[Comics]Kamikaze Kaitou Jeanne

  • Beautiful
Other media: Anime:Divine Wind Thief Jeanne(Kamikaze Kaitou Jeanne) / Literature:Kamikaze Kaito Jeanne
Comics total pnts rank Rank 720in 8,998 titlesTotal 16 / Deviation 53.37
Comics avg pnts Rank 498in 1,320 titlesAvg 1.23=Good/13 reviews
Comics rank of 1998 Rank 26in 195 titles
Statics of evaluation and Ranking
Reviews' statics
Post review by myself
Hot heart33%1/3
Made me think33%1/3
Shed tears0%0/3
Learned something0%0/3
Information about this title

Tanemura Arina
Japan Released:1998 Ribon / End:2000
Recently views
  Limit by opinioin
Search in this page

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post your review to English version, please click here.
2016/02/06 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 3668 Host:3475 Browser: 5213
From the time I started writing here, the animated version was notoriously expensive (?),
I think the original is highly appreciated. However........

Well certainly there was a place that looked like Saint Tail. In the case of this manga,
Differentiation beyond that was done, such as recovering the power of God by getting rid of evil spirits possessed by art objects. However, I felt like it was not very compatible with the style.

Major appearance characters Ejin is big compared with that of the whole face, typical girls cartoon touch, beautiful beauty boy is usually cute and coolly drawn as good as it is good,
On the other hand it was not so much fear that the devil was transmitted. Masanori who was Jeanne,
In Sindhut, I could not describe why he did so (although it seems supplemented in this point also in this point), I also had a feeling that Tomo usually fell in love with, but on the stands it was somewhat garbled Although I was wondering if it was attached, if I speak of the devil, I liked my toy made by my father, but with my devil to my father ....... Impression of the story of punchy which became gentle with the activity of Jeanne Although it remained in the parents, if a parent touches such a way, it will always become a human being who asks the color of an adult's eyes and will it become so easy to get along with parents and children?

Well, although it is a stupid Tsukkomi, when I was talking about my father, I was not able to smile too much that it was a model that was deformed in my city as a police officer, while my father's heart was set up as a doctor, but my medical student Have you earned him within?
In spite of being unexpectedly I was able to appreciate my younger son and I was also young as a son who was despised by my son, but ... he was trying to bring him back a bit more aggressive
(I was letting the house suddenly invade), I wonder if he was going to be a loving affair that I want him to face more with him, and that he was a relatively interesting character. Although Mr. Kozaki Kosakuzaka of animation version seems to be different in image ......

Well it probably did not want to see aggressively the animated version as well !! Evaluation is "ordinary".

2015/05/03 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 687 Host:435 Browser: 5171
[Comprehensive evaluation]
It is a work dealing with so-called battle girls and magical girls, but the most notable thing is to incorporate the girl's "traumatic injury" there. In other words, it should be said that she painted a girl version "Eva".
There are many opinions that "Magna's personality suffers" and "There is no such a girl", but Moromon is not a wonderful person. No, Tanemura Arai himself will not even draw Magoro on a wonderful girl. She is desperately playing a "good child" while hiding self-centered parts that occasionally show. While being a high school student, parents live in different places and receive "neglect" which is high enough not to contact, while she is able to play "good child" to attract surrounding attention only. "Kaito Jeanne" was born as part of it.
In this era, songs such as Ayumi Hamasaki "A song for xx" (1998) and Chihiro Onitsuka "Moonlight" (2000) were born and became popular songs. They miss the "myself" in the same way as Magross, hence they must play "strong child" and "God's child". "Sailor Moon" who continued to orient strong girls supplemented their weakness, although girls' bonds supplemented their weaknesses, but the girls are already "damaged" like Shinji.
However, Mellow is different from Shinji to truly gain the circuit of growth. Mahoron was betrayed by fins and could not transform himself into Jeanne but encountered Jeanne who was time-slip and reborn, gets another transformation and relating to Kaoru to "If you do not forget purity, Jeanne You can transform into ". And enveloping the last enemy "myself", smile with "not alone". Surprisingly, even fins change from falling angels to quasi angels on the way. And I will defeat the demon king.
Compared with "Sailor Moon" which has a fate to keep fighting for the rest of the year, "Kamikaze Kaitou Jeanne" gains the way to realize the circuit of growth, and fulfills it until it is complete without comprehension compared to "Eva" which has not yet acquired growth. But the choice is in danger. In the world that completely defeated evil, is Momorrow growing further? Does it really heals the girl 's "traumatic injury" if he defeats the demon king?
As if criticizing this work, Mihono Fujii "GALS!" Which was serialized at the same time in Ribon did not put a weight on romantic love thoroughly, and advances the story centering on the mental trauma of the city. Reiko Momochi "Problem raising series" Yeah Baby Keiko "Life" started serialization at this time as well. The girls' cartoon starts to pursue the theme about the girl's "pain" in a modern society.
However, even though such points are excluded, the sharpness of "mental trauma" presented by "Kamikaze Kaitou Jeanne" does not fade away. "Jeanne" called for sympathy of girls, and it stopped to stop, not only the beauty of the painting. The girls were reading while sympathizing with themselves that they paint themselves the hardship to play "good girls". That is why "Jeanne" became a girl's manga that can still be told.

2013/09/14 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 1943 Host:1820 Browser: 5386
Compared to an animated version that failed, it is somewhat like a work called Mashi. (Still the same anime, is a work that is not accustomed to so much love.)

This work is a work like "Kaito Saint Tail" and "Pretty Soldier Sailor Moon", it is like a work that you split and added, no innovation is found in characters and settings, and contents of "Saint tail It is not like Kaito, but rather works similar to "Sailor Moon".

[good point]
Speaking of the merit that should be characterized in this work, the drawing (in particular the eyes) is strange, but the picture (especially the color illustration) itself is beautiful and the "Jeanne" drawn in color illustration has glamor, it can be said that this has boosted the popularity of the cartoon version. (At least, or from "Sailor Moon" is Eryoku is above.)
That I think good is that position.

[Bad point]
It was a work that I can not like much in animation, and this original version is not a better work than the animation, though it is somewhat better.

In this character's character, there is no character who liked himself well, especially "Kusakabe Mamoru" was disappointing because of poor personality.

As for the setting, there is no freshness just as a work that says "Saint Tail", and it seems better to say that it is a degraded copy of "Saint Tail" in content.
In the case of "Saint tail" about the motive of being kidnapped, Budami became "Saint tail" in order to save "stray lambs" troubled by bad guys being deceived or stolen items. In the case of this work, in the case of this work, whereas in the case of this work it is a gangster like "Rogin Kid" and "Robin Hood" in the content that it retrieves the item from a bad man and returns it to the lost lamb (the original owner) The devil that brings disaster mainly attaches to art objects, Jeanne sends a notice to seal the devil, Jeanne is the content to seal the devil, Jeanne is more like an exorcist than a thief There is also a development that battle with devils at times, so it is not a purely black-and-white thief, rather it is a person who told that it is a beautiful girl fighter-like work that adds element of demobilization to God and religion as a theme of "Sailor Moon" or good May not.

Jeanne, who is the figure after the transformation of "Hisashi Mashimoto", the hero, borrowed a name from "Jeanne d'Arc", the hairstyle is similar to "Tsukino Usagi", the hero of "Sailor Moon" Although the name uses the Western name "Jeanne", the costume is a character that combines only strange elements such as shrine maiden wear why, and from those who knew "Jeanne d'Arc" in detail, " I think that there are not a few people who thought that it was "What's this?", And in spite of being named a thief, the costume is too flashy to stand out and the sense of the author is not understood.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Despite this content, this original version got a reasonable hit, at that time Toei and Bandai, who were planning a new girls' animation to replace "Sailor Moon", turned their eyes to this work and animated them. However, in the animated version, the beauty of the picture which is the sale of the original disappears (Although Toei of the time was somewhat unfamiliar with digital production yet, the original picture was beautiful and it was broadcasted at the same time " Cardcaptor Sakura "and" Collector Yui "cell picture production compared to the drawing of the drawing, so the pain drops are conspicuous), it became degraded compared to the original version I could not get the support of the original work, it ended in failure.

There are many paculi works which are more severe than this work, but that is not so much as it is interesting content, and this original version is only a work hit in a bad sense.

2011/02/23 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 44387 Host:44297 Browser: 8416
[good point]
I did not make you cry, my parents came home.
I like the cover of 5 volumes. Ah it is nice to taste.
Door pictures are beautiful. The spread of "I am Windy" has an impact.
[Bad point]
Is not it a disadvantage to divide the race with Mr. Tamura's picture?
[Comprehensive evaluation]
Mahoron is an honor student, she is a girl who is also a cheerleader in the United States. The capital is a pretty child and I do not buy antipathy. It is delicious that it is seen to think that Maron and Mr. Aki "I always thought that I am next door".
I thought that 7 volumes were stuffed in a balanced way and it was just a professional job.
There are many things I thought as "___ ___ ___ 0 ___ ___ 0

2010/03/27 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 7552 Host:7605 Browser: 13276
[good point]
Girls definitely addict. It's cute and so cool. I do not have any clumsy ...
Originally, I thought that it was just a cartoon of a transformation thing, but it is deep inside.
It is a story to seal the devil, but it was fresh to go to steal paintings to seal.

[Bad point]
4 scenes example scenes. It is too shocking for children.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Jeanne is more interesting than gentatoru. After all the scenes of 4 volumes are useless ...
I think the 7th scene is still good. It looked beautiful.

I think that it is the most interesting work in the past Tomura work. Recommended for junior and senior high. I think that it is a work not suitable for elementary school students.

2009/02/28 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 12042 Host:11908 Browser: 6344
Although I liked the series at the beginning, I do not like it much as I read it now. I feel that it is overpopulated somehow.
Especially stuffing too much in the main character, if you do not do well, the best friend who is feeling in the Mary Sue state can still feel sympathy still Anyway the world is turning around Masaru who is the main character so it can be like her I think that I like or dislike this work.

I think this author is the only thing cute only

2009/01/28 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 11438 Host:11419 Browser: 3874
I thought it was the best masterpiece. I felt that deployment was too fast to say strongly. I might have wanted a showdown with Sindbat a bit more

2008/09/28 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 15921 Host:15842 Browser: 8090
[good point]
The most important thing is that the story is built in. From the beginning, the source of the talk has been firmly decided, and there is no unnaturalness even after it is overwhelmed. Well it seems that the elementary school students will get confused if they read it ... Also, the drawing power is wonderful. I am fond of you. I will catch on to the monologue. I was touched by tears. It was nice that the last was also a very convincing finish. I feel like that in 4 volumes ... but I think it was good to have a reason for 7 volumes and a happy feeling.

[Bad point]
It seems that you are not good at painting rippled characters and uncle characters.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
I think that it is very good. Kaito's style is well thought out. Especially I liked it is a monologue. I think that I picked up the place that seems to be misleading if it is another comic, and I think that it is expressing firmly.

2008/05/27 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 23597 Host:23360 Browser: 5234
Mahoron 's positive character was good.

But honestly, I think I should have serialized it in a different magazine.

2007/09/08 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 4237 Host:4057 Browser: 5234
For girls' cartoons, it is a work of choosing a viewer a bit.

Is it a disadvantage of this work that the content of the story will be unknown if it does not age as it is.
The painting is too rough and honest is hard to see.
You can withdraw the last seen in a promising development.
I pulled quite a few volumes and seven volumes.

This manga is a "bad" category for private evaluation.
I wanted you to think about the reader a little more.

2007/05/24 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 13064 Host:13290 Browser: 4487
It's truly likes and dislikes, but I liked it.
Certainly Mr. Tomura's picture was clumsy, but the picture is beautiful. It seems that there is not much time at the point of saying Kaito .... Even though it seems to be serious in the second half, I think that it was fun personally.

2007/05/24 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 34156 Host:34059 Browser: 4685(Mobile)
It is unnatural that it is not the main though it is attached to the title "Kaito".

Although the picture is big with eyes, it has a stupid feeling, but it fell in love with the tone sense (pasting too much) and the design of the clothes.

I got quite a bit on the 4 〓〓7 and 7 volume 〓〓〓〓〓scenes ....

2007/05/21 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 8516 Host:8589 Browser: 4928
Personally it was fun and some depiction of the final volume seems to be controversial, but I personally do not mind. The picture is clumsy but I think it is beautiful. Lastly it was married to Chiaki, Momorrow 's best friend and Suigetsu ?, and the kids thought that the fins and the accelerator got caught up. It was also fun to use the dragon's goddamper as an owner.