• Cute
  • Enjoyed
Comics total pnts rank Rank 8,293in 8,983 titlesTotal -3 / Deviation 47.71
Comics rank of 2008 Rank 244in 277 titles
Statics of evaluation and Ranking
Reviews' statics
Post review by myself
Hot heart0%0/2
Shed tears0%0/2
Made me think0%0/2
Learned something0%0/2
Information about this title

Japan Released:2008/09 Monthly Shonen Rival / End:2010/10
Official sites
1. http://kc.kodansha.co.jp/content/top.php/1000004556 (Translation)
Recently views
  Limit by opinioin
Search in this page

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post your review to English version, please click here.
2016/01/02 Very Bad(-2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 13195 Host:13242 Browser: 5171
[good point]
The picture is grasping the characteristics of cute characters

[Bad point]
Deviation from setting and directing as an imagination

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Although Xenogrania is being beaten, this is popular.
It was completely boring.

2015/06/04 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 26728 Host:26815 Browser: 5171
Commitment to Imasu SP, with No High School Student P as the main character.

Comikalize is one of the many worldwide lines that there are a lot of P's that you know, but among them it is the one that uniquely exposes.
Depending on the age group of the publication magazine, as mentioned above, the hero is young. I wonder if I can sympathize as much as I can with the fans who are struggling to produce unfamiliar with the youthfulness like high school students.
Seriousness of confrontation with 961 pro after 2 volumes was added and the reason for transferring Miki became better than the original, but the one in which P and Idle live under one roof is not Scan Dallas ?

I do not even mention anyone 's explanation rather than explaining about the "large debts that the president held," which Yutaro had done for P ....
If it does it favorably, is it the kindness of being idols?

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Often this cartoon is ridiculed as "extra drama CD extra", but it is also a convincing piece.
It is not a recommendable one for P who has a feeling of idleness.

2012/12/02 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 6708 Host:6718 Browser: 11859
[good point]
Pictures and character illustrations are beautiful

Character of the character

[Bad point]
There seems to be a little less to draw a subtle developing developing hero ...

The setting of the hero feels a little unreasonable

[Comprehensive evaluation]
The result is not good, but the main character with good or bad passion for idol is suddenly to serve as a producer.
Both the hero and the author are feelings like rough stones, although there are a few difficulties, it is a work that you want to support including it.

2012/04/04 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 15458 Host:15408 Browser: 7541
I am not playing the game version, but it is interesting as a cartoon deepening the bond between the hero and the idols.
The picture is also beautiful, and he seems to be able to enjoy it normally if it is unexpected.

It is Yuutaro Takagi of the hero, but he is a hero growing, so it may be different from the producer of the animation indeed.
Pros and cons are sometimes divided depending on whether a new young and growth type main character appears like Mashiro in "Manga version Mai - Yume HiME" or Shinrojiro in "Sakura Taisen V", this is one such piece.
It's just a love comedy, but if you look at it this way it's easier to understand the characters than animation, you will also know the name of the idol (you seem to be decreasing).
The work called idolmaster is for cartoons and games, and maybe it is not much to see with animation.

Well, indeed the content is somewhat unsatisfactory for this volume.
I put it together quickly, but at least if I have one further volume, it may have been a bit more interesting.