[Comics]I'm A Faker
|Statics of evaluation and Ranking|
|Information about this title|
|Japan Released:2001 Weekly Shonen Jump / End:2001 |
- ▼Sorted by:Newness
2014/09/20 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by TCC (Skip) Provider: 7014 Host:6965 Browser: 7454
Although it seems that it was a series debut work of the author, it was the first impression that I picked up suddenly difficult subject such as basketball. (Note that I do not know "Kuroko no Basuke")
That is because there was a precedent (?) Of a super famous cartoon that was about the jumping golden age called slum dunk, but of course it is a professional and a student.It is a straight basketball that is different from a society person, and saying that it was really modern, mutual lies There was also a differentiated setting such as a chat which was talking while attaching.
They finally got a good impression in that they talked about each other's real things, got darkened strangely, did not leave a lump, but as a man in the inside it was a woman heroine-rank-neechan,
(I forgot the name) In order to return my friendhood called Mirok to the basketball club ......
Although it was the setting that it was setting, it may be that there was also a place where the other two were wielding halfway halfway.
And, although it was supposed to be the street basketball tournament, surely again, the growth of the main character such as supplementing missing height and skill with knowledge was also convincing. With encounter with Rin neechan. But the valve to Shimazaki who was a member of the basketball team was a bit talking about from the top? This shimazaki enemies the hero to Mye,
After all it was only a character for him. Although the picture was drawn as it was, it was impossible to convey impression and power.
Soon after the series ended, it was feeling that it was so weak with the selling point unique to this manga. Since the current author seems to be serializing pachinko comics, it is probably because it was said that it was okay, but I feel it was good even if I looked it up in the long term. Evaluation is "normal" on the "bad" side.
2009/11/18 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by 山口21号 (Skip) Provider: 19847 Host:19730 Browser: 6794(Mobile)
The picture is beautiful
The idea is interesting
There is no force
I am excited to read
In the basketball cartoon serialized by jumping pretty pictures are pretty.
Although it could read interesting as it is, it is painful that the game scene has no force and is not so exciting.
Evaluation is slightly sweet but I was able to read it funny so I usually stay close.
By the way, the author was an assistant at the place of Neuro after this series, "Since the picture is beautiful, was it okay for me to add the original and revenge?"
2008/10/13 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by 爆音 (Skip) Provider: 32756 Host:32663 Browser: 3028(Mobile)
When I read the first episode this comic can be expected .. I think that it is an incompetent work that ended before making basketball serious.
I feel that basketball has done well such as digging up three characters, so I wanted to continue a little more. I do not feel like I know people in chat than when I was in Sludang.
Even though it is a censoring end, it seems that it is a work that was wrapped up in its own way so evaluate "ordinary".
Whether it is a separate magazine or a magazine, it is a painful place to compare basketball manga with Suladan.
2008/07/07 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by 剣舞大使 (Skip) Provider: 18003 Host:17822 Browser: 2133(Mobile)
...... It is 3on 3's basketball cartoon that three people who got acquainted with chat or something unfold.
Well than to basketball,
Although the hero is not good at that, he lied about "I am a good basketball." Moreover, one of my teammates is expected so much. What shall I do now?
It seems that there were more scenes drawn about events. From this manga, "Lie, let's keep the frequency and the degree a little too."
I learned things.
But, I do not say that you should not tell a lie. There will be things that you will tell a lie to others.
"I will do my best to make the lie true."
I thought that it was probably Ali's hard work.
Moreover, although I should not like the story of this hand very much, I did not feel uncomfortable.
It is not only the hero who knows the lie as a lie, it may be because there are some others in familiar places.
No, I guess this lie was felt that it was not a big deal even though it was ballet.
It is also a good point to tell the truth from yourself to your teammates at the end.
At that time I was missed closing the series. I feel it.
The picture was clear and easy to see. This is pretty important. (It becomes less important if the contents are really interesting.)
2007/06/27 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by ためきち (Skip) Provider: 25985 Host:25854 Browser: 4184
Basketball cartoon with little basketball scene.
There are scenes that are playing basketball, but only about 20% of manga.
Most of the content of the story is only the unpleasant lie of the hero.
The story is indigestion, but the picture is also white.
2006/04/22 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by 武信君 (Skip) Provider: 137 Host:135 Browser: 4928
As seen in most sports works since Sludang,
Is it a work belonging to the former category out of the 2 patterns of "an unbelievable and boring work of the author" or "a work of impossible play such as" The Prince of Tennis "?
I can not feel personality in the work somehow .... I think that it was honest failure to set 3ON 3 setting. It is not a club activity, it is not a professional, after all it has become incomplete to call it purely as a sports manga by giving the reader a feeling that it is within the range of hobbies after all It becomes impossible to empathize a character It is painful not to get out.
If you are drawing as a club activity, the hero may not have been basketball an amateur and physique, so if you were drawing in the form of a challenge to talent it would have been possible to become a basketball eye shield 21 Hmm.
Actually, in the second half of this work, there was a character named Miroku, which is an idol of Eyeshield 21 ....
Evaluation is "Weekly Shonen Jump" drawn basketball manga in a certain sense, but after all compared with Suladan ........................ ....................................................... ....................................................... So, please .... ......................... At "Worst".
2006/04/22 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by スパン (Skip) Provider: 24887 Host:24893 Browser: 5234
It was a pretty work.
Thinking that it was 3on 3, I felt that it was closer to Harlem Beat than Slam Dunk, but it was quite plain.
In any case, the main character was a character that was pretty painful at the time that the hero had the most useless lie of "a powerful person who did not do anything" and (as long as it is the character of Sakuragi, the character of this hero It is painful too!), I was not able to see the "difference of the case" feeling when I first met a friend I met in a chat.
Also, I think that a special skill called "path talent" (?) By "excellent spatial grasping ability (may have been insight?)" Was discovered at the end of the work surely also for such a dummy protagonist, but this is what it is again. ...
Even at the level of "It has never been a game before," even if this is a "experienced" experience, it seems that it is a setting that has been used for a long time, After all of the week, "amateur" has such a talent, I can not dribble, shoot or defend anything besides the pass, even if it is just a half coat movement, but in addition to that it is a street basket that has few people and it is quite usable Well, I guess.
Even Sakuragi, which tends to be subject to criticism as "too talented", has been able to dribble and shoot in a row as a result of practicing so much, even though it is only three months, regardless of the rebound, Regarding defense and to say that the hair was grown to amateur until the end ... ...
Well, it seems that there were only choices for this setting in order to make use of literary system athletes (expressions that are pretty gentle), but that can not be done anyway.
If there are only options like this, I even think that it would be better for those who did not draw on such subjects.
Even if there is a possibility to make use of this subject matter, it is impossible to say that the load is too heavy with the competence of this author.
Although it was evaluation, when I began writing this comment I was thinking about making it "very bad", but as I wrote a comment, the dislike for this work gradually revived, so "worst" I would like to say that.
Even if I read it, it is super hardworking of only muzzkuku. It is better not to absolutely read.
2006/03/18 Very Bad(-2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by さば (Skip) Provider: 33834 Host:33768 Browser: 5234
Well ... the material is not bad ...
It is said that the story is lacking in excitement, it seems to be heard even in the memory stories of the hero who is the center of the story,
The feeling of 'listen'.
Impression that the realistic feeling has not been conveyed anyway and the raw materials are not taken advantage of.
If you like or dislike it is a favorite category,
I think that doujinshi level is a work that can not be ruled out.
2005/07/19 Normal comment [Original Japanese review]
by 羽幌炭鉱 (Skip) Provider: 25640 Host:25324 Browser: 4487
As I can not make a complete evaluation because I read only half (ie only 1 volume) I only comment on the impression I received.
Basketball manga that may have become a difficult genre in jump (it is the cause of [SLAMDUNK]), but this work is trying to differentiate it as it is decided to shift to 3rd street basketball . The characters also had to withdraw due to the circumstances of the parents who lied that the hero of amateurs rich enough only to know "ace of famous school" and "lack of high school" to former basketball team members The heroine saying "To actively participate in the practice of the 3on 3 team" and the heroine who lied and came to persuade childhood friend who jumped out of his hometown, three people lying to each other. Perhaps it seems like "Lie = absolute evil" Many jump readers have not accepted this "lying"?
Although the hero may be a miserable man, it is probably a miserable man, but I try hard to make a practice menu while purchasing information on the net with cooperation of my colleagues or not even trying to become a skilled person at the level of experienced people from an amateur of only knowledge, I will make an effort properly I still have a good impression because it is. It is still better than those who are fighting with talent alone without any effort.
I will say something that is missing, that is why it ceased to exist, after two volumes are read.