[Comics]Ue Wo Muite Arukou

RSS
Comics total pnts rank Rank 6,693in 9,223 titlesTotal 0 / Deviation 48.62
Comics rank of 1997 Rank 150in 199 titles
Statics of evaluation and Ranking
Reviews' statics
Post review by myself
Poll
Information about this title

Toshiyuki Mutsu
Weekly Shonen Magazine
Koudansha
Japan Released:1997
9,55266
Recently views
1102216100
  Limit by opinioin
Search in this page

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post your review to English version, please click here.
2014/08/14 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 44839 Host:44799 Browser: 10465
[Good point] I liked this manga and I was watching from around the third baseball club

[Comprehensive evaluation]

2010/05/19 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 4053 Host:3958 Browser: 10714
It is a sequel to "prestigious! 3rd baseball club" with hot-blooded baseball manga of Mutsu Toshiyuki serialized in Weekly Shonen Magazine in 1997. "Uesugi Ring" of the student of 'Hinoki Asunaro' who was originally a professional baseball player who came from `Sakura High School 'had a genius of a rigid ball while roughing, but at university it was a role to try chores. However, Chiba Mullins Scout `God 'who noticed that he was sharpening his arm while shadowy bought his enthusiasm and nominated him in the lower rank. Uesugi's new baseball life, which became a professional baseball player, will begin.

This work, which was portrayed as a sequel to "prestigious! Third baseball club" that became a pillar of the magazine in the latter half of the 1980s and was awarded the unity, was positioned as a continuation of the same work 'Flying Hen' Contents is mainly the growth and activity of "Uesugi Ring", the team appearance characters including `Asunaro 'of the previous work collectively strike the owners conspiracy and fight against the conspiracy of the owner and compare with the story content, the tom down I can not deny the feeling. In addition, there is a feeling that the "Uesugi ring" of the hero is overly impudent, the impression is weak as the protagonist as compared with the previous work `Hinode Asunaro ', and because it was lacking in power, the hot fighting spirit that was in the previous work I was not able to convey the feeling that it was very sequential. In the previous work, 'Kuwamoto Satoshi' 'Kaido Takeshi' which was the main character after Asunaro appeared, but because of being turned to a companion role, there was not much powerful image of the previous work. Also, Kato general manager is gloomy only because it has a bad mouth, and even though it is not in the previous work, it is dirty itself to put out such a character. In the middle of this work, the mouse will run on the elbows of Uesugi, and it will turn into an expansion that will become a crisis that can not be thrown, but I do not know if the censoring is decided, but for that reason the development of the whole story It will be too steep.

Although this work depicts the growth of one pitcher in the setting made as the sequel of the previous work "prestigious! Third baseball club", because he could not pass on the heat and momentum of the previous work, it deteriorated the masterpiece I could not deny the feeling. However, it is made as a story for the time being, and the face is made as a sequel of the previous work, and the evaluation is [normal]. Lastly, he played major in the major, came back to Mullins again and it was nice to conclude with Mr. Kuwagoto again with his colleagues to rebuild Mullins, but because the previous work was great, there was a bad work Was not it.

2009/05/18 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 52462 Host:52618 Browser: 5600
What made the content of the work "sequel to the prestigious! Third baseball club".
I think this is the biggest failure made by the author.

The story is a student of Asukaro Sakura who is a director of Asaka High School, starting with Mullins joining Uesugi Ring,
Just as As Narro turned the owner to the enemy and pulled out the pennant race,
It was the content that the rings who turned the general manager to the enemy fight the pennant race.

Synchronization of the first draft is not being mastered professional pitching technique and the rings show off the professional pitching technique beside being hammered into the Kaido,
The process of flowering the flower talent little by little was polite and readable enough.

However, since the advent of general manager, the race leaves the ball field due to the mouse which occurred at the joint of the elbow, treated in the United States, recurred in the major spheres,
Progress of the story until generalizing as a closer as advice of General Manager was a tremendous high pace.
It was enough to know immediately that the censoring was decided.

Because there are plenty of room for excuses on the author side, the evaluation is "ordinary".

2009/04/25 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 1957 Host:1629 Browser: 6653
[good point]
Although I understood only the appearance that the hero is working hard ...

[Bad point]
A story that can only be felt as a second-serving tea of 〓〓〓〓〓he previous work.
I do not have likable to the hero.
Contents of a story that can be thought of as a matter of course at the censure.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
It is not an exaggeration to say that the tea, the degraded version of the previous work's release.
I understand that the protagonist's pitcher is an effort, but he was not a person who likes himself because he is somewhat subservient and has a dark place.
Because the character of the previous work is also that sequel, so far it was not feeling that it was too much to use them by themselves,
There was also the character of the hero and there was only dark, heavy feeling overall in the work.
Although it seems that it was cut off in the end, it is natural, in this work that can only be felt like a gum with no taste.

2006/09/10 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 10008 Host:9888 Browser: 4184
It was a sequel to "The prestigious! Third baseball club". Pitcher raised by Asunaro Uesugi One unfortunately, Today B class is confirmed, Chiba Lotte is active in a model-like professional team. The spirit of self-sacrifice, the fundamental theme, there was no brand-new thing compared to the previous work, such as the presence of a mean-owner. The main character, Uesugi was a character lacking in fun, punch power was inadequate. It was good that the supporting role appeared in the previous work such as the sea route was showing active. ........

It seems that Uengusi ended up in the place where Uesugi damaged his shoulder like a master, and the author also ignored the existence of "Phantasmal Volume 4" at all, but it was regrettable that such halfway end way . Were you thinking that someday the 4th volume will be on sale? Were you supposed to be included in the final volume of the previous edition version? Well, should I say that I was okay?
Evaluation is "normal" as it was not possible to deny the sense of unsatisfactory compared with the previous work.

2006/09/09 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 17368 Host:17149 Browser: 4487
Although it is a work that is positioned as a sequel to the [prestigious! 3rd baseball club], the hero could not possess himself in herself while having a privileged physique and talent, and furthermore the person could not rise to the front stage for good Uesugi. He is from that high cherry blossom age and his teacher is Asunaro that cypress. Although the evaluation from Asunaro was rather high in terms of capabilities, although he showed a glimpse of the talent hidden at the end of the high school days when he was on the bench as a player who is also a part-time staff member as described above, It was said that the surroundings did not follow, but also because of his personality as a university era, he was still in a substitute until the last minute. However, there are still people who understand his talent, so he will join Mullins who has played his teacher Asuna ....

Although Asunaro and Kuwama are appearing in the characters of the previous work, Uesugi had nothing to do with the impression of punch power anyhow, and there was something that made me feel somewhere frustrating as well. Although it is clumsy as a human being, it is not killing that it is sincere.

It seemed impossible to exceed the previous work as before, although it was a bonus that the last round and the previous round were not recorded after ending with a book volume of three volumes, but the book version of the book version [prestige version] It seemed like I saw the sunny day at sunset. Uesugi was an active player in the major.

There was also reasonable handiness of this work, and how to draw the secret talent of Uesugi was never bad, though ....




↑Top