[Comics]Idol no Akahon

  • Cute
  • Enjoyed
  • Funny
Comics total pnts rank Rank 1,367in 8,980 titlesTotal 7 / Deviation 50.70
Comics avg pnts Rank 765in 1,318 titlesAvg 0.64=Good/11 reviews
Comics rank of 2006 Rank 68in 393 titles
Statics of evaluation and Ranking
Reviews' statics
Post review by myself
Hot heart0%0/3
Shed tears0%0/3
Made me think0%0/3
Learned something0%0/3
Information about this title

Tozen Ujiie
Japan Released:2006/06 Weekly Shonen Magazine / End:2006/11
Recently views
  Limit by opinioin
Search in this page

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post your review to English version, please click here.
2015/01/27 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 26629 Host:26386 Browser: 9931
Success depicting the process of three new idols who are supposed to be united from the miscarriage of the office, growing while being massaged by the rough waves of the entertainment world ... Is it a story ... or not?

[good point]
〓〓〓egular team that is too strong for Aku gathering at entertainment production "Ray Princess". Yuri who is responsible for arrogance irresponsibly and insidiously downward stuff Shiho who is the youngest person and has youngest and has a long career history Yuri who can also deal with dexterity deftly Yuri, sometimes glooming as a mass of professional gestures Karuna et al. As well as the staff of the president, manager, clerk clerk, since the character rises up to the supporting role such as seniors idol, you can enjoy even just watching the exchanges.
〓〓〓t is a good impression that I did not get derailed from the main part as "gag cartoon", because I usually attach punch line with lower netness even if we incorporate slightly sentimental scenes.

[Bad point]
〓〓〓lementary school students, junior high school students, high school students' ideas of "triple booking" are excellent, but it seemed unnecessary to have few stories and gags making full use of "generational shift".
〓〓〓quot;It was sold as a CD with a CD debut and made a song" 〓〓〓I finished with only a result report The last tasteful dry final ... How much is everything so smooth as it is?

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Although I was receiving high treatment for the first time on 14 pages, it became a short comic page of 6 pages as early as the third episode, and after that I feel sadness in the place where it was treated as a short stretch until the final round.
Although it seems that the author himself finished it on the grounds of "exhaustion of the material" on the grounds, it is exhausted as one word of "unnecessary" to let you realize the descent swing of the motivation as going to the final stage.

2013/02/15 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 14400 Host:14312 Browser: 6172
Creating a story centered on the idle of a three person startling

It is the idol unit of a woman threesome of elementary school student, junior high school student, high school student, and it is only in the work of the same author that the generations that are far away from this generation are aligned, it is the same as other works, of course, it is only the bottom neta Because there is a story of different age, its width is wide, yet lower neta manga with a sense of stability is unfolded as usual

It is fun as a fan to do the way to end with the same story of the same author 's "female college student tutor Hamanaka Ai" at the end of the book

2009/06/21 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 1957 Host:1629 Browser: 6653
[good point]
It feels as ever, but it was okay.

[Bad point]
There was a feeling that energy was exhausted (stinky) as soon as possible.

[Comprehensive evaluation]

Well, if it says that this work is also this person, it is there, but it was good as it was.
By saying the idol 's story, the setting felt a little fresh, although it was short, I could enjoy it as it was.

2008/06/22 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 51291 Host:51358 Browser: 6395
It was my usual manga, but it ended suddenly.
I was able to enjoy it so much while I was reading with just the bottom of the neta as usual.
However, none of this man 's manga changes almost. Well there might be attraction.

I was too short back shortly.
Although it seems that it ended with a piece of story, does not it think whether there is neta before the serialization?
Well, since my sister was in tandem with adolescence I guess.

2008/02/10 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 18003 Host:17822 Browser: 4749(Mobile)
After a while after the "Female college student tutor Hamanaka eye" ended, the series began with Maga week. However, it ends immediately. It is short and short as a complete book. In the final round comment at the last round of publication, "Are you going to finish because the material was broken" is nothing to be clever. It is wonderful, Mr. Tsuyoshi.
Such a work is the story of idol eggs (maybe chicks), but the group name is "Triple Booking" is amazing. It is a three person group born from mistakes of the office.
However, aside from the early stage, "explosive power" after the middle stage is not in this work. Was the compatibility between the material chosen as the stage and the author bad, did not it have room to extend?
Is this idle like this? I do not know the actual place well, but it is a good thing that I became interested in reading it even if I am not very interested in entertainment relations.
Although the talk was completed at the place where the CD was issued, it seems that people who seemed to be characters of the previous work appeared in the last round. At the end such directing is also nice.
Honestly I think that this work is inferior to "Hamanaka" as seen from me. However, it was fairly enjoyable and it is a work that can be read. Evaluation is "good".

2007/08/13 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 1942 Host:1857 Browser: 3875
It seems you did not have a wonderful idea if you thought you had this setting. But content

Although it was inferior to the previous work, I enjoyed it normally. It is totally fun if compared to the gag cartoon around here

I will.

2006/11/07 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 33146 Host:32904 Browser: 4928
Although I was watching the series from Hamanaka and adolescence like and so on, Hamanaka, adolescents are more interesting. I wonder if the characters in the past are better for characters. Well there is a place that can make you laugh too. I edited it on 25th October 2007 but when I read it in a secondhand book, poor development of the manager was fun and the characters were also quite funny.

2006/11/06 Very Bad(-2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 33223 Host:33285 Browser: 6287
The deployment that makes pretty girls do the shy simoneta as well as the previous work "Hamanaka Ai" does not change. I guess the author has only that.
In this time, I made three idol eggs trying to sell the leading role, but eventually it is not as long as the previous work ended. Whew.

Well, the picture is neither good nor bad, but Simoneta is impatient and I can not laugh.

2006/11/06 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 17368 Host:17149 Browser: 4487
It is this work that started as a short gag work that made the main characters of pretty girls mixed with Simonettes, but it is that I will conclude "Stuttering" and end the series. Should I say it is fresh, what should I say ....

This work is a character character of the hero who became an idol (the oldest oldest man who tries to make both school and entertainment activities compatible, the youngest of the artistic activities with the former child role and the daughter of the protagonist) Although there is a habit which is unique to the author, there was an impression that it was doing well well.

It was a work of the impression that I could read aloud and I felt sorry for the abrupt end.

2006/09/03 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 11009 Host:11078 Browser: 5234
As usual the picture and personality are not bad but I think that the material is absolutely ....
Even in the previous work, the evaluation was consistently "normal" and I think that I will neither rush nor fall again this time, so I will assume "normal" again.

2006/07/19 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 31346 Host:31593 Browser: 4184
After all, Mr. Tsuya's comics are interesting.
I hope that you will exceed the serial number of Bama Hanka.
My younger sister in the Yang magazine is under adolescence and double series, right?
Please do your best!!