[Comics]Nausicaa Of The Valley Of The Wind

  • Made me think
  • Impressed
  • Interesting
  • Sad
  • Beautiful
Other media: Anime:Nausicaa Of The Valley Of The Wind
Comics total pnts rank Rank 37in 8,984 titlesTotal 182 / Deviation 102.93
Comics avg pnts Rank 61in 1,319 titlesAvg 2.25=Very good/81 reviews
Comics rank of 1982 Rank 1in 69 titles
Statics of evaluation and Ranking
Reviews' statics
Post review by myself
Story2.38(Very good)26
Character/Setting2.19(Very good)26
Picture2.04(Very good)26
Made me think92%24/26
Learned something35%9/26
Shed tears15%4/26
Hot heart0%0/26
Information about this title

Hayao Miyazaki
Monthly Animage
Japan Released:1982 / End:1994
Recently views
  Limit by opinioin
Search in this page
2005/11/25 Best(+3 pnt) [Edit/Delete/Suggest to delete/Show only this review or post sympathy comment/]
by (Skip) Review history[Good:26(63%) Normal:10(24%) Bad:5(12%)] / Provider: 2388 Host:2362 Browser: 10508
I think this is one of the masterpiece in Japanese comics history.
Though this work got famous through the movie, the quality of comics is much higher than movie.
The world was drawed with good details and the world was quite big.
And the environment and ultimate weapons had big meaning in the real world, too, due to the cold war.
So the storyline matched quite well to the era.
Though final chapter was drawed too late after the blank, it wasn't so good, but I can give best to this work though the end is not so good.
In that meaning, this is a quite rare work.
I think this is the best work of Hayao Miyazaki.
Actually, this works made Japanese people know how far we can go with comics and anime.

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post your review to English version, please click here.
2016/12/04 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 21644 Host:21845 Browser: 8282
〓〓〓Please be careful because it contains spoiler

[good point]
Kushana and Crotto are portrayed in more detail than the movie, making it a more tasteful character.
Nausicaa 's view of the world is explained in detail (whether each person likes its world view or not)

[Bad point]
People I meet Adult worship Nausicaa like a god, becoming more specific than movies.
A strong view of religion.

Nausicaa is extremely short-circuited, I believe my thought stubbornly and I am running and I can not sympathize.
〓〓〓Have a different sense of value from life for life (or possess a mystery)
I firmly dislike bugs and insects as being dirty.
Unlike in the movie, not because the father was killed but rather crowded by being crawled by a dirty bug,
Killing the Tolmekian soldiers (also enjoying it).
I do not know how to compromise about it and become a saint who respects life 〓〓〓Always fighting the foolishness of people and living things, wandering around the battlefield and deciding the destiny of the world by believing one's own judgment.

Anyhow Nausicaa has no human attraction. There is only body.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Although the movie was a bug and a feeling of Princess Nausicaa,
Manga is stupid, pathetic creatures and absolute justice Nausicaa feeling.

The picture is like a still picture or a picture book rather than a cartoon because of its precision.

It makes me feel like I read a deep thing due to a series of bloody scenes and an elusive long text.
Although there would have been no one to lift unless it was done by animation.
I think that it is good for those who want to analyze Miyazaki.

I like the movie Nausicaa, but I dislike manga Nausicaa in the world that was used for the author's argument.
I did not want to meet really because I liked Nausicaa.
At the worst.

2015/09/21 Very Bad(-2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 19178 Host:19261 Browser: 9155
[Good point] In a sense, Hayao Miyazaki purity may be that Kore is the highest ...

[Bad point] I dislike the development in the second half, especially the final stage, in the first half. As the gigantic soldiers call Nausicaa the mother, as soon as the rotting sea is gone, human race is gone, and the outcome is too dark and too heavy. As the story progresses, the picture becomes dark and dark ...

[Comprehensive evaluation] Because the salvation is done too much in the conclusion, evaluation is very bad.

2015/08/16 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 11453 Host:11360 Browser: 9330
This manga is a masterpiece I want you to look at with Miyazaki Hayao's idea disgusted at all.
Of course, the technique as a cartoon is wonderful. Expression power is already artistic.

This cartoon is not a thing to read in consideration of a strange political message.
If you see too much detail, you will lose track of the whole thing.
Although it is a difficult story, it may not be difficult to read.

Of course, it is made up of a precise world view, but how bad people, the country, everything, it is not depicted quite negatively.
Misery of war and stupidity of human beings are painfully expressed, but rather than denying themselves in a straight-forward manner, such creatures are both human beings and human beings are human beings, even though how stupid they are There is an image like a human praises like, there is.
No matter how desperate it is, I would like to have hope in both human beings and the world.

I think there are various interpretations depending on the reader, but I have not met such awesome cartoons since then, including including being beautifully completed.
Do not think hard, I'd like you to read it once.

2014/12/19 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 6357 Host:6325 Browser: 7872
〓〓〓br> A picture that imagines the picture as a painting with a picture as a picture ... It is a work that is reminiscent of the preciousness, the greatness of talent that can be realized, how great it is, how impressive it is, and overwhelming works.

The story tail is not good at all, and it is not my taste to draw narration and people,
I want to admire praise to the knowledge, painting power and understanding of the author who created a work named Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind.

Ms. Hayao Miyazaki was forced to change the idea of 〓〓〓〓〓hat kind of writer is. Well it is amazing.

However, it is incomprehensible of the stomach to deny "Evangelion" by drawing this.
What you are doing is pretty close.
I guess Miyazaki was probably because she saw her work and her work with Anno Hideaki and his work.

2014/04/06 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 834 Host:568 Browser: 10396
Especially a character likes a picture Anyway Kyusha is a bad guy even if it is a movie, especially though it is a cartoon but I thought of his subordinates when I was a manga I was amazed at a good guy.
I thought that there was only a movie, so I got completely into the movie before I understood various secrets.
Personally, I felt that the movie respects nature and manga respects freedom.

2013/10/22 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 15030 Host:15288 Browser: 11728
Well, I bother with my head how I evaluated this work.

I could not understand what I wanted to say after all although there was such a deep thing as singing foolishness of man and wonderfulness of nature and it seemed that it was difficult to understand the story line as a whole because it was blurred.
Even though I tried to Nausicaa, I do not think her behavior is always right.
I feel that desire to suicide by emptiness or despair is big. She may not be deciding her own heart.
In that case Kushana and Crotto were still likable.

The story depicts Nausicaa sailing from the valley of the wind and drawing until the king falls at Schwarz which is the final destination of Torumekia, it is a story-like short time.
However, there is a point that it does not understand such as the battle situation and the position relation of major people.
Especially, the last person has received it as an expansive development as a butt bud.
Because of that, I felt like the maps. Time, human, stories, etc. were totally overlooked and blurred.
Surely, in Mr. Miyazaki's head there is a magnificent story being developed, but as a person who is reading, there was no particular impression.
No matter how much awesome work I think it will be meaningless unless it is conveyed to the reader.

However, if I say it, I think that this world is very interesting.
It is a very interesting world such as the royal giants and giant soldiers, and the valley of the coral and the wind.
Miyazaki's head in the arky garden (slightly smeared but ...) I thought that this work is a bit peeked in?

Also, the interesting thing is the technical aspect of the picture.
Currently, unlike common manga, I think that comic strips are fine, and the picture is also scenery and interesting.
As expected it should be said that it is an animator, but it seemed to be watching a movie.
Although the picture is fine and not good, it is warm and very easy to see.
Even if it is a tone, the color of clothes is not necessarily this tone, is it also the balance of light and darkness,
The way of describing was very nice.

Although I am not impressed very much, I think that I would like to read back and reread from anything that it is never a bad work.
Every time I read it, I feel like I will take a step back to the world of Mr. Miyazaki.

2012/09/09 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 5871 Host:5882 Browser: 5139
[good point]
Miyazaki Hayao 's overwhelming imagination and expression power setting strange realism

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Feeling like a scripture predicting the future

2012/08/31 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 823 Host:734 Browser: 5345
A cartoon that I want to keep a cartoon mania as well as a movie Nausicaa obviously.
A masterpiece that can be understood by young people or boys.

[good point]
You can evaluate the message quality of a young man - made author and the unique style of a work. It also depicts the interests of war and the problems in modern times.
Adventurous spirit that can be understood even by boys who did not have a sense of throbbing feeling when reading at elementary school age, can also evaluate the setting that attracts.

[important point]
Picture. I like myself. It seems to be accepting everyone unexpectedly, but some people are useless.
Deployment is magnificent, but the director is a bit different from general manga. Maybe it seems pretty light as you see it in flow.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
At the highest.
People say that the movie version is better also watch the tila hora. Personally, it would be amazing if I made a cartoon version into a movie. More than a trilogy.

Below, simple impressions.
It is interesting to compare the beginning because there are many parts that follow the movie.
Attached strategy map.The world map is also intrigued.
Hydra was terribly scary. Maybe because of the size close to a person I was scared more than the gigantic soldier, came out in my dream when I was a child.
The most rereading thing is the 3 - way battle capture game. It was a powerful scene that is using the cavalry fight well in the world where there is a gun.

It is simply amazing that coming out of the movie such as the Uniform Guerrilla Union and slime mold weapons and graveyards come out.
The message has something in a way that leads to the backing of Panzerd Raccoon (it can not be written) and is easy to think.
I think that votes depends on people.
Kushana and others are several times more funny and more interesting.
Besides, it is better to draw countries and people as well. Religious, way of living. So I wonder if stories and messages will live.

There are many surprises because you are watching the movie version. People who are not seeing please come.
I think that it is also a work that can be felt with a picture. I wonder if it is good to touch childhood.
It is interesting to see the consideration of the Internet from youth manga. Because you can see papers and so on.

2012/08/26 Very Bad(-2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 16716 Host:16716 Browser: 4894
[Comprehensive evaluation]
Although I dare not talk much, in other words, such as "Epology of ecological style that leaves nothing when removing justice sense". Although I read expecting that it is different from the animation version and the ending, I wasteful in terms of honesty tactics theory economics. Well after all it is because it is after I saw 'Avatar' after all. Eventually Avatar is "like Nausicaa in Hollywood movie" It is like thing, more powerful than Nausicaa, and there is not much wasted part so much that the evaluation falls as this one more. Content and the world view are the same as animation. Therefore overall evaluation is "very bad".

2012/05/15 Favorite comment [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 30092 Host:30133 Browser: 7460
[good point]
Anyway it was good.
I do not want to write the contents so omit it.

[Bad point]
To put it this way, it is interesting that Madamen who was influenced by Miyazaki Hayao when drawing this manga is contents.
Just this cartoon is the charm of each person's character.
The power of the gigantic soldiers and the royal muscles is above the creatures of Mad Men.
Unlike animation, it is not in color.
There is a doubt in the way of the end.
Manga 〓〓〓animation 〓〓〓Ohmi Shinrikyo uses animated version Nausicaa 〓〓〓Is it a cartoon?
[Comprehensive evaluation]

Because I read from manga, I was able to read while throbbing without knowing what it would be like in the future.
It is unknown whether to read cartoons or to see animation, or to read cartoons after watching anime.
It is certain that animation can be enjoyed even if you read comics for the time being.

2012/04/10 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 12297 Host:12369 Browser: 7453
[good point]
It is completely different from movies. Probably not like anyone like "What is it like a movie?"
The depth and depth of the content that completely surpasses the movie is exactly overwhelming.
About life, to deeply think about death, about ecosystems, about people and science, ... and so on, a person who lives in modern society places a heavy proposition and thinks deeply.
"Is it a good thing to think about the world with only conflicts such as clouds and turbidity, good and evil?"
What you could not understand well in the movie is fully understood. The secret of the human race, the rotten sea, the giant soldier, and the Nausicaans are elucidated. This is exactly a surprise. Many people were surprised to see the branding of giant soldiers' teeth.
In the movie the depiction of the Torremequi side, which was easy to understand villain, is very polite. There are also complicated and political reasons over there, and you can see that they are acting.
It is not a happy ending but a painful ending part is realistic and very good.

[Bad point]
It is not a friendly entertainment cartoon.
Drawings are fine, lines are also many, it is difficult to read.
Story and setting the threshold is high. I think whether there is a person who is "difficult" or "I do not know" even for adults, but there is a depiction that can not be understood if there is no minimum knowledge such as nuclear power, environmental pollution, cloning technology. Even though I do not understand it, I think that "somewhat amazing" is understood, but it is better to have some basic knowledge.
Overall, it is not easy to read manga.
There is a person pretty that the last can not be convinced. As for me, I would like to agree with the decision of the hero.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Among all the works of Hayao Miyazaki including animation, it is the white eyebrow 's performance.
It is worthy of praise that under the "Shuna's journey" underlie the problem universally for modern society from the front and presenting the author's answer at this point. In "Princess Mononoke", he is a writer who has launched a simple message "living", but in fact this work also says the same thing. What this work exceeds "Mononoke" is that you can not live beautifully "raw" such as "live with a confusion and confusion", "to look at the evil or evil in yourself, still live" It is in firmly presenting it.
Never a happy future waiting for a bright future is not a happy ending, but even if we look at the history of human beings, there was a time when it was only lucky. As a masterpiece reminiscent of deep emotions to the reader, I hope that you will be forever read.

2012/03/10 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 15458 Host:15408 Browser: 7541
This manga does not feel like manga. Sometimes anime, feel like a novel occasionally.
The picture is very precise, already each frame is like an art, and the contents are many characters and plain battle as much as "no matter how bad manga it is here" ....
I think that it will be seen with a sense that it is "amazing", rather than "funny" until the setting comes to mind.
The setting is already too enormous, and it may take more than one month in only seven volumes if you read through while grasping everything.
However, I will also understand the theme of this work, and I also like Nausica's "gentle and noble" character.
Because it is a very rare type of heroine, in some sense the heroine which exceeds her is a cartoon world, it may not come to the animation circle.

2011/10/23 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 18633 Host:18454 Browser: 2619
[good point]
Nausicaa's character is slightly different compared to animation, the amount of information of the scene thinking that Jill is strict or saying weak sounds, and the character's energy comes out when fighting is something.
[Bad point]
Character difference is subtly different such as taking a hostage

[Comprehensive evaluation]

Even with animation 's climax in a series of turbulence two volumes yet. Afterwards also threatened by insects, raging in war and fulfilling meetings, thorough depth. The theme is too strong feeling.

2011/08/12 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 4586 Host:4829 Browser: 4894
Honestly I do not read children. Some people who are years old may find it difficult to understand.
Something is different from the comics around there.
Rather than entertaining us, drawing a way that puts emphasis on communicating the idea of 〓〓〓〓〓he author.
If you see his movie after understanding this story, you may be able to discover various things you have not noticed before.

It is natural because it is an artist who is admired by the public, but it has a very deep big idea,
Furthermore, I will highly appreciate about the point that it is not forcibly or forcibly punctured and is conveyed in the flow of the tale of the story neatly.
However, I felt that his idea, thought itself was quite biased.
I will not comment on anything about good or bad because there are a lot of people who agree with that, and the other way around.

Evaluation of this work is more than the theme itself It is in how to express Hayao Miyazaki, the author.
Please visit those who are interested in himself once.

2011/03/15 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 29328 Host:29361 Browser: 12803
[Good point] If you read this you can see that the writer Mr. Hayao Miyazaki is not a kind of writer who plays to everyone even in Meehae Anyhow good meaning Anyhow a meaning Any meaning It is trying to be a minor comic Throughout it too the origin of super- So it's funny for people despairing the world ...
Anyway it is a dark, modest comic, but the content is minority but it can not be crying Because this kind of thing is appreciated, I have not thrown away the world yet

[Bad point] can be a bit brighter ...

[Comprehensive evaluation] Do not decide this story only with animation. There are also different elements as origins It will be a good learning for creators trying to be conscious of major from the beginning

2010/09/13 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 48901 Host:48798 Browser: 3876
In masterpiece, manga I am NO1's work (tomorrow's joe line up). Because animation is Laputa, I am an enthusiastic fan of Miyazaki's director.

There are many things, but I want to narrow down to only one.

Originally this theme was the theme of symbiosis between nature and humans. However, it turned out to be a theme of "life is not before". Did it escape with Miyazaki's director's conclusion?

I do not think so. I think honestly the latter is more difficult. The former is more difficult if you expect a perfect response to convince all people. The former is more convincing than concrete measures. However, it is a world that was in the first place realistic. Because the ego position of each human being is the underlying problem, it will be enough to find a compromise and tighten it in the shape.

The latter should say Hayao Miyazaki's idea. Speaking of which one is convincing is the latter. But the latter will destroy all the high degree of perfection with this work if it becomes a personal impression. But since the latter is a thought, if Hayao Miyazaki is able to produce ideas of the level that is aligned with successive thinkers, that accomplishment is not in heaven. The problem is whether to do it.

I do not know? Just how hard are you who can pervert Nausicaa of Hayao Miyazaki and beat this last speech of Nausicaa straight from the corner. That is probably Hayao Miyazaki itself. At least I was pressed. Indeed it is decided NO if it can actually be confronted as my problem. Because I am weak. But Nausicaa is strong. So I can make that speech. 1 There is no need for the individual's sense of life to be consistent with the human sense of life. It was a dazzling word if it could think like this. I think there is an answer of Nausicaa's speech there. I can not agree, but there is a person I can convince if the character named Nausicaa speaks.

Because this is a story, it is not a reasoning problem, because it is a question of how the emotions of the viewer move.

Perhaps the placement of the persons in various positions of the Princess Mononoke thought that Miyazaki himself gave out residuals that did not fit himself, but when I looked at the conclusion, I could not bear to tell the story. That is also a story and director Miyazaki, so that's why I put out some words, Nausicaa is wonderful. I changed the story, but I am convinced myself because it is a question of whether it is ultimately possible as a story.

2010/06/06 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 26803 Host:26919 Browser: 7350
Since animation was wonderful, I read that I thought that the direction of cartoons would be pretty good.
There is a slight difficulty in the flow of the talk with animation, but there are some difficult things, but as well as its animation, it may be over anime, no.
After all, there is only the original of "Nausicaa", the view of the world and the story in general are wonderful.
When comparing the animation which is doing recently and the original manga, mostly animation is done better, cartoon is subtle, there are cases like like, but as in "Nausicaa", both animation and original cartoon A wonderful work is not something you can meet on your own recently.
And, although it is the evaluation of the essence ... Of course, as well as the animation version I will consider it as "the best."

2010/06/06 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 39626 Host:39596 Browser: 10692
This is amazing. A word of wonder is exhausted.
As a result of human exploitation as far as the end of the world, it is the end of the world as a result of retaliation from nature and walking through the process of extinction. This work depicting the adventure of Nausicaa daughter of the wind people who survive the harsh environment to coexist with nature, is attracted to the size of the scale and a deep story anyhow.
First of all, how to draw the power balance of the valley of the wind, petite, torumekia, and demon is precise and real.
Also, the theme of saying that excessive science does not make people happy is well drawn, and we are casting a single stone on the limitless human desire.
Although the character has a stereotype part that seems to be Miyazaki's work, each character is drawn individually and it is attractive as a villain.
As for the picture, I am painting this world without leaving it with a simple but firm brush.
It can be said that it is a classic masterpiece whenever you read it.
Evaluation is <highest>.

2010/06/01 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 12103 Host:12268 Browser: 6213
[good point]
Sorry Dear Sorry, I have not written anything else Honestly, the characters of Kushana are changing (unlike movies)
[Bad point]

[Comprehensive evaluation]


2010/05/27 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 26374 Host:26413 Browser: 9207
[good point]

[Bad point]
Maybe it's a bit difficult

[Comprehensive evaluation]
I was made to think very much.
I'm glad I bought it.

2010/02/28 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 18411 Host:18479 Browser: 5941
Nausika's conclusions and many others.
Nausicaa's ideal clean world was harmful as a price to acquire the physical body that can respond to the corrupt sea. Humans are informed to Hydra that when they die they bleed.
Once adapted to a corrupted sea, in order to respond to a clean world again, human beings will have difficulty maintaining life unless something artificially enters there.

The Lord of the tomb has the power to manipulate life, giving power of the tomb closer to immortality and death, creating powerful fighting weapons, and if it is seen from Nausica, it is a certain magical act to call it "a tyranny of life" Because it was because it was destroyed by Nausicaa,
As I said before, to grab the body that can adapt to the sea, the grave power is needed, perhaps like a grave to adapt to a clean world I need something artificial power.

Miyazaki also describes the limitations of dualism, but human beings are sometimes inviting themselves, which is uninteresting to humankind, as we try to enhance functionality and efficiency as long as we are human beings.
For example, it is not easy to produce nuclear weapons with the possibility of leading human race to destruction for the first time in weapons history as a result of continuing to develop weapons considering strategies to overcome other countries by waging a war because of its own economic development It is. It can be said to be one of the bad examples of human greed.

I think human desire is about the Lord of the grave. However, it is impossible to separate the ideal world of Nausicaa from the graveyard (= greed) as long as humans are human beings, even though humans can not hide themselves or become dirty by humans, coexistence of both I think that it is ideal.
The ideal world of Nausicaa is beautiful, it is a lively world where coexistence with nature has been fulfilled, and at the same time it is very weak and it is also a soft one that can not escape the collapse at the moment human activity enters, so all human beings are forest Nausicaa's hope will never come true unless you are a man of. No matter how wise he is.

If you turn on the TV now, eco points and eco car commercials will flow, and notes and toilet paper will also be recycled paper.
From global warming and environmental problems such as the ozone layer, to the ethnic problems of the Middle East In the midst of global problems worldwide, it was a work that made me think about what is real coexistence.
Personally I wanted to read about the story or sorry that I wanted a little more wind valley and Nausicaa, but I say that the evaluation is very good as it was readable

2009/12/08 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 12046 Host:12155 Browser: 14203
There is not much I want to talk about for a while, but this work gave me one answer I was looking for.

I always thought that human beings are disgusting creatures (honestly, I still think that it is a disgusting creature) but I can not tell people that I'm seriously thinking about such things I thought that no one would have an answer even if I told the person.

Miyazaki-san seemed to have shown one answer.
That phrase is "Life is a dark light in the dark" place.

People are not light, but if they can become light ... There was a desire to want it as light. However, Mr. Miyazaki seemed to be saying that "people are dark, and occasionally the light is brought down by people". I felt that the darkness is a person and that it is not a person without darkness.

But, after all I am seeking the light = person world. You probably want to believe that cleanliness is a person. I want to keep believing.

Well, in the end I know I can not grasp the truth, but I want to believe that I can grasp the truth It is false to have myself.

While I was thinking about this, I noticed that this work was eventually self-satisfied by Hayao Miyazaki. But it is probably for something to say to all those who watch "All your thoughts !!" .... There is no use.

However, when I look at such works after all, I think that I think that the work that comes to my mind is a thing in the world, and I want to search.

Was good.

- Overall rating -
For each person, I also have more to say to this work.
But the work that finds what you want to say is "the best", is not it?
I think that other movie work is also a long and deep work in Miyazaki-san, I am filled with the desire to have it as a book before my death.

Finally, I do not like the movie so much. I thought Nausicaa of the movie was subtle, but I was convinced that it was because it was a piece of manga.

2009/10/11 Favorite comment [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 5562 Host:5548 Browser: 3874
[good point]
Writing a corrupt sea well Nausicaa was not a representative of "human beings" but a dialogue with "graveyard" as a representative of "whole life" That the human ugliness and the beauty of life were written
Nausicaa's mental power is not perfect until the first half of volume 1 to 7 volume Kushana's character

[Bad point]
Episode, chiku, the main character that comes out of the presence of forest people is almost royalty

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Consider the bad points and let me put the highest ones

2009/08/09 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 40667 Host:40634 Browser: 4184
It was when I saw a movie (anime) that I first heard about Nausicaa. It was a terrible thing to say the impression at that time. After that, I learned that there was a cartoon version, bought it immediately and tried reading. At this time I am 14 years old. It was somewhat difficult to understand ourselves, but I could gradually understand it while reading many times.

Unlike animation cartoons, I think that a larger scale view of the world was out. The relationship between Nausicaa and Kushana, the appearance of people and mushi in forest, the death of Yupa, the seal of the graveyard ... I think that the world without being drawn in manga is spreading and it is a work that can be read quite freakly . As it was also in animation, it seems that natural love is probably written as an axis, but at the same time, I felt that I realized the important things in relationships such as friendship and love. I also like the picture of this manga. Somehow, feeling warm.

2009/05/04 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 3748 Host:3696 Browser: 7761
I finished reading Nausicaa of the Valley of the wind in the cartoon version the other day so I made comments on miscellaneous.

It is Nausicaa of the famous Valley of the Wind in animation, but few people have read manga version. Nausicaa of the Manga version of the manga version based on animation plot, Miyazaki Hayao was doing series for a long time with a lot of holidays in between, was written by one person, entertainment for everyone Animation I think that it can be said that Miyazaki Hayao's drawing was drawn in that the version was rebuilt again, various factors were added, and the closer customer layer completed the work as a core cartoon.
It seems to be high with a large book. In fact I think that there are many people who hate smoking but in reality it is almost the same price as a general boys' manga. Actually it is very cheap if you consider it from just the size. (Although it tells the paper quality and binding to that extent) There are not a large number of 7 volumes and functions, so anyone who is interested would like to have it hands by all means.

Thought cartoon
Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind has a funny feeling of what is called "manga". Because when I looked at it from the viewpoint of cartoonistic production and interestingness of Kohwari, I did not see much ingenuity and it was impressive with repeating similar things. Also, the picture is precise and has a lot of information to write but the amount of information is amazing but there is nothing to make it feel movement. It is an illustrationistic feeling.
In addition, it is sometimes felt as if development and production are suddenly deterred from emotional import into the situation and characters.

However, the way the pictures drawn precisely and the view of the world talked about everywhere are wonderfully set well. In each of these settings Hayao Miyazaki's thought of viewing people and the relationship between the world and people are included, and as we read through the story, we can touch nature. I felt that the development of the story was also part of the structure of Mr. Miyazaki's philosophy talking on the stage based on the philosophy.
I wonder if it can be said that it is a cartoon that sees the world rather than chasing away from these points. It is very similar to FFS as a manga to show in world setting.

Nausicaa is a special existence refusing the empathy of the hero. At the beginning of the story the sensation was sharp at the beginning and the degree of compassion was enough, but as the talk advanced and approaching the core, as well as the strength of will, ability to act, Is from Takami who transcended it by human beings. There is no individual will to feel there, as if it were a species, the manner of being depicted intentionally of the earth. This forces the reader to a third party perspective.
Nusika was originally inspired by Nausicaa at a fairly early stage as Kushana thought that it appeared as a pair of Nausicaa and antithesis. Besides this, various people appear, but they change from Nausicaa as a starting point. Nausicaa himself also grows and changes, but the gear-like element that turns a group image play is strong. Feeling that the author intentionally made such a structure.

Difference from animation It is good to say that while animation is sharing progress, characters, worldview, it is totally different thing. Anime is an entertainment that depicts a gentle girl who struggles to gather the situation firmly while being caught up in the battle but draws the situation but manga depicts the origins of the world, the will of the people and the will of the people who go there ing. The impression that I feel consciously stepping on the "rhyme" of animation is completely different.

Summary It is a stunning manga that expresses the theme of setting thoroughness and talk flow. However, there is a part to put on entertainment interesting. I think that it is interesting as a cartoon that reflected thought around the world view, so it is worth reading. Repeating affirmation and denial, while giving a range of judgment, how to summarize the story of wanting to live like him is brilliant. Moreover, it is advanced also to the animation version fan in that it draws deep Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind.

2009/05/02 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 2289 Host:2107 Browser: 8090
A story about a princess Nausicaa born in the Valley of the Frontier Wind, traveling seeking the secrets of the world covered with a corrupt sea. It seems that the value of this work on the theme of living in the ecosystem and in the hardship is increasing rather than declining over the years since the announcement.

Words of the work that you can go on the same road without becoming Nausicaa will also tell the reader.

Even the depiction of battle, ecology, wind and other landscapes is precise and spectacular. Pictures by unique touch also draw a line with other works.

The character is also a collection of habits, the bottom of the villain seems shallow, deep, deep, shallow and also interesting. The one I like most is Kushana, who loves soldiers while burning with revenge, but Nausicaa and Chalca, who are trying to keep on walking while aware of themselves as foolish, are also attractive.
It is a work that reads with various perspectives. Evaluation is "highest" in the content, but it is "very good" because it does not like pictures and frame divisions.

2009/03/21 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 23622 Host:23835 Browser: 9326
[good point]
Although it is a distorted view, first of all I feel worthwhile in the point of Miyazaki Hayao's manga work.
It is a very heavy story, it is not my favorite phrase, but I was made to think very much.
I think that the design of giant soldiers and Hydra with unique eeriness is one of the attractions of Hayao Miyazaki.

[Bad point]
Especially the early stage is hard to read, there are places where it is hard to swallow.
Grasping the geography and relationships between the countries was also a little hard for a foolish person.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
I could not bring myself to understand what Miyazaki Haya wanted to say, no matter how much I tried.
If there is meaning that I do not notice something more, the depth of the pocket which I think is attractive.
Just saying it seems like Takashina. It is a deep and difficult work than to say fun.
The movie made while painting this includes Laputa, but after that it is a courier service of the witch, Totoro of My Neighborhood,
It is bright and gentle atmosphere, so you can see how this cartoon was heavy for Miyazaki Hayao.
It may not be entertainment for all people, but I sometimes want to retrieve it and read it. I think that it is a work that you can associate for a very long time.

2009/02/16 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 10823 Host:10862 Browser: 8455
In the manga I touched, there is not anything to cross this work.
I just read it recently, but I am deeply grateful for meeting this work.
Nausicaa's story was completed in the movie in me, so when I learned that there was a continuation in the story I was very excited.
The content is more than expected, and it was drawn into the play in every single frame of a page, in a unique world view that could not be expressed in the movie, and it felt sorry for one line of sorrow.
The depth of the story seems to be tired at the end of the whole volume reading, and in the final volume, desperately desperate to fight with something like a frustration that you have to read about wanting to know the end, all 7 volumes I felt it very long.
Through this work, Mr. Hayao Miyazaki is a work that painfully conveyed what he wants to claim to the public (to readers).
Finally, I would like to once again thank you that I have met this work for over 25 years.

Evaluation is "highest".

2009/01/31 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 3196 Host:3180 Browser: 5234
[good point]
It was good that the preciousness of nature was conveyed! Also, it seemed like depicting coexistence between depiction and humanity and nature!
[Bad point]
There might be plenty of unknown meanings ... I am worried about the way Nausicaa of climax eventually ended up.
[Comprehensive evaluation]
Although I read the movie version a few days later, I read it a few days later, but I think that the scope of the movie version is just 2 volumes out of seven volumes of cartoon version ... I was surprised at this fact. (By the way, I read manga is a manga I bought while my mother was young.) The content is good, but if there are many unknown places ...
Well, for the time being "very good".

2009/01/24 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 27972 Host:28093 Browser: 8090
Works that I really want to read over and over again.

It was struck by this "revolution" caused by Nausicaa carrying the whole human race and was shocked.
I truly depicted the revolution from the start, and I was overwhelmed by the magnificence of the story.

Characters are also very attractive people, I do not get tired at all.

However, as Miyazaki himself says that he is not good at making manga, I think there are elements that are hard to read, such as pictures and tempos.
Moreover, I think that it is not a work that can read "I finished reading" once from the beginning to the end, I think that it is a work to read and understand many times.

Since I read comic books, such as the stories of Kushana and the stories of giant goddesses that were not movies, movies have become less satisfying.

I thought whether evaluation should be very good considering points that are difficult to read, but I will make it "best!" Again.
Those who like Miyazaki work or Nausicaa should not read it once but at least three times.