[Comics]Ice Revolution

  • Cute
  • Friendship
Comics total pnts rank Rank 2,005in 9,015 titlesTotal 5 / Deviation 50.09
Comics rank of 2008 Rank 68in 277 titles
Statics of evaluation and Ranking
Reviews' statics
Post review by myself
Picture2.00(Very good)3
Hot heart33%1/3
Shed tears0%0/3
Made me think0%0/3
Learned something0%0/3
Information about this title

Japan Released:2008/11/04(Tue)
Official sites
1. http://jumpsq.shueisha.co.jp/contents/icerevolution/index.html (Translation)
Recently views
  Limit by opinioin
Search in this page

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post your review to English version, please click here.
2012/09/17 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 11904 Host:11717 Browser: 9930
It is a work that seems to be incompatible with published magazines as you see it ...
This is the word that came to my mind before I read through this work.

The content was the main character with a notch that was helped by Tachibana Kaoru where it seemed to be run over by the track.Masaki Osawa walked down the figure skating path.

Karate 's skill set aside for his father from an early age is a man' s fault, not being treated as a female at school,
You are going to chase after Sai and get a pair of shoes for men from Saigonji at skate rink etc.
Masaki's behavior is before men see figures, men themselves.

Such Masaki, who saw jumping high, suggests Mikasaki figure Miyazaki,
Seeing that Sai is sliding, you can grab a knack and use up to a double axel,
The thing which karate wears gets lively in the figure etc. It gradually blooms as a skater.

The source of the story is a straight ball game without tiny work, no fatal mistakes are seen,
You can also see traces of the efforts of the author who is trying to make Masaki 's initial ability higher and publish it to publication magazines and readers.

On the other hand, characters other than Osawa's father and girl are poor in acknowledgment, and people who can be called rivals were also close to friends rather than rivals,
It was easy to imagine that saying that it would not be possible to attract readers of the journal.

Therefore, the evaluation is "good" stop.

2010/11/28 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 4516 Host:4474 Browser: 4341
Is it regrettable that it ended in a short term (3 book volumes)?

The neighborhood where the heroine Makazaki who was brought up like a man in the same way as a man goes to the figure skating motivating the feeling corresponding to the year "I want to be a woman" and "I want to turn back to the boy I like" was a royal road Then,
You can also feel favorable how to watch Saire 's character rival and target as well as the surrounding adults.

On the other hand, there is also a feeling that there was not a poisonous character and that the deployment seemed to be running fast, slightly weakened the power as a manga.
The height of painting power is perfect, if you let me draw this content thoroughly in 4 volumes,
Or I think that it was better if you could incorporate the episode during the three-year consecutive consultation shown in the last into the story.
With "good" than "very good".

By the way, although the main characters were struggling to see the gender in reverse, also the reading edition of "Blizzard Axel" serialized by Shonen Sunday, is it that the figures and Karate really correspond with each other?

2010/04/11 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 10594 Host:10892 Browser: 10065
Speaking of skating, Maoto Asada who was parodied by Yatterman,
Kim. Jonah (she can not be said to be a victim of anti - Japanese education) is greatly excited, but his skill is high, his body is a woman, but the heart is a man and the hero who is a man, as well as Takahashi Daisuke kun The boyfriend who was a handsome,
Due to envy of other players, the accident happened, the relationship with the rival which somewhat have been twisted is well deepened and the appearance that the hero grows not only skating skill but also mentally is polite I think that it was drawn on. Coach's Saionji Temple was likable by a good leader even though it seemed unimpressed at first glance.

However, on the other hand, the hero who was suffering from inconsistency of sex and mind,
The shop manager of the beauty shop who visited on the way was actually a man, he was one of the characters who remained strongly impressed with him who was not the same person as if he was a bad Bari Bali, but sexual identity disorder (as if Haruna love as hero I think that it is abnormal to treat it as if it is abnormal) but it was a deduction factor that I was overconsciously aware of it more than I needed. Still unfortunately I could read it in the Jump Square series (which I purchased monthly for a certain globe bullet cartoon) which can not be said to be a high level, I think that the short term cease was unnecessary ... ... ....

Well the evaluation is "normal" slightly less than "good". It would have been said that it was a regret work that could clearly present a popular system rating if it was more balanced.

2010/01/02 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 12144 Host:12150 Browser: 6210
[good point]
The picture is very beautiful.
It depicts how to strive.

[Bad point]
The mindset of the hero's muscle strength is high ...

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Because I am not familiar with skating, it was a work that I learn while studying very fun.
It is drawn with very beautiful pictures and I think that it is easy to read.
I wanted to continue talking about more and more.
It will be discontinued ....

2009/05/29 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 34156 Host:34116 Browser: 2135(Mobile)
Because there are few manga that handled figures, I felt it was a challenge (In Shonen Magazine, other than Suzuki sensei 's Blizzard Axel)

But since the hero is a genius type that can do anything at all, there is not much tension.
Besides, I write emphasis on human relations rather than figures, but it is not very funny.

2009/03/07 Favorite comment [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 14213 Host:14070 Browser: 2906(Mobile)
It is an impression of a book.
[good point]
Overall, it is a good picture with high quality, good use of distortion such as deformed.
[Bad point]
There are rare places to feel like a picture you saw somewhere.
It is cartoon based on figure skating. Because the reason that the hero starts is the royal road, it is a feeling that it will start from the end at the end of one volume, so I can not evaluate the story yet. However, I think whether the picture can be evaluated very well. Speaking of greed, I thought it would be nice if I had basic figure knowledge of figure skating etc. besides character commentary.

2008/12/20 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 13991 Host:14004 Browser: 2999(Mobile)
I have never seen comic strips based on figure skating. I was addicted to it when I read it. The main character seemingly looks like a man and a woman. The story is also interesting.