endings, the way of finishing like this work may have been a bit heavy, but like a "crowned couple", youth is a difficult generation and the heart of people is complicated Perhaps I wanted to represent that.

2008/11/01 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 8858 Host:8682 Browser: 7345
I remember it as if it was quite fun reading at that time.
I thought from that time back, but the picture is still weak.

There are quite a few tense scenes, but I think that the picture of the hero managed to manage somehow. After childhood friend's child.
Well, it was good with the last.

2007/03/17 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 39980 Host:39986 Browser: 5237
Kim I did not know that my pacri is being told, but I thought that I am also like Kim, and thinking that I read it on a crowd, is it really the way to die like that at the end? Surprisingly I was surprised. Well Oh well on the whole.

2006/04/14 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 49951 Host:50069 Browser: 5234
I think that it was good overall but the scene where the last Yuko Takigawa dies will not be convinced personally. I received a feeling that made us die only to end the series, the aftertaste was bad. I feel like I did not have a scene to predict death.

2005/11/12 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 13007 Host:12898 Browser: 5234
The last scene that can not be thought of as a jump comic strikes the heart.
When thinking that it advances with love comede development, it was pretty heavy that the heroine chosen had death sickness ....

Yuuko's father also asked for this thing Natsume, but when that feeling arrived ....

Although it is said to be "Kimagure Orange Road" Pakuri, there is a feeling that this work later became a model of the scene where Yumeki of "Hell Teacher Nabe" will die. Even if I confessed to Professor Ritsuko, it is also a place to go to the source of the dying Yumeki even if confused.

However, there was no gratitude for Yukimi who will be revived afterwards (because it is a youkai?) So what is Yuuko's position like?

Nevertheless, this work also has a scene of Natsume and Yuuko approaching in a movie of parody of "Titanic" (described long before the movie) described at FJ magazine at the end of the bookbook, and the scene of my disappointment is in my mind .. I put on something and the last feeling has been destroyed ....

2005/11/12 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 18206 Host:18268 Browser: 4487
It is often said that "Pakuri of [Kimagure Orange Road]", etc., but this work is not a work never reaching fool. Perhaps it is said because of the triangular relationship of two pretty girls and a boy.

Yuuko of the so-called "Madoka" position is originally a high school third grader but, for reasons, it transfers to the hero who is a junior high school student. And the triangle relationship with Chisato of childhood friend which is "Hikaru" position began ... ....

Well [Kima Ole] may be a bit taste, but this work also has a good taste like a melancholy drifting away, and the last is a sad last that the heroine after the main character 's confession ... was.

Although it may be a small grain, it can be said that it is the fact that this sad and love triangle relation love manga is an interesting work.