[Comics]Ateya no Tsubaki

  • Scareful
  • Sexy
  • Shocked
  • Sad
  • Beautiful
  • Interesting
RSS
Comics total pnts rank Rank 1,094in 8,904 titlesTotal 10 / Deviation 51.54
Comics rank of 2008 Rank 35in 285 titles
Statics of evaluation and Ranking
Reviews' statics
Post review by myself
Picture2.17(Very good)6
Story1.83(Very good)6
Character/Setting1.33(Good)6
Scareful100%6/6
Sexy83%5/6
Shocked83%5/6
Sad67%4/6
Beautiful67%4/6
Interesting67%4/6
Impressed33%2/6
Shed tears17%1/6
Made me think17%1/6
Learned something17%1/6
Funny17%1/6
Cute0%0/6
Hot heart0%0/6
Brave0%0/6
Romantic0%0/6
Moral0%0/6
Friendship0%0/6
Enjoyed0%0/6
Cool0%0/6
Poll
Information about this title

Kanji Kawashita
HAKUSENSHA
Japan Released:2008 Young Animal
Official sites
1. http://www.younganimal.com/magazine/list/ateyanotusbaki/index.html (Translation)
28,25777
Recently views
1223313442
  Limit by opinioin
Search in this page

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post your review to English version, please click here.
2014/06/26 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 40155 Host:40435 Browser: 6686
No, it is interesting. Although it is interesting, I wonder if it was different from what I had hoped before opening this work.
First of all, the sense of painting is very high, and I am captivated by the vivid appearance of camellia.
I am really outstanding in pictorial sense ....

However, although I saw it by being invited to the singing phrase "Oedo mystery", I have a very doubt about genre called honest mystery.
As others say, there are many elements devoted to the occult completely to resolve the case, and with the impression that it is too far apart (in some sense it is a mystery).
For those who were expecting real routes that I felt like Kagami Heiji or Toyama's Kim, I think that it is somewhat disappointing.

2012/08/24 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 18042 Host:18292 Browser: 11976
[good point]
The picture is very beautiful.
I can not read the development of the story.
[Bad point]
There are many erotro elements.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
As the picture was very beautiful and easy to read, I could not read the development of the story so I was excited and I was able to read through the page.
I think that eroticism and grooming are okay so it is okay, but I think that it is better to purchase after thinking carefully for those who are not good.

2012/02/01 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 11785 Host:11552 Browser: 9929
The more you read it, the less you know whether this work is a detective or super stuff.
This is a frank opinion on this work.

In the story, Ukiyoe teacher, a case where a female prostitute who had made motif of Shogun's shogun was murdered occurred,
It starts from the place where Fengsheng enters the tenement house which lowered the sign written "battle shop".

Detective thing that challenges various mystery cases mainly by the fighting killer where the camellia involves women's faction with Feng Sen.
A woman murdered in the neighborhood of Edo is discovered by being cut out of his ear, a priest's murder in a nunnery,
In the case involving Tsubaki, there are many things involving women, and the depiction is quite glaring.
A woman who has lost his ears, a poor witchcraft entertainer, a character of a famous house which was hidden in a nunnerya,
Even if you see the drama developed by the central figure of the incident, there are many things against the ego of the female,
The story is well kneaded in.

However, because the case of the incident is not a trick, it is only the case of dropping a story with a kind of paranormal phenomenon,
As a detective object, I feel unsatisfactory.

Therefore, the evaluation is "ordinary".

2011/11/01 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 36209 Host:36373 Browser: 6425
[good point]
High drawing power.
Especially the fusion of the balance of cute and beauty different from "Moe" of female character, incongruous feeling with erotro depiction.
As long as the story is not too bad, the author can do it as a professional in a youth magazine.

[Bad point]
Tsubaki emphasizes "logic" on Tsubaki while the occult (= nonscientific, nonlogical) element is strong and there is a subtle aspect as a mystery story.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Among the serious system reasoning adventure of 18 ban game,
There is also a work that enjoying the atmosphere of the story with the story being so abundant with the rippling the side view of the lateral groove work,
It seems like you comicized that kind.

I think that you can enjoy it so much unless Eroguro is a person who is not useless.

2011/10/19 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 32099 Host:31952 Browser: 3446(Mobile)
Although it was a work that was attracted to the cover picture and impulse buying, each story and character has a mackerel each and reading continues. Among them, Tsubaki's exaggeration of the main character is also a study.

2010/07/10 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 18067 Host:18048 Browser: 7339
I evaluate this comic because it is quite favorite.

This work of the mystery thing set in Edo. I think that there is something quite attractive if you read it. In addition to the good picture, the composition of the story is interesting. There are many things tricks are unique to manga, many erotic and grotesque, but I do not mind separately. If there is only one point to worry about, it is occasionally short of explanation of the story. It is still unlikely that some of the characters that appeared had solved the incident.

But it is fun to compile them. I am looking forward because the hint still remains.

Although it is a genre that it is difficult to put out the story, I hope Mr. Kawashita is doing my best.

2010/04/06 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 27293 Host:27202 Browser: 7336
[good point]
The picture is fine
The incident is interesting

[Bad point]
Critically erotic, grotesque description
Lack of explanation
There are many depression developments

[Comprehensive evaluation]
An inference cartoon set in Edo.
My main business is a painter but I am working as a female principal, Feng Sen, who is not good at living by drawing a secondary job of drawing shoes, and a camellia camellia, a hero who is also a hero and a heroine, A story that uncovers the truth of a murderous murder case occurring in Edo.

Erotic (sexual intercourse) scenes are surely entered every time whether Yoshiwara's girls are involved in most stories, and Fengsen's occupation is also a shunki.
Because it is published in Young Animals, which are often dealing with relatively adult content among young magazines, this is also appropriate to the needs of the reader.
However, I think that it will be a minus point for someone who is not good at blatant eroticism.
And most of the incidents happening are murderous murder cases.
I properly describe every detail up to the details of the human body such as internal organs and bones, so I can not recommend reading while eating rice.
From this point, it would be painful for a person who is not good at expressing grotesque to read it.
There are many cases involving entanglement of innocence in the case, and the ending will come about as much as you feel depressed. I think that this is one of the taste of the work, but there are still people who are not good at it.

The contents of the important incident are the story that the nun who had never touched a man got pregnant, the story that the dead body that was chewed by the beast after the shrimp dog of the shrine disappeared, etc. are all like urban legend It is intriguing that it is just a bizarre case and special cases, and how it is going to be what it is.
However, as the explanation part goes fairly lightly and quickly, it is likely that it will end with indigestion if you do not read through the line often through the eyes.

Yoshiwara no Jiro is a work of concern because the mystery and hints are still many, such as the mystery of the magical capability of Mr. and the man who seems to know the past of Tsubaki who came out at the end of 3 volume.




↑Top