Other media: Movie:WANTED
Comics total pnts rank Rank 583in 9,227 titlesTotal 20 / Deviation 54.63
Comics avg pnts Rank 454in 1,330 titlesAvg 1.33=Good/15 reviews
Comics rank of 1998 Rank 21in 198 titles
Statics of evaluation and Ranking
Reviews' statics
Post review by myself
Hot heart0%0/1
Shed tears0%0/1
Made me think0%0/1
Learned something0%0/1
Information about this title

Eiichiro Oda
Japan Released:1998/11
Recently views
  Limit by opinioin
Search in this page

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post your review to English version, please click here.
2015/08/23 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 10151 Host:10257 Browser: 9629
[good point]
You can see the origin of Professor Eiichiro Oda 's personality
Especially, directing in the showroom is fluffy
A piece of "one piece" template is good

[Bad point]
Initial reading, the picture is too young to read somewhat
Level to disappoint when reading the story expectation

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Mr. Oda was the one who writes a distinctive reaction ... It was an impression that ... it seemed to have been apparent from this time!
Surprised face and angry face thrust me

As the initial reading, the line is thin and the solid is lacking, the screen feels thin. Conversely, does that mean that they are progressing better? I think that it was the result of trial and error in that youth, I think that it was very good that it began to be thoughtful to make the lines of nearby objects thick, to give a realistic feeling

And the work which became the template of "One Piece" is completed, the drawing is completed and the screen is very bright. I feel youthfulness, momentum and refreshment, and I think that it got a good momentum toward serializing

Even outside the painting side, I stepped up making characters and making a story steadily, and at that time the boys were able to see many romans in the challenge of one immature comic artist Is it not? It is a precious work collection that you can see "The beginning of a dream story"!

2013/05/23 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 16452 Host:16518 Browser: 6173
It is a writer who can properly read stories of these short stories. It can be reconfirmed.
Everyone is conscious of the gimmicks and the fairytale, and I realized that Mr. Oda is a man with high manga power because of setting and talk making to be pulled in with force. The annual "Don!" Started from here

It is nice to have a secret story written on every episode, it is amazing that there is no talk of Hasure.

2011/07/28 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 1527 Host:1461 Browser: 2884
Thinking things throughout the whole thing is powerful because what I want to write is clear. But rough cutting.

I will not say it one by one because it is a short story from here.

It is fascinating funny. It is easy to read. But my impression does not come out. The content is simple, the battle scene is the main husband, but somehow it does not remain in the impression. I wonder why I am watching a great battle scene from this.

[Present of the future from God]
Extra in the middle, black glasses remained in the impression easily. I was worried about that. Well, well done, but the taste is unusual.

[Ichiya Night Bank]
"Why do you have a monster like you ... your teacher must be killed !!!" I agree with a bad meaning.
Reason why I did not understand after all.
There is neither depiction nor process to eat, why is the teacher who lost to such an enemy like such a trash?
There is no meaning that it is a necessity of being a buddy who does not need a friend of a teacher,
There is no scratch on the forehead, any meaning. If you are a swordsman or another you do not need to explain, but you are a shaved guy, you need explanation.
Honestly it is boring.

I do not really understand the world view.
And why is not King broken? And the dragon shadow is thin, I do not know the strength of Silano well.

It is the most interesting. There is personality in the most protagonist among the works until now. Even though it is from the last guy, the picture is the best and has its personality.
The only drawback is that there is no description of witchcraft.

Overall it's subtle, but ROMANCE DAWN was good and the evaluation is good.

2009/07/18 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 2289 Host:2107 Browser: 12063
Early work edited by Professor Eiichiro Oda. The natural nature of rough cutting and incomplete comes out as an advantage and makes me think that short editing should be such. I am confident of my excessive confidence in my work. Many cartoonists think that past works are embarrassing, but Mr. Oda is proud of masterpieces.

Title work. Hollywood western dramatic work correctly. In other words, there is no piece of delicacy and the story is appropriate, and I am committed to "attract" the screen. Only ghosts are casually and casually strange.

Present from God to the future How to put hints, how to roll the story is crowded. It is good as a cartoon. Is a promised boys' manga part of the humanity?

It is a Japanese style. The line was at the same level as WANTED!, But I was impressed with the noun theory of the author's comment.

Good foolishness of bad guys is good. Powerful spectacle has just jumped out of the page.

Romance Dawn
Prototype work of ONE PIECE. The painting style is good. A good example of a boy's manga which makes a boy absolutely think it is "Funny!" It may be the same opinion for those who draw.

2009/05/31 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 10695 Host:10688 Browser: 3876
Since I have been reading quite a bit since reading, I remember only fragmentary things.
[good point]
I was glad that I saw a piece other than One Piece.
Because it is a short story, Okuda who is able to simplify there and still shines gag is amazing though it can not be drawn finely.
The reading which I have read so far is a particularly interesting category.
What I like is a gift from God.
When an explosive was set up, when the guests were running fast, I got it when the uncle read a strange kimono with written letters.

[Bad point]

[Comprehensive evaluation]
It seems that the villain draws thoroughly as a villain from long ago.
Compared with now, it was good that there was no strange fairy tale character that I could not understand.

2008/10/13 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 29983 Host:29908 Browser: 8090
Mr. Oda's work was something I knew barely known as one piece, so it was fun to read a story set in various worlds.
There was not a single story that could be said to be a loser, and the place where the hint is stretched firmly from this time is also wonderful from this time.
Especially "Gifts from the future from the god" is a good excitement of the talk, full of the charm of "Aho-character" good by Professor Oda,
It is wonderful thing that made full use of pickpocket which is occupation of Blanc.
I also enjoyed the development that "Ronma who thought that there was no delicacy at first with laziness and" MONSTERS "was a nice person and the silano which looked like a good person was bad.
Since there are many developments of this kind of oversupply in one piece, it should be said that it seems to be Professor Oda.

The only difficulty is that the picture looks like a dragon ball.

2008/07/02 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 51291 Host:51358 Browser: 6395
Mr. Oda's short edition, but it was quite funny.
Just a goblin night was a subtle feeling.

Well the work itself was funny though. Professor Oda said it was a collection of masterpieces by himself, but it was about honest masterpieces ....
I think that one piece is a sufficient work to call it masterpiece enough.

2007/09/06 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 9818 Host:10088 Browser: 6520
I did not think that except for "Romance. Dawn" which became the prototype of the one piece so interesting.
Ruffy appears in Dawn somewhat differently, but I felt that the fact that I was a rubber person and where I can not swim with a dress, and that the basic setting was made from this time.

2007/07/23 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 42529 Host:42609 Browser: 6287
Since it is a short edit, the story is small compared to the one piece episode, but each episode is well organized and you can sense Mr. Oda's talent. The sense of tempo which is not much seen in the teacher's work now is It is nice to have it, because the page is limited (it can not write so many things) it is natural because it is a short story, but I like the one who is assassin this much

2007/06/21 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 2897 Host:2667 Browser: 4184
Mr. Oda's short editing.
It was a development that made everything cool and cool. Among them, romance dawn, which became the origin of "One Piece" which became a big hit later, was fun. The setting of Luffy is slightly different, but it became a rubber person together.
Anne who appeared in this manga would be a person who became a model of Nami of a later one piece. The nice personality is the same as Nami. Pirates on the enemy side also bring out the fun and disgustingness that leads to the many villains later.
I thought that this will lead to the early dress, I thought that this story was enjoyable.

Evaluation is "very good".

2007/06/20 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 25985 Host:25854 Browser: 4184
A prototype of one piece can be seen from various reading manga.
Various ideas and unique characters are attractive.
Before debut, the impact of Dragon Ball was big.

2006/07/31 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 32756 Host:32740 Browser: 2771(Mobile)
It is a short edition of Mr. Oda's past which is currently serialized by WJ. A total of 5 works are recorded.
I think that everything is more interesting than the level, but I especially like "gifts from the future for the future". I felt that the setting is unique if it were not able to read.
"Romance Dawn" is inevitable, but I feel that `betrayal 'in' MONSTERS 'is reflected in' ONE PIECE '.
It seems to be an early work, this book full of freshness. I think that "ONE PIECE" fans will probably read and not lose.

2006/04/14 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 28203 Host:28303 Browser: 4184
It was a short editing drawn before the one-piece series.
I have read this by chance that my family bought it.
Below, if you have comments for each episode.


Although the prize money was the main character, the Western play, it was a ghost gunner who took him,
It was quite funny character, such as challenging Osassu of the strongest winning prize money even though I did not want it. Although the important battle was surprisingly unexpected ... ... ...

"Future present from God"

It was God who tried to give the chance of conversion to the hero who had repeated pickpockets, but he was a good one. I wrote a notebook and a pen that happens to be written, I wrote a convenient future for myself, but it was delicious.

"Ikko Night"

Brother who became guru with the hero, brother who defeated the monster, naked eye suited you.


It was a silo that was standing in the city heroes, but it was a solder food. I was grateful with him
Three swordsmen also saw a strange appearance in the impression, it was my brother's father, but it seemed like Mr. Oda better or worse. (Bitter smile)

"Romance down"

It was a story that can be said to be the original form of a dress. Ruffy does not have a favorable impression now, but it was exhilarating to rub off the bad guys without using gums and objects with rubber body. Sacrificing subordinates, saying that the captain of the captain who tried to escape only himself brought out catharsis more.

Now, Mr. Oda, a signboard artist who is not pressed by a juvenile jump, was a short story that appeared in such a length, maybe it was better for him to draw manga of the middle part as well.
One piece is Gudaguda for the first time, and Dee Greyman and Hunter are only reading about maisono penguin in Matoo in the series which is closed for a long time ... ..............
About this, although it was not boring, but depictions of blatant villain characters,
Since the point that was stuck was also seen such as a bad point of a one-piece has already appeared, the evaluation is "ordinary".