[Comics]Space Battleship Yamato (Akira Hio)

RSS
Other media: Anime:Space Battleship Yamato Movie / Game:Space Battleship Yamato (Space Cruiser Yamato / Uchu Senkan Yamato) / Literature:Uchuu Senkan Yamato(Ishizu Arashi version) / JP movie:SPACE BATTLESHIP YAMATO
Comics total pnts rank Rank 4,164in 9,006 titlesTotal 1 / Deviation 48.90
Comics rank of 2005 Rank 213in 368 titles
Statics of evaluation and Ranking
Reviews' statics
Post review by myself
Character/Setting1.00(Good)1
Picture1.00(Good)1
Story1.00(Good)1
Hot heart100%1/1
Shocked100%1/1
Cool100%1/1
Sexy0%0/1
Cute0%0/1
Brave0%0/1
Shed tears0%0/1
Sad0%0/1
Beautiful0%0/1
Romantic0%0/1
Moral0%0/1
Scareful0%0/1
Friendship0%0/1
Made me think0%0/1
Enjoyed0%0/1
Learned something0%0/1
Impressed0%0/1
Interesting0%0/1
Funny0%0/1
Poll
Information about this title

Reiji Matsumoto
Akira Hio
Asahisonorama MEDIA FACTORY,INC.
Japan Released:2005/02
10,74565
Recently views
1131012140
  Limit by opinioin
Search in this page

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post your review to English version, please click here.
2016/03/20 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 11329 Host:11546 Browser: 7874
Here's Yamato ... There are memories that I touched first from the artist's name recognition as Yamato.

[good point]

In the design and character peculiar to the author, there are many battle depictions much more than Matsumoto version.

Despite being drawn in the project, eventually you can notice the penetration of Gamiras soldiers from a drill missile that was submerged on television, and toko who can bring Yamato into a dangerous situation as Gamirasu soldier Irose comes out.

The fleet warfare not drawn much in the original, rich depiction such as gun battle and amusement are higher than Matsumoto version.

[Bad point]

In the picture of the author, there is no force of captain Okita somehow, snow does not feel beautiful, and it is a entertainment drama too, it feels like a deep theme or story in the original is being mocked. There is no choice but to say that such a point is inferior to the authors version, and there is not the impression of the last.

[Comprehensive evaluation]

How Yuka, now I say "2199" may be the originator of "2199". Matsumoto color was abolished and it looks like original original ... but in 2199 too battle scenes are flashy, the deep theme that was in the old work, the depiction of the human drama is light taste, leave an impression in the character modeling Because I feel strongly, in that sense it may be 2199 〓〓〓〓〓〓〓〓〓

Even though the 2199 succeeds to a certain extent as entertainment, it does not deny the feeling that it does not reach the old work regarding the impression and the theme of the important thing, and also I feel that it is the same as 2199 in that sense as well.

However, it was not as bad as I felt as severe as 2199.

2007/09/20 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 47208 Host:47231 Browser: 8090
I could not have drawn Yamato's painting, but unlike anime it's a flashy battle fight anyway !!!!
The Gamirasu army who attacks Yamato with overwhelming amount of material also had a force that was not sticking to the strategy of the smallest player It is impossible to overlook that there is a unique episode such as a coup raise even inside Gamirasu Unprotected Gamirasu Ancient to mercilessly bomb the city The feminine part shouting "love" was a really manly character with no fragments. However, captain Okita who is like a girls' cartoon style (slender and tall and eyes sparkling) was creepy ...

Evaluation is "good"

2006/06/03 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 47133 Host:47311 Browser: 6885
The original atmosphere is different in places where the main story changes while the story changes. Anime It is one of the tie-up works. In a sense, it is not a proper work if it is considered as a komekalize for children.
There are many depictions of vertical lines on the face of the character and it is striking that her complexion seems to be badly odd.

2004/12/19 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 31094 Host:30876 Browser: 3875
It was a pity that I was going to be postponed at "Media Factory", but it was postponed.

Like the sweet potatoes, the "Space Battleship Yamato" characterized by a round and thick fatty Yamato picture,
Since we talked in short, the deployment is fast, it feels like a digest version.
There are many rough places, so there are plenty of tsukkomi.
If you enjoy such a "naughty" story, this one is funny.

Ancient older brother "Moriguchi" hides the identity and appeared as "Captain Herlock"
The name of the rival enemy is "Romeru"
Some of the initial settings still remain, so you can enjoy this part as well.

Since "Farewell Space Battleship Yamato" comes after, it is almost the same as a movie story,
Since it was just a digest version, funness decreased by half,
Regrettably it is a painting of Mecha that the copy of the same picture which another person wrote has become many.

I completely forgot that it was up to "Space Battleship Yamato New Departure" and "Space Battleship Yamato Complete Edition".
It seems that there was not any special suicide of Iskandar Dal 's suicide bombing at "Space Battleship Yamato" or "Farewell Space Battleship Yamato", but this will be inconceivable.
It would not have thought that it would definitely draw a sequel at that time.

2004/12/19 Not favorite comment [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 30606 Host:30421 Browser: 3845
After all Yamato is not Mr. Matsumoto Zero. Pictures and atmosphere.
But I also felt that the story was more detailed by the Hippo version.

2004/12/19 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 19247 Host:19009 Browser: 5623
By chance, recently I was pressed from a colleague of the company, so I read it ... .. I was troubled.
I can not help memorizing the Matsumoto Zero Edition version, is it for low age group?
Okita died pretty quickly, and there is no excitement like the TV version last. It will not die with a Cosmo cleaner. There is no scene corresponding to the scene where the last, Yamato returns to the earth and the earth turns from red to blue. To be honest, I could not think it was a work that I carefully look at now.

So, my colleague gave me three volumes of "Farewell" .... Uu, did you read it ... .. ..




↑Top