[Comics]I'll

  • Friendship
  • Interesting
  • Cool
  • Impressed
  • Funny
RSS
Comics total pnts rank Rank 709in 7,871 titlesTotal 16 / Deviation 53.07
Comics avg pnts Rank 682in 1,285 titlesAvg 0.81=Good/16 reviews
Comics rank of 1995 Rank 23in 182 titles
Statics of evaluation and Ranking
Reviews' statics
Post review by myself
Picture2.25(Very good)8
Character/Setting1.88(Very good)8
Story1.50(Very good)8
Friendship88%7/8
Interesting75%6/8
Cool62%5/8
Impressed62%5/8
Funny62%5/8
Cute38%3/8
Hot heart38%3/8
Brave38%3/8
Made me think38%3/8
Shocked38%3/8
Enjoyed38%3/8
Shed tears25%2/8
Sad25%2/8
Romantic25%2/8
Sexy12%1/8
Beautiful12%1/8
Moral12%1/8
Scareful0%0/8
Learned something0%0/8
Poll
Information about this title

Hiroyuki Asada
Monthly Shonen Jump
SHUEISHA
This description has the part which was created by referencing Wikipedia, so the licence of GFDL is applied to this description.
Japan Released:1995/11/06(Mon) Monthly Shonen Jump / End:2004
Official sites
1. http://mj.shueisha.co.jp/ill/ (Translation)
2. http://www.sonymusic.co.jp/Animation/CKBC/ (Translation)
31,4721817
Recently views
6656445576
  Limit by opinioin
Search in this page

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post your review to English version, please click here.
2016/03/26 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 45204 Host:45212 Browser: 10564
[good point]
An ordinary manga whose picture is beautiful so beautifully.
I remember the things I was worried about the last mistake I love you is wrong mistake lol Haha

[Bad point]
Wondering if the story is normal ...

[Comprehensive evaluation]
It's kind of boring but it's a little funny and it's a little exciting

2015/06/22 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 28352 Host:28366 Browser: 10071
[good point]
The story, all the characters are the best.
[Comprehensive evaluation]
It is my favorite manga.

2014/02/07 Very Bad(-2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 23770 Host:23821 Browser: 6159
Even from the age it is a basketball cartoon serialized in response to the hit of Slam Dunk Looks like no mistake Character that the idiocy is bad and it is freaky and the influence can be seen around the final closing with injury.

Tachibana and Hiiragi became friends at first at first, and the flow which will become able to be called as a buddy even within the field also comes to mind Sakuragi and Nagarekawa, and it is no doubt that the relationship that made it progressed

Although the picture is good at first glance, how pale and painful it is when the movement and emotion are added
(I think that one piece on the front cover of the comics and the scene of the scene is very good)
There was also that I could not write interesting basketball games without any appeal of the basketball scene

Even so it may be good as basketball is used as a stage or device for one scene of youth, but even as a youth manga the feeling that the author is drunk by his own characters and works It came out to me quite pleasantly

Although it is a youth manga rather than a basketball cartoon, it seems that it could not be enjoyed either and it seems to be a work that does not suit me. Evaluation [very bad] I will assume

2013/07/14 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 33841 Host:33794 Browser: 7408
While I was thinking "This manga is fun !!" I thought that it was going to be stalled until now ...... In the end it was "calmly so funny," it settled down.
One volume was super, it was interesting. It was very fresh for me to start with a sports group (it can be said that it is a club activity group) manga, starting from the point where he is trying to stop club activities such as hero. Mostly, this man's manga is whether the hero who was not interested in the sports of the subject starts growing from time to time and gradually grows up, or the hero who has amazing ability and talent enters high school.

However, this comic begins with the two hero's trying to stop basketball. It fulfills a destiny encounter at that point of smoking, recognizes each other as a rival, and tries hard work hard. It was a wonderful introduction part that made the reader fully think that "What happens to this !?"
And these two people are only watching each other as they are surprised even during the game. It only considers each other rival, it is out other than. This is interesting.

Also, episodes outside the game. This is also attractive. There is no doubt that this work is not [sports manga] but [youth manga with basketball as a theme]. This is interesting, is not it?
However, it seems a little youth way is safe, is it a one-pattern?
The expression of conflicts of boys and others runs in delinquency, only ...... Or rather, it is said that it is not convenient for you to cause violence while subjecting sports as a theme, somewhat reality I do not feel like lacking in. I felt it was somehow that only those who face themselves through sports and are raising themselves are doing something.

There is a more serious problem than that. If this work is a growing tale with Akane and Hitoni as one, there is one problem. Episodes outside the game are not related to their growth at all.
No, there are things that are strictly involved, but it can be said that they are rarely present. To be honest, it is almost irrelevant.
Well then why do you include an episode outside the game? Unfortunately I do not have an answer.
In ordinary sports comic, I draw until the launch until the game up until the game, fascinate the change in the game, attract the attention after the game. However, since many episodes outside the game are not directly related to Akane et al., I will not go on this street. Therefore, in the end, there are many patterns about how to lift and how to lift about Akane.

In other words, there is some reason, the feeling falls, the flow that it is revived by being imprisoned by Jin-well. As expected it is too much, from the middle a little bit eating ... .... Do you need a manager episode?

Also, although I think personally, I feel that the style and style I am good at as the author does not match. Even though it is a type of style that attracts drama among the expression of characters and so on, expressions are too much manga. To put it concretely, it is somewhat annoying because there are too many speech and sound characters outside the balloon. You can not enter the drama, is not it? (It also wrote it in the review of Tegami Bachi)

Every single factor has plenty of interest, but I felt that the connection was not satisfactory, so the evaluation is [good].
I wonder what it is, but there is interesting to read but lacks interesting to continue reading, that kind of feeling.

2012/03/01 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 5506 Host:5389 Browser: 5345
There is a Gudaguda story around the middle, but after the last leaves Yamazaki I think that it is a good manga that can be said good enough.
Although the last volume may have a somewhat brute force part, I thought that the two of the hero were developed which were able to put together "buddy" and "rival" well.

2011/11/30 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 3515 Host:3132 Browser: 11722
[good point]
High drawing power. "Mr. Asada felt once again that drawing people is really good." Being a basketball cartoon, being a manga that emphasizes humanity and drama nature. Emotions and gestures made by the character exciting, serifs. "Acho !!" when Tachibana decides shoots will be alright. "Lol
[Bad point]
There is no school in the curry division, so usually w. "I laughed here."
[Comprehensive evaluation]
This is the work previously drawn by Professor Asada who is the author of "Tegami Bachi". It is very interesting. It is a must-see as a fan. The combination of Hiiragi and Tachibana is the best !!!
Evaluation is "Highest" !!!

2010/10/10 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 7363 Host:7217 Browser: 11293
By the way, even Tegami bees adorned the cover in the November issue of Square ........

The exchange of games was also a sense of urgency, and the enthusiasm to raise the author was transmitted, but rather than a basketball cartoon, it was a youth manga by young people who bore basketball.

Akane who was dedicated to basketball, when he thought that he was unable to basketball in an unexpected accident, he thought that he was cutting down coldly, in fact he was a good brother,
In the Hayama Yuzaki, a former Prime Minister's style, Yarazaki who endured the pain and worked hard, Yamazaki who was suffering from conflict with teammates of the junior high school era and the like, etc. Character depiction of ally side such as Higashi Omoto I think that he was well deepened.

However, rival leaves Yamazaki's people, Minowa was able to compare with Naruse who was in the dog monkey indeed, and I was able to understand the kinship hatred to Akane too,
Did you say that it was a pioneer of "Kire ni Tenshi"? It was not a rival character whose personality is short-circuiting, self-righteous and much better. Did you say that he was one-sided?

Sorry about the place there a bit,
Akane who was driven to the end of despair at the end (in other words, CV in OVA version was an actor from Nagasaki who was recuperating him, was he appointed in Nagasaki connection?) Is safe in the world of basketball I was able to go back and I was able to meet again with my other friends,
There was a high level of painting power, although not as good as the present. Tegami Bachi also animated version seems to have started broadcasting a new series, this aisle's evaluation will be considered "ordinary" which is a little over "good", but in the work of Mr. Hiroyuki Asada, it is the work which seems to be the best . It could be said that it was a piece of manga that was regrettable anyhow.

2010/01/03 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 12514 Host:12597 Browser: 9646
[good point]
Stylish picture
Chara has charm. The main characters are cool.
Episodes of each character are skillfully drawn.
And it is good that many of the episodes lead to basket as a result.
.Volume 1!!
Easy to collect in all 14 volumes!

[Bad point]
There are many stories besides basketball. In particular, I feel that I do not need an episode of joining a manager.
Patterns do not match actions and sports scenes.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
As the following nikoniko says, it is best to read as "youth manga drawn through basketball". Perhaps the author also thinks so and draws.

But the final leaf Yamazaki was like a sports manga and got hot.
Tachibana and Minori on the final scene of the game have a 1: 1 relationship, and there is also a provision for making it to it,
It was a proper basketball cartoon.
I think that it is awesome for an author who does not have basketball experience (it looks unlikely) to draw so far. (I'm sorry for that)

Last leaves Although I do not like the story (14 volumes) after the Battle of Yamazaki,
Continue forcibly, "Take out new characters 〓〓〓attach episodes 〓〓〓basketball team solve with you"
I think that the way of finishing was better than repeating it.

If you have not read yet, please read 1 volume by all means. Volume 1 is very hot (@ 〓〓〓〓〓〓〓〓〓@)

2009/04/12 Favorite comment [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 13571 Host:13775 Browser: 9207
[good point]
Establishing a character Cool atmosphere
[Bad point]
Occasionally cold gag last

[Comprehensive evaluation]
To the extent that it is said that basketball manga will not succeed except for some exceptions, I felt that the cartoonist was drawing a good theme on the theme of hard subject matter.

Especially, how to draw characters is wonderful Shooter's beard, captain Yamazaki, rival team leaves Yamazaki Naruse, low spirit PF and many emotion-transferable characters appear.

However, I do not think that overall the poor tempo is outstanding enough to be said masterpiece by being conspicuous. I could not say that I had put together the development of the last well, but I could not say it to flattering, but the character got a bad result although I could draw it well.

2009/02/17 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 21303 Host:21491 Browser: 9505
[Comprehensive evaluation]
It is interesting to see it as a man's youth manga painted through basketball, not basketball. However, although there is not much impact in any direction.

2007/04/09 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 8516 Host:8589 Browser: 4928
I was attracted by paintings and I read 7 volumes in the library, but it was quite funny. I think that hero was also cool.

2007/03/02 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 19047 Host:19009 Browser: 5234
You should see this as a youth comic rather than a basketball cartoon.
It is more interesting than when playing games ...
Akane and Hige Dundee Higashi is a good character.
The battle with Hayama Saki was somewhat stretched and sagging.
The last round was very good.

2006/05/30 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 22789 Host:22757 Browser: 3875
I'm not caught trying to raise this manga on the same ring as Slam Dunk,
I could not read it properly because it did not fit the skin.

If you briefly summarize the doubts about this manga,
It means that you can not understand why they are so good at basketball.
The exercises they are doing do not seem very strict,
Apart from being shadowed it would not be a special training to be superhuman like the Astro Ball Team.
If it says that it is a talent it is also there, but that is too easy.

If you say this in front of a friend,
"Do not think this is a sports cartoon"
I was scolded.
However, they seem to be enjoying and they can not empathize them,
After all it can only be evaluated cold.

2005/11/15 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 432 Host:7 Browser: 5234
It is the worst result as a basketball manga. I have read up to 10 volumes, but I hate pictures first, it is hard to read ....
The content is not remembered at all ..... I lost feeling of reading. I have not read until the end so I will keep the evaluation bad.

2005/07/27 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 12661 Host:12594 Browser: 2753(Mobile)
Tears caught in a conversation at the hospital of Akane and Hiiragi at the end. And I was amazed at the confrontation between the two at the Inhi Semifinals. It was a pity that the content of the game was not hung. My favorite character was beard dandy. Three in the match with the national body substitute group was thrilled

2004/11/22 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 39708 Host:39711 Browser: 3646
How to carry the game, how to show the character was good.
The picture is just beautiful, I like the feeling full of speed.
Friendship that Tachibana and Hiiragi are brittle but tied firmly was also good.
However, "momentum" as a manga which was in volume 1 to 2 was lost as I headed to the final story. Was it a pity?
While the middle stage was strangely slow progressing the story, I was surprised at the early development of the final volume.
It was a little regrettable that I kept following it, it was the way I finished like WJ's celebrated work.
I also felt that I wanted Hiiragi's parentage relationship to deepen further.




Top Page top MetaSeachJP Works