[Comics]Astro Kyudan

  • Hot heart
  • Friendship
  • Made me think
  • Shocked
  • Cool
RSS
Other media: SF TV:Astro Kyudan
Comics total pnts rank Rank 480in 7,709 titlesTotal 23 / Deviation 54.99
Comics avg pnts Rank 331in 1,286 titlesAvg 1.53=Very good/15 reviews
Comics rank of 1972 Rank 6in 30 titles
Statics of evaluation and Ranking
Reviews' statics
Post review by myself
Picture2.00(Very good)2
Character/Setting1.50(Very good)2
Story1.50(Very good)2
Hot heart100%2/2
Friendship100%2/2
Made me think100%2/2
Shocked100%2/2
Cool100%2/2
Beautiful50%1/2
Moral50%1/2
Scareful50%1/2
Enjoyed50%1/2
Impressed50%1/2
Interesting50%1/2
Sexy0%0/2
Cute0%0/2
Brave0%0/2
Shed tears0%0/2
Sad0%0/2
Romantic0%0/2
Learned something0%0/2
Funny0%0/2
Poll
Information about this title

Shirou Tozaki
Norihiro Nakajima
SHUEISHA
Japan Released:1972 Weekly Shonen Jump / End:1976
14,4281815
Recently views
1441413232
  Limit by opinioin
Search in this page

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post your review to English version, please click here.
2015/08/21 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 17095 Host:17104 Browser: 7909
For me it is a manga that is difficult to evaluate.

Although it is not my hobby, there are several cartoons nominally important for manga history, and its representative is this "Astro team".

It is not a cartoon that I can recommend to read to the young people now.
The story does not know the reason, there is contradiction, too, what is it that you want to say, it is manga.

However, this comic later has a serious effect.
If you call on the name of the technique you do not need reasons to deathblows or the Magic ball OK!
I do not know what the phenomenon means, but I push it with a powerful imitation expression.

Without this manga, it may not have been born "to hang the ring" or "fist of the North Star".
Too much more than six million copies of the "jumping golden age" may not have come.
In that sense, it is an epoch making cartoon of a boys' manga.
But, if asked if it is worth reading now, it can not help heading its head.

Historical value is high, but there is not much meaning that you have to read this work.
From the viewpoint of manga historical viewpoint, I have to put a rating of "good" or higher, but in order to put a rating higher than that, it was a work that my body got stuffy somewhat.

2010/09/17 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 42753 Host:42643 Browser: 7389
A legendary work. A terrible baseball manga with extreme absurdity. It is full of passion and madness.

Since I saw the drama version that was broadcasting at midnight a few years ago, I wanted to read the original but recently I read the reprint version of Ota publication.

The prototype of the story is based on "Satomi Hakkenden". A baseball superman who inherits the real soul of Sawamura Eiji who gathered in the Pacific War gathered and gathered to form the Astro team and overwhelmed it.To revolutionize the baseball world aiming for the major league is the outline of the outline.

The baseball manga of this era often comes out of the demonic balloon represented by the "Disappearing Magic Ball" of the "Star of the Giant".
The batter creates secret hits to defeat the balls and breaks down the balls, and the pitcher sets up a new magic ball against it ... This is a classic flow where the story advances with this repetition.

Even in the "Astro Ball Team", the talk progresses in the same flow as before, and after the black team won, Lotte battle, the conspiracy of the Astro team wipe out, the fellowship of the brothers of Daimon and Shibusaburo, and one of Astro Supernatural while intensely astro team Even though various expectations such as Shiro Shiro who has hostility intrude into the victory team warf which swirls ... ....

It can be said that this Victory team fight is all of this cartoon.
I am using the weekly series and about two years' worth for this game. Even the entire work is actually two thirds of Victory team.
This is common in the jump manga (not just a jump ...) It is not the result of forcibly stretching the story because the popularity came out, it is not the result of stretching the story one batting For every one ball spot drawn with a spirit this length I think that it has become.

I do not write the contents of the game in detail, but something ... I am crazy about it. The brake is broken. Why will it be such a thing?

I will not have anything if I thrust each time. Depending on how to read it looks like a gag only.
However, the players who are fighting and the author who draws are also serious. truly.

The game is long, but always full of enthusiasm and tension and is a continuation of climax.
I am very tired with reading. Now I can not tell how many points the game is going on even such a thing.
By the time the game was over, I was exhausted and I began to burn out with "Oh, it ended ...". And this cartoon finishes like burning out as well.

If it sees it as a work it is balanced or messy. Only three games are played in a four-year weekly series.
Perhaps it is better to say that it is a phantom than rather a masterpiece.
But this manga may not be ever again.

It was a wonderful manga.

2009/08/13 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 15278 Host:15503 Browser: 6342
The original series serialized in Weekly Shonen Jump in 72-76: Professor Tokuhiro Nakajima's Superman Fighting Baseball manga by Shiro Tokorozaki. Japan is proud of an unlucky nominee lord of late.Email by Sawamura Eiji September 9th, Showa 29 on September 9, 1954 with a mysterious person `Shuro 'that he succeeded in the Philippines with ball type aza somewhere in the body 9 nine superhuman who were born at 9 minutes and 9 seconds are overthrowing giants. A real baseball drama that forms the world's strongest baseball team with the goal of overwhelming major league.

When this work began, it was a time when professional baseball cartoons such as "Giant Star" and other animations and "Baseball Mad Poems" were popular, the baseball world also became king. The main enthusiastic era of Nagashima giant army It seems that it was born by multiplying it. But even though it was thought that ordinary baseball cartoons are not tricky, it is a true death struggle, not sports, which is quite different from the traditional baseball known as superhuman baseball, it can not be apologized or reoccurring at the game place Etc. It is done with a fierce development.

The story took over the legend of the legendary national player `Sawamura Eiji 'The nine superhors born at 9:09:99 on September 9, 1959 gathered together to create the world's strongest team" ", Based on the setting of" Jacobini Meteor Striking Method "and" Andromeda Great Nebula Turning Method ", such as the blows of the great names such as" Skylab throwing method "and" Phantom great magic ball " There is nothing with rules, such as surgery, etc. There is nothing dangerous Most dangerous people are seriously injured because explosive extraordinary murder technique explodes. It should be called desmatch named baseball. I do not know what purpose it was created, but there are also many people who understand because they are too far apart from now. Despite this rugged content, it is a long-term series of 4 years (20 books in a book) whether its tension high development was amazing. But only three games were played though.

This work is a masterpiece that supported the jump of Genesis of the 1970s, but it has become impossible to keep up with the content that is too common. It is a high tension sports (or whether it can be said) whether it is a drama, but because there is a feeling that it has gone too loudly, the evaluation is [good]. By the way, the Astro team won this rugged game of superhumaners to anger Tenji Kawakami (doubling of the ball world), it will be expelled from the ball world, and the last will be departing for Africa to fight the Maasai tribe finish. Even though I think about it now, it seemed that it was an era when such a great thing was sought, but I felt that the work of such ha ha ha ha featured well for readers. However, thanks to this work, it will set the thing called a deathblow to a jump, and it will greatly influence a number of works including fighting sports manga such as "Kinnikuman" "Sakigake! Men Juku" .
By the way, sports cartoons with huge mecha content like contents which can not be called very sports also in recent jump work are often, but it may be influence of this work. I wonder if history repeats itself.

2009/07/18 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 2325 Host:2227 Browser: 9207
[good point]
At the reach of Magical Ball Comic, historical works

[Bad point]
Is there a lot of discriminatory terms?

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Izuin Hikari says that the age when I met this work was important, but I agree.
For me who met this work at a public hall near my elementary school lower grade, it is the ultimate work.
But when I purchased the Astro team of Daeje Publishing and put it in the laboratory of the university,
Everyone did not take it as a gag work,
Even though I knew it, I was a little sad.

2008/12/28 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 4070 Host:3839 Browser: 8445
[good point]
all.

[Bad point]
None.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Will two brothers come out?

2008/08/12 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 30956 Host:30872 Browser: 7282
[good point]
If the eye shield is set to 1, this manga expresses about 10000000000000 fun, superhumanism, and man's romance brilliantly! (Ice is like a man for women.)

[Bad point] However, the content of the technique ... (especially human Niagara wwwww)
Some discrimination terms also exist.

[Comprehensive evaluation] Still it is funniest to the highest!

2008/04/29 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 3592 Host:3439 Browser: 7395
No, this is amazing. Really, it's too loud and you can laugh.
Even though it is baseball, there are some techniques to kill people, and indeed some people are actually dead ...
It is too terrible in many ways and it is the best.

2007/09/10 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 23770 Host:23443 Browser: 4184
Typical of young manga that is "good and bad" "no Tondemo".

Elements such as' Overwhelmed Giants' and Major League 'such as "Giants and Major League" who was born on 9th September 1954 who inherited the will of Eiji Sawamura were quickly forgotten, and under the name of "one game complete combustion" I think that it is a work that gives priority to fun of the place.

However, when I get calm and read it back ...
"The first two balls are mountaineers, and it will become the stepping stone of the second generation ball 2 appearance"
"Lonely director, Shizuki Kaneda's sneaky strategy to this extent"
"Is the ninth superman a chinen or a seventh spirit, or is Ryo Sakamoto?"
"Razor's Dragon = Kaohsiung Ball 6 will come to a helper at the last minute"
"Ijuin-in brothers feud"
"The transfiguration of Baron who came out instead of Daimon"
"Conversion from killer baseball to clean superhuman baseball"
"To decide the end of the Victory game is not a ball but a ball five"
I thought that many parts that seemed to be calculating the whole composition such as "I think that you are thinking properly as a product that a professional produces" ~.

As a compensation,
"Chin and Takuro 's real character is actually the last superman, so Chinen: Nanai Shirai, Ryo Sakamoto characters dangle"
"The drawing seems to be inferior to the earlier episode because the drawing has improved too much compared to the initial stage (the actual depiction itself is not inferior ... ...)"
"The shape of Shibusaburo's character greatly differs before and after Victory War (contradictions also exist, such as being born in Tokyo in the Lotte game as concrete origins have been decided by Victory)."
"Shuro disappears when it is crucial, and it is just a background"
"Kaneda Shoichi suddenly added a sneaky attack until then" will teach professional severity "will be a good person"
... There are other countless disadvantages that can be pointed out, but even if you deduct them, it's a funny work that makes you feel the heat overwhelmingly.

Realistically it is absolutely impossible to kill a murderous murderer, enemies who are devoid of bloody special training, ordinary gymnastics that can not be done in "bleeding of blood" enemies, characters that do not care for ally, "Manga cartoons produced by the 1970s".
I can only say that this is "I want you to read and feel the enthusiasm."
I thought that it might be "very good" because the disadvantages are too much, but I think that such a cartoonist will not be born anymore ... from "the best!"

In addition, the extra edition is redundant even if it reads as "loving omake". The man who should have finished her beautifully in the match against Lotte shows such abomination ....

2005/12/14 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 13217 Host:13098 Browser: 5234
A manga whose evaluation is divided whether it should be called masterpiece or "stray".
This work affects not only jump manga but also various manga, in the genre called fighting manga with title fraud, it is an icecol cartoon that is in line with "Samurai Giants" of the same period, but the content is definitely interesting and can play with a good meaning Part is also seen quite a bit.

Although it is a work that pretty much anticipates the era if it says it well, if it says badly, as Haboro coal mine says, the opportunity to jump to fix the direction of the subsequent jumping direction and thereby crush other possible works It may be one made. If collective conflicts like this work are simply received, there is no need to restrict it to baseball because there is no collective battle (even though it can not be helped if you think about baseball popularity at that time, I also have something like strong soccer and rugby elements), and I think that this has given too much unfavorable influence to Masami Kurumada of "RUNKING ON THE RING".

The author of this work is a translation that it is impossible to write a hit work so much, but it certainly was written by myself and it would not have thought that difficulties will come down to oneself. Jump manga is not a collective conflict ___ ___ ___ 0 ___ __ 2 ___ ___ 0

Although it is good while ukekei is good, I think that this work clearly stated the problem of the way of tightrope walking that one step stripped off ... and I wanted a device to make more use of reflection about that part ... ....

2005/12/14 Normal comment [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 47291 Host:47316 Browser: 4487
It is a nice thing Ikaretonguchiki baseball cartoon, but it is important with regard to drawing work of this work (or rather this person was thinking about talking with the editor almost in the second half).
That is to suggest a notorious "questionnaire system introduction" in the jump.

Even though it was a jump that included a notorious system called "exclusive contract system", Tokushuhiro Nakajima, the popular author at the time, proposed that "to introduce a survival system for activation" In the beginning of this, the questionnaire system of Weekly Shonen Jump which is still infamous by this is completed.

In that sense, the author of this work did a terrible sin making thing ....

However, it should be said that it is also self-owned that his own work is being ceased repeatedly with that questionnaire system.

2005/10/24 Favorite comment [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 30606 Host:30421 Browser: 3846
Oh, did this end with the intention of the author?
I certainly can not imagine that the material will not have to continue even more than that.
Because I got a dead man in a baseball game.

I can only think of a deployment where the dead comes alive again when it comes to more stories,
Even being beyond that one point is conscientious.

2005/10/24 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 6517 Host:6643 Browser: 5234
During the Astro Cypriot series, I am still an infant, the first time I saw the Astro team was a reprint that was reprinted in about a few years. I knew about the Astro team for a long time, but I had not had a chance to read it

It is a comic book located in the extremely north of the abyss of baseball cartoon, and in a sense, it is manga that will definitely remain in the comic history.
Especially confrontation with the Victory team is no longer baseball, it can be said to be fighting manga with bat and ball, furthermore the naming of the magic ball, secret hit, super defense is also amazing !! Anything like "Magic ball xx" But nothing can be said about it.

Magical ball ... Final large balloon, phantom great magic ball, bean ball magic ball etc secret hit ... pole of star shooting star, Andromeda big nebula shot method etc. super fiel .. human Niagara, cavalry fist law big wheel etc etc

Especially the human niagara used by the Victory team is that several players from the sky come down like a waterfall and hurt the batter who advances to first base and out.
Furthermore, even if the Achilles tendon breaks, it runs, holding two bats and striking by saying "two sword killing method", and then turning to Nunchaku bat.
It is not absurd in half way, I remember even refreshing in a sense if it is thoroughly done so far.
When I know Namasi baseball, this is something I can not imagine absurdly, but because the author does not know baseball at all, it is all that there is something that is not written in the rule book, so it was developed like this I was talking about things like that.

And it is likable that the series ended at the time of popularity peak.
Mr. Nakajima said, "How long is the series four years"
It is an opinion that this is an opinion that we know that it is time to quit as well as knowing my competence, judging that I can not draw anything I can continue any more.
Mr. Mitsuaki Yokoyama also said that, even though there are attachment comics, I think there is time to stop. Recently, not only jumping, I think that any magazine missed the time to quit and I was able to finish in a nice shape while the comics that are going on and off are lots of trouble.

Comics like this may not show up in the future.

2005/07/25 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 37247 Host:37156 Browser: 4487
It is too overbearing work. Whatever you say, you already want to do commonsense for the first time.
Memory that the heroes were also so wonderful. However, I killed the practice game partner ....

By the way, how about this painting manager after this work date?

2005/05/05 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 53887 Host:53973 Browser: 3846
It is a battle cartoon covering sports skin as well as linking It can be said that it is a cornerstone of jump manga It is supposed to have left the place to play baseball and went on a journey to baseball mission to Africa but it is more than 30 years since Ale , I wonder what has become of African baseball

2005/03/18 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 27866 Host:27810 Browser: 5234
A phantom of a generation in which baseball was 90% of the world for a boy who was temporary. Why are you killing? Is it okay for baseball superman to do things?
And reasonably it is 120 degrees Tsukkomi index, but only abnormal tension is accepted.
The work of those who inherited the soul of the deceased are mutual killings.
Things that can not be floated by anything Nothing is better than me ... Honestly There is no worth reading other than impact now. Well it should be enjoyed as a poisonous thing.

2005/03/18 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 33021 Host:32998 Browser: 5978
Oh, it is a work known as the first manga who died in baseball. Without this work, hell koshien and the prince of tennis could not have been born ... I do not know.

Well, it's confusing from introduction. A legendary pitcher saying that young people born September 9, 1952, with the balls of the ball, will be gathered by Filipinos who are entrusted with the will of Sawamura Eiji and aiming to establish a super team which can compete with Major Leaguers It was a ton demo. So, on that day flying objects of mystery are flying to the earth ... SF!

Brother of the giant who ignored human standards and brother of extremely dwarf brother, brother tossing his brother by blowing his brother, catching any homerun nuisance, or further breaking the bat to break that technique I will devise a disturbing "Jacobini Meteor Striking Method" technique, but only by mentioning superhuman baseball, a tonedemo technique will be deployed one after another.

Even if it is an enemy, the unusual team will come out with an incredible team of black teams formed by collecting families of athletes who have been thrown away by the Yomiuri Giants. Ah ... this is Japan, are not you !?

There are real players who said Nagashima, the King, but Mr. Nagashima is a terrible fellow at any mind. In order to let an orphan with a sight to join the future Giants, let me enroll in an unnamed high school so as not to be noticed by other teams ... I wonder whether I ignore human rights (bitter smile).

Otherwise, the leader side is going on the lawless side who can paralyze dead people from the helicopter with a parachute and revive it with the shock, or lawless family who can be appealed by the bereaved family. Besides, this is seriously not a gag. No, the old jump cartoon is truly irresistible.

2005/01/29 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 30606 Host:30421 Browser: 3846
This is tired of being stomach full if you read once, but it is worth reading.
Do you want baseball to do or do you want to do killing? It is unknown intention, but the meaning is impressed meaning the skill is terrible.

Black volunteer Nanai Shirai 's murder L - shaped throwing method which I was particularly impressed with reading.
But even though this superman could not hit it, he was struck by the giant's upstream.
Tetsuharu Kawakami who is a terrible real person than the superstar who is terrible ordinary person (Nanai Shishi) has come.

2005/01/29 Normal comment [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 22159 Host:22036 Browser: 3874
Although it may have been certainly impacted in the past, it is not so easy to read now, it is difficult to read only by old ...




Top Page top MetaSeachJP Works