|Statics of evaluation and Ranking|
|Information about this title|
Shinya Suyama Monthly Shounen GANGAN SQUARE ENIX
|Japan Released:2002/01/12(Sat) Monthly Shounen GANGAN / End:2004/11/12 |
- ▼Sorted by:Newness
2008/09/07 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by vein (Skip) Provider: 38778 Host:38628 Browser: 5978
Each character was established properly.
Also, the story development of one episode one episode is good tempo. .
As gags were dependent on the personality of the character and many things were solid, likes and dislikes seemed to be divided, but also the goodness of the tempo was boosted, I thought that I was pretty good.
More than anything, I liked the atmosphere of the whole work.
First, change of drawing.
In my case, I like the style of 4 volumes the most, but the shaping of the face from the beginning to the end, the amount of tone, how to use, etc. continued to change. In this regard, even though some people like a certain time, there are few people who like it throughout.
Also, since the final story and the story of the introduction part take up the summary without such hints, we received the impression that it is very abrupt development. The main character and other psychological depictions are also inadequate, so I felt the behavior of the character very abruptly.
The character, tempo, atmosphere was the best.
Although the composition of the last one was disappointing, it is basically like a short editing, so I think that you can enjoy it enough except for that part.
However, the change in the drawing was clearly said in the first half and the second half, it was enough to receive the impression of a completely different work.
However, from this work, I felt the great possibility to overwhelm the bad points if good points of laughter fits.
I am also a person who fits in a key and personally like this work personally, but as I am writing above, it is not a work that I can recommend to myself from myself.
Therefore, the evaluation is "good".
2008/05/26 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by goodday0220 (Skip) Provider: 24221 Host:24340 Browser: 3491
Although it is in the position of Moe cartoon for the time being,
If you compare it with Nagareboshima and your master, drawing is too bad.
The contents are also pretty bad, it is a place where I am looking for and I can not find an interesting place.
Although it is no doubt that this work is the worst,
Is it better to praise the place where it lasted about 3 years.
2007/07/27 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by シャル (Skip) Provider: 1407 Host:1251 Browser: 5598
The point that the picture change is too violent, the number of service scenes, the behavior of some characters, I was uncomfortable because the words were reading.
Especially the change of drawing was fatal, I thought the imbalance of parts of the character's face and outline was terrible at the beginning. I thought that the second half had stabilized somewhat ....
Still, there are several stories that I can enjoy and there are places I think are interesting, so I make the evaluation "bad".
2006/08/22 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by オゾン圏 (Skip) Provider: 14180 Host:13972 Browser: 3694
There are many points that do not agree with this comic, and the disadvantage is that considers that it was made that there was no factor thought "Well good".
I dismissed the position of the hero
The collapse of the drawing was terrible (I forgot what the story is, but the episode where Milky becomes a child has a bad face and body balance)
I was able to read the expansion of the last three episodes to some extent (it is expected to be restored after all, in the middle)
Besides Cosplay and Clerk of the 1 st story with Mayuzumi Hiroyuki I did not like it much
Epilogue (6 volumes of bonus)
Even if I saw it as a comedy, I was not able to laugh so much, so the evaluation was "worst"
2006/03/24 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by ペリカン (Skip) Provider: 14261 Host:14144 Browser: 4184
Although the picture was rather poor, I was more concerned about the lack of composition of the work than the bad picture.
(Probably) When I saw "debuffy things" that was a debut work, I was wondering why I could debut.
Although there is not any hint of the main character, it is the ability of magic sudden abrupt suddenly in the second half, and when the bad guy said "When you are 〓〓〓〓〓〓" I can not keep up with it completely.
It is a way that it was 〓〓〓〓〓〓without this author's hint, so the reader can not keep up with it.
The configuration is so much that you want to doubt that you are in charge properly, often with the second half punchless making the first half events meaningless.
It is not possible to distinguish the characters, there is no difference in the face other than the hairstyle, it is deadly that the picture is poor even though it is Moe cartoon.
If you do seriously you are always going to gag.
I think simply as a manga artist is not enough.
2006/02/02 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by jack (Skip) [Good:2(100%) Normal:0(0%) Bad:0(0%)] / Provider: 44869 Host:44939 Browser: 4184
Impression that it can not be read well though it was time to read or to start serialization,
Pictures from the neighborhood of artetery. As the story got even worse and harder,
I did not read anything at the end.
As a picture can be borne, the story is boring in one pattern anyway.
New character appearance 〓〓〓seemingly serious story - in fact it was 〓〓〓〓〓〓- (Gag Ochi)
Repeat this. I did not know at all what I wanted to do.
Serious things are also very common, and I can not feel the motivation of the authors clearly.
Manga that guts posed at the end of the series even afterwards, is this alone?
Evaluation is "worst"
2006/01/23 Very Bad(-2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by らんさいわ (Skip) Provider: 40229 Host:40199 Browser: 7915
I'm sorry, I can not keep up with the dramatic change in paintings and I do not read it till the end (I am buying up to 4 volumes in front of Afta.
I do not read magazines as standard.
So, if you evaluate quickly.
〓〓〓Picture 〓〓〓... Why did you need to change it so far?
Okay, I wrote a short comment in the postcards, "Every time writing style will change".
Well I think that it is a good thing to write various things and look for something that fits yourself.
Why is it a commercial magazine ... Do you change it so far in the middle of a series?
Commercial magazines are mainly commercial, it is not a place to see the reaction of how to draw a picture?
No ... There are many things that the picture changes certainly during serialization.
It is natural that there is a change because it is written by humans. It will be fine as well.
Just ... I do not know how to change the character picture so far.
And ... it became only bitches.
〓〓〓Story basic gag. However, gag is also slightly subtle many things (only sweat ... you may like to talk to the kindness system.
There is no consistency in the story, there is an impression like a short story.
〓〓〓Comprehensive The picture is a bit painful, is not it?
It seems that I was told that I was injured with the left hand and hurt his handedness (sweat
Evaluation person is ...
I will attach it.
A dramatic preference to change the atmosphere of cartoons so far, I thought how about after-sales.
The content ... I think it is okay.
2005/11/11 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by ウミ (Skip) Provider: 10031 Host:9833 Browser: 5533
I think that everyone's character is unique and I liked it well.
Tempo is good also in terms of speech, I will read it next.
While setting well, the story development that attracts it is good, it is impressed.
There seems to be some people who are poor at drawing, but in the case of this manga artist, it is still the first serial work, so I expect it to grow in the future.
The picture changes too much because this manga artist is still in the growth stage. Although it is not stable in this work,
Later on the picture will also be stabilized.
As a technology, there are places where the drawing is crazy, but I think that the way of shadowing is very good.
With a stable picture and drawing skill, if it gets on, it is a stick to a demon!
Did you forced to finish like you want to end up like going into a book?
The story before the story going into the final round is a pool, it's too abrupt.
It may have been told to let it go as if it comes to a book.
I also wrote the first, but the tempo is good, the story is good so if you have not read yet,
Why do not you read it once?
I'd appreciate reading this comment and increasing the number of fans of demon encyclopedia even by one person.
2005/06/17 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by 金城ゆうりる (Skip) Provider: 7042 Host:6927 Browser: 3875
Moe type conspicuous that stands out in recent cancer.
Although the story is not interesting so far, the tempo is good, manga which stops as it is drawn into nature and starts reading once.
I felt that the development that ran from the next one was easy to read.
I had a good impression on characters with full of individuality.
I think that it is one of the characteristics of this manga that the style of painting changes dramatically in the three-year series.
I personally liked the picture per 3 to 4 volumes the best.
Personally in the latter half of the series, I was sorry that the balance of painting collapsed a little, I think that further progress could be expected in the future.
It is regrettable that it is ended serialization which seems to be somewhat brute force.
In his work is a piece that enters the best 3 with cancer. Therefore, the evaluation is changed from "very good" to "best!"
2005/04/14 Normal comment [Original Japanese review]
by クラウル (Skip) Provider: 11544 Host:11672 Browser: 5407
It has a lot of bad reputation, so I am concerned and browsed by book off. Tentatively, evaluation up to two volumes.
... ... It's not as bad as I thought.
It was difficult to have a part where the picture was rough and lacked in existence, and even though it seemed that there was a lot of idiotic stories after a single episode, well, still, I did not have a bad impression anyhow. In other words, there is no particular impression if it says anything, aside from being a book, it seems that it would be awful when it comes to reading this in series, it was a kind of feeling that the translations were unfamiliar.
Regarding the skills of painting, roughness is quite conspicuous (at least it is hard to say that it is good) as described above, but the composition and the manner of taking in between are not bad, and gags can not be laughing, but it was not a substitute like to dislike strongly like〓〓〓〓〓
The theme seems to be unlikely, but I do not expect it from the edge, so this has no problem.
In general, "Impression that it is not good to collect, but not as bad as predicted in advance" is the impression of the present situation. It is a feeling that is neither poison nor medicine.
...... I wonder if the impression will change again when all are read.
2004/12/18 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by プーさん (Skip) Provider: 13417 Host:13318 Browser: 4184
Anyway, I liked the story quite a bit. There may not be any other manga that has such a violent change in picture so far. (Haha maybe the first person was mashi personally
The story may have been a little too much female characters, if you increase the man a little more and increase the gags you can do it to the highest ^ ^
The personality of the character is also good (I also feel a little strong, but when I make it this time I want you to go forward with gags, blurred people ^ ^
2004/12/18 Not favorite comment [Original Japanese review]
by エスパー (Skip) Provider: 49994 Host:49991 Browser: 3875
It is still worst level enough to enter five fingers in the past Gangan work.
Well finally it came to be cropped so I do not care, but I feel like closing with a gag comic next time.
Drawing Moe cartoons with this pattern is wrong itself.
2004/12/16 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by ヴぁんどれん (Skip) Provider: 32089 Host:32030 Browser: 3875
There is no particular point to mention particularly about the story. I wonder why it is posted in the cancer gun.
Although evaluation is good, evaluation is normal.
2004/12/09 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by タロ堂 (Skip) Provider: 39686 Host:39712 Browser: 4184
Changes in painting are painful, but I think that others are fine. Although the story is coming, I have devised details and I think that it is good that many characters are unique. ... except for one person, but.
Since it is a manga that I personally support a lot, evaluation is "highest!"
2004/11/23 Favorite comment [Original Japanese review]
by ルキファウス (Skip) Provider: 36976 Host:37128 Browser: 4585
I bought 1 to 5 volumes.
Although I was watching 0 episodes, the difference in the picture was awesome compared to the last episode (I am not worried but I do not mind such a thing.
I thought about personality as well, I heard that it is bad that it is good to be there.
Mr. Nakayama wrote a work that read "Let's fix things broken" before reading.
I'd like to read it once and for what reason.
2004/11/14 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by 瑠葉 (Skip) Provider: 54400 Host:54549 Browser: 3874
I read it last time. I think that it was quite good.
This person is a good way to show coma. I am not good at drawing.
I would like to call it with expectations for reading. . .
2004/11/14 Normal comment [Original Japanese review]
by エスパー (Skip) Provider: 37963 Host:37990 Browser: 3875
The final round was not too bad ... Ahahahaha.
Well, are you reading on your next round of powers? Do you read it?
Recently I am glad that the degree of Moe of Gangan is decreasing (lol
2004/11/14 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by ルキファウス (Skip) Provider: 36976 Host:37128 Browser: 4585
I think that I can go quite well on a speechless basis.
It would be nice to say that the picture is also good.
When you compare the first picture of the first picture with the picture of the present, the picture clearly changed too much.
I think that it is strange how much everything is.
So I will not go to the highest and I will keep it so good.
But I guess the story is quite satisfactory and I hope that others will read it once.
2004/10/28 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by 斉藤 (Skip) Provider: 22029 Host:21820 Browser: 5879
The story is haphazard and the picture changes as well and it's not cute at all. Taka picture Kimoi.
While it is a Moe cartoon, watching while it is kimoi etc. can only be said as fatal.
It is difficult to see the commentary on the menu. I want to tell my head why it is on a commercial magazine.
Say clearly and it is the worst manga of the point 0.
If I think, it will be over next month. It was good.
2004/10/17 Favorite comment [Original Japanese review]
by 異邦人 (Skip) Provider: 12380 Host:12520 Browser: 4487
I thought that the end was close in the talk stream, are you already?
I thought that this one was more interesting than Ai Ranjima. Disagreeable.
Even though my rankings have recently become higher and color pages have also increased.
>> Is it said that the face was crushed vertically? Yes. In the early days it is a landscape face. Now the face length.
I do not like the notice of 4 volumes.
"Fierce romance otaku Vain and the words ..."
Wait a moment !! Vane is not a romance otaku?
It was a child who came to apologize for not being able to say anything when Arteri was torn.
What is such a good girl is "romance otaku"? What are you thinking?
Also, "CM Alchemist" was at the time of anime broadcast, CM of the first generation.
CM of a song called "Dandan, Sudan!"
"Hagaren" "Spiral" "PAPUWA" "Halle gow" ... and the image will flow.
Watching it slowly with slow playback, "Demon Encyclopedia" was at the end.
I do not even get the image of "Dorakue" which is always at the last in Gangan. Wow
To say is one of the works that supports the popular four pieces of work in shadows. Right.
(Although I feel like attaching it.
The series lasted nearly three years but the last .... I feel sad,
"This is the policy of the world" It is useless because it is not.
In the meantime, I think that the appendix of "demon script" is only about postcard .... I wonder, is not it?
2004/10/16 Not favorite comment [Original Japanese review]
by 暁のドンキー (Skip) Provider: 7466 Host:7395 Browser: 3646
Oh ... I have not read it so in the comments.
Character ... what it says, this way, it says something like that the face was crushed vertically.
The picture is not very good. The story seems not interesting at all. I got tired of 3 pages.
2004/10/16 Normal comment [Original Japanese review]
by 瑠葉 (Skip) Provider: 51734 Host:51928 Browser: 3874
Have you thought that it has become interesting these days? Are you going to be the last one next month ... ?!
I thought it somehow but I finally like this work.
What is the way to finish the last round? I am looking forward to it.
2004/09/19 Normal comment [Original Japanese review]
by 異邦人 (Skip) Provider: 12380 Host:12535 Browser: 4487
___ = Gentiles Because you can not write with the same name. Excuse me.
2004/09/19 Favorite comment [Original Japanese review]
by 異邦人 (Skip) Provider: 12380 Host:12535 Browser: 4487
I bought the whole volume with the merit of this month issue.
3.4 Volume. It was really impressed.
Psychological depiction is good.
In the first evaluation, "Pattern is cheap" but it was corrected.
I got used to seeing it. It is not that crowded as I see it.
It is a setting to listen in various places to a woman whose main character is a man,
What to say ....
There are various circumstances to gather, it is a personality.
It is a manga that can sympathize with any character.
It seems like a little punctuation, but it is exactly like this because it makes you awkward if you are serious.
Clearly, I like the steel next to gangan.
However, Hiroyuki's younger sister, broke from the place where Ayumi came out.
Although it is right, my sister liked my older brother ... I pulled.
If only that character is not there, it is the best, but why?
Anyway I want you to animate seriously.
Character Moe etc No matter. I hope the impression of this work is transmitted ....
2004/09/15 Favorite comment [Original Japanese review]
by かお (Skip) Provider: 50588 Host:50596 Browser: 4487
This month's issue was amazing ...!
Especially the last page. I am going to cry.
The way to show the screen is on the inside. Wonder. I am good at expressing emotions.
I wonder if it is near the last round. Flow of talk.
I will give you that I was bad.
Even if I said anything ... I have this comic.
I wanted "an evil spirit" more animated than "This is my husband".
I do not want animation, but I want a drama CD around.
2004/09/06 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by すいる (Skip) Provider: 31975 Host:31977 Browser: 3874
The picture is terrible. It is too cruel. There are plenty of heads whose heads are larger than their shoulder widths, but most of them are not so unnatural.
But, it is unnatural.
If it is the same Moe Manga, Grepelli seems more interesting. It is no wonder why this manga does not end and other cartoons disappear.
2004/09/06 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by エスパー (Skip) Provider: 13417 Host:13166 Browser: 3875
Previously evaluated as "very bad", we will drop it to "worst".
When summarizing the reasons for it ...
〓〓〓Moe will not. Or rather it looks like a Moe cartoon. It is not good to see it by gag.
〓〓〓The drawing is strange. In a word "Kimoi". It is not human. Is not it a human being? (Some except (3) There are many characters that do not need, since we can not divide the drawing further, it is just a copy.
〓〓〓The story is boring. It is common. Is it being serialized using the stupid story? ...
〓〓〓make the reader feel uncomfortable. I'd like to say I'm funny.
I will make it "worst" by the above points.
It is a work that I want you to disappear like a certain master in the current Gangan work.
2004/09/06 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by かお (Skip) Provider: 12380 Host:12624 Browser: 4487
> I like the early one Yes.
I'm with you.
Recently purchased 1.2 volumes. The first picture is different as I thought "Wow ...? Different comic?"
Early, caterpillar that pure Milky was cute. But it was clumsy.
It came only when I came along with a mental scene, but that's it.
There was nothing in any way.
Recently, it is.
While it was the face of the initial horizontal width system, it became a face length system.
It's cheerful to say clearly. Now the first one was better.
I thought that the author 's arms went up but not at all.
I got back to bad. I am scared of kimo.
2004/09/05 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by 雨月 (Skip) Provider: 29898 Host:29767 Browser: 5978
I think that it is quite funny, but the picture has changed a bit.