[Comics]Aoki Shinwa Mars

RSS
Comics total pnts rank Rank 7,600in 7,871 titlesTotal -11 / Deviation 45.38
Comics rank of 1996 Rank 155in 165 titles
Statics of evaluation and Ranking
Reviews' statics
Post review by myself
Poll
Information about this title

Yukihisa Motojima
Koudansha
Japan Released:1996 Weekly Shonen Magazine / End:1999
8,50288
Recently views
1251443222
  Limit by opinioin
Search in this page

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post your review to English version, please click here.
2013/05/30 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 18742 Host:18482 Browser: 5345
Mr. Yukihisa Honjima sensei horse racing comic series serialized by Weekly Shonen Magazine in 96 ~ 99. "Koyano Mamoru" and the parents of the university professor nurture racehorse research and foster in the pasture and raised the female horse 'Hermes', but Hermes' making pups is extremely difficult, which makes the mother overwork dead. Once I was a father who gave up, I read my mother's research diary and challenge again to make Hellmes's offspring. At last the struggle ends, "Mars" is born. And overcoming many challenges, Mars grows as a racehorse. Ma also becomes a jockey and challenges the race with Mars.

This work is a newly created horse race cartoon that combines the flow with the success of the previous work "Sylphide of the Wind", finished as a work synchronizing the view of the world of Silpheed. Although it is a work of the same world as Silpheed, Miles is a rival horse of Silpheed, whereas Sylphide is a white horse, it is not a legitimate sequel because the position is opposed due to Maxim's Dingle bloodline. In addition, while the previous work was the main story of a horse and a man 's friendship, this is the inner circumstances and so on which were made behind the horse race world and the doping etc, etc. are drawn, and it is finished in a dark image compared with the previous work. It is a work finished in a more real horse racing world, but since there is no scene that is impressed when compared with the previous work, it was only left in the impression that it was drawn almost irregularly.

Compared to the previous work, the picture was also a solid feeling compared to the previous work and there was not much good impression because there was a feeling that deployment was big and it was stray only tension. Therefore, evaluation is [bad]. Although we are finishing it in a form that concludes everything together with the previous work, there was a feeling that it was not so good as a aftertaste. I wish I could obviously complete the story with the sylpheed Jr version.

2011/01/09 Very Bad(-2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 7013 Host:6757 Browser: 12340
It was still good until around the Asahi Cup, but then it gets dreadful.
It is completely different from the gate of Makibao and Yusuba. . .

I'm excited for regular classic but it was lacking in excitement somewhat. The Sylphard was still more excited.
The skill was up and it is easy to see. I ran into Ultra Confrontism. Even if it says that he won the derby like this, if it knows the horse race 'is it, is it?' Do not look sweet the dreams of horse racing festival derby, all Horseman.

Evaluation is very bad.

2009/12/21 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 14576 Host:14640 Browser: 6404
Saying that the work itself is a sequel to Sylphide, additional settings such as Sylphide and Maxim's father,
There was a bad feeling in this work just after the serialization started.

The story began with the episode of Hermes born by extreme inbreeding of Dingle,
Mars is born after the hardships and efforts of the parent and child of Kunozo for bringing Hermes' s offspring which child is not born due to evil of inbreeding.
After that, it was the content saying that the story will be developed around the game with the children of Sylpheed Jr called "white four heavenly kings" that appeared before Horse and Mars.

The contents of a human drama entrusting dreams to horses deployed under the work did not almost replace the previous work, including Kuno Oyako, Rikodo Brothers Sister, Ridge Brothers Sister, Jockey Sidetracked Horsemen, Morikawa Hayao, Yuki Jun, etc.

Also, I also looked at the miscellaneous creation that the power technique that makes Mars who retired once will be returned as a local horse to fight with Maxim's baby is outstanding.

Evaluation is "bad".

2009/01/24 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 54537 Host:54483 Browser: 6302
It is the same as the previous sylphide, but this author's manga has many works only on the upper side.

This cartoon is also a horse body which is far from thoroughbred and it was what I came to read in magazine serialization with a magazine serialization as to aiming to make it coherent or making a racehorse idiot.
Honestly, Mutsu Toshiyuki's horse racing manga was (more) fun to read.

In this story, I think that it would be better for a manga artist whose painting ability can only draw the upper side disappear.

2009/01/15 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 25881 Host:26185 Browser: 8455
[good point]

It is a spin-off work of "Wind Sillfield". Well I twisted a little by saying that it is a child of a rival. I am impressed by Mars that crawls from premature babies.

[Bad point]

I did not have much interest, including my previous work. Although I do not think that it is a terrible trash work in content ...

[Comprehensive evaluation]

After all, it is going to be treated as a second dish (sweat). The actual problem manga artist is also serious, it is to survive. "usually"

2008/11/01 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 8858 Host:8682 Browser: 7345
Well, the image of a work drawn by a person who does not know horse racing is too strong ...
Although I was still able to watch it at the time of Silpheedo, I can not feel love in "horse racing" itself .. This man's manga

2008/05/14 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 10986 Host:10962 Browser: 6287
[good point]
I think that the figure skill has risen well since the time of Sylphard.

[Bad point]
The horse of the maxim line which was a rival of Silpheedo was set as a hero. This was the place I did not like in the first place. I wish I had made Sylphood Jr who came out in the last of Silpheed obediently the hero.
Also, I had a bad impression that the reorganization of the story of the previous episode, which the silpheed eventually ended without winning the maxim, was underway in the story. And despite it was nuance that Silpheed Jr inherited the dream that Silpheed could not fulfill in the last work of the previous work, in the end Silpido Jr finally changed into relay handling to the next generation due to lack of power It is the most disgusting point.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Even now, there is an impression that it was a sequel made forcibly because the previous work was popular.
If you look only at the story itself, it can be as "very bad" or "worst"
Evaluating the point that I saw the story of Silpheed again after all, I regard the evaluation as being "bad" sweetly.

2008/05/14 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 18003 Host:17725 Browser: 2218(Mobile)
The descendant of Maxim who was a competitor of Silpheed is the story of the hero.

Although it was a sequel, it seemed that the depiction of the horse was deteriorating.
And in Sylphode I ended up winning Maxim, but Maxim made a story of a revenge to Silpheed and I think that the sylphide was unified.
I thought that such a sequel was not very favorable.
Still the sylph themselves had something to do with them, so I worried if there is a sequel, so I read it but the evaluation is "subtle" because it is subtle.
There were not a few races to enjoy.




Top Page top MetaSeachJP Works