[Comics]Akatyan to boku

  • Cute
  • Made me think
  • Shed tears
  • Enjoyed
  • Impressed
  • Friendship
  • Interesting
  • Funny
RSS
Other media: Anime:Baby and me
Comics total pnts rank Rank 175in 8,220 titlesTotal 61 / Deviation 66.19
Comics avg pnts Rank 187in 1,299 titlesAvg 1.85=Very good/33 reviews
Comics rank of 1991 Rank 4in 123 titles
Statics of evaluation and Ranking
Reviews' statics
Post review by myself
Character/Setting2.71(Best)7
Picture2.57(Best)7
Story2.57(Best)7
Cute86%6/7
Made me think86%6/7
Shed tears71%5/7
Enjoyed71%5/7
Impressed71%5/7
Friendship57%4/7
Interesting57%4/7
Funny57%4/7
Sad29%2/7
Moral29%2/7
Cool29%2/7
Sexy14%1/7
Beautiful14%1/7
Scareful14%1/7
Learned something14%1/7
Hot heart0%0/7
Brave0%0/7
Romantic0%0/7
Shocked0%0/7
Poll
Information about this title

Marimo Ragawa
HAKUSENSHA
Hana to yume Comics
Japan Released:1991 Hana to Yume / End:1997
40,3653433
Recently views
4826463223
  Limit by opinioin
Search in this page

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post your review to English version, please click here.
2015/12/08 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 273 Host:588 Browser: 10247
[good point]
Baby is cute

[Bad point]
It is a story that the mother died soon and the older brother fought hard for the baby troublesome. I could cry at the setting point, but I could not cry at all whether I was expecting too much. .

[Comprehensive evaluation]

I read only the 1st volume and the last volume, but it seemed like omnibus format and it was betrayed in a bad way first. Especially the last volume is too severe, sudden the baby is bounced on the four wheels w My mother chants Zhaolik from Heaven to a baby in a coma as what is terrible, so the baby revives with full recovery (without aftereffect) The story ends ... That's suddenly incorporated fantasy elements into a realistic story!
By the way, a different story caused the man to be bounced up in two wheels ... Is the writer grown up in a bad environment of transportation manners ... well, let 's pay close attention to anyone who does not ride a car either!

2015/05/04 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 45568 Host:45425 Browser: 8080
It is manga I was reading when I was a primary school student.
From that time I loved to read junior high and high school students from time to time.
Currently it is 30, I gave birth to my daughter last year.
I gave birth to a daughter, I wanted to read baby and I like somehow for some reason, I got an excerpt when I went back home to GW.
Especially the story that I forgot to forget the past is the story of Shiho Mama who has a baby of 6 months.
My daughter is six months now.
As for the story, Shiho mama hits the baby with child rearing neuroses. I will never be beating or rough, but when I've been crying for a long time, there are times when I do not like it anymore.
Takuya said that there was nothing I thought was cute when the fruit was a baby as I read through. And, when I had a sad face I advised that I actually had a sad face, and laughing when I laugh.
Tears stopped stopping at that scene.

I read it while I was a student, I was reading while wondering whether Mama is such a painful thing, and now it is exactly what Miho Momma feels like.
And, advice from Takuya.
It became a positive GW with positive feelings and gentle feelings.
My favorite manga (* ^ _ ^ *)

2015/04/20 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 1835 Host:1764 Browser: 8953
From this work I became a fan of Mr. Raokawa's work, I read it all.
I love them all, but I like this work the most among all of them.
Takuya Good girl too much.

2014/08/13 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 16535 Host:16606 Browser: 5171
It seems that it was a popular work, but because there was no chance to read until now ...

Synopsis is that a 12-year-old boy who lost his mother will take care of his 2-year old brother.
There are marriages, pregnancy, maternal problems, bullying problems, child abuse, etc., family, childcare issues in general.
I heard that "Hana to Yume" was a publication magazine, I thought that I was setting the target age a little bit lower, but this would cover the readers of high school students and higher enough.

There are other girls' manga works that boys get parenting and getting involved with family problems there, but there are other "babe I love you", but this work is in addition to the hero's point of sight, from the point of view of the surrounding people There are quite a few stories that talk about family problems.
In that sense, I also feel that it is "pocket" which lowered the target age.

I think that it is a work that is made with a very gentle tone in general, it is a work that can be read without stress, but I hesitate to be kind a bit too gentle.

It is common also with "Pokkakoka" mentioned earlier, but you can stay as it is, there are many stories about the color tone that you do not have to push yourself.
This may be due to the reading of a man by myself, but I feel such an impression, but I think that it is impossible for some surrounding adults to be a little more than a child.
But, if you draw on such a gentle route, it will deviate from the reader's layer of "Hana to Yume" and this is the correct answer for this.

Also, since the reputation of reading was good, it is often in serial work as it is, but when it comes to the latter half of serialization it will inevitably clog the story. Clearly this work can be seen in the second half.

As a general review, I think that it is a nice work that you can read with a gentle feeling so evaluate "good".

2011/06/22 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 3805 Host:3854 Browser: 9927
Basically I have not read girls' comics as I am a man

However, since I also animated and I was trying to explore girls' comic at that time, I was reading this manga

Eldest son who lost her mother looks after younger brother and grows while being surrounded by the surrounding warm people Talk here I read very much and I feel very girls cartoonish ...

To men 's servant it did not echo to that extent, and it was a feeling that it would be "slightly hurting" Please forgive that the target of the work is the impression of the person who is different

Surely a good work I would like to read over again in a few years

Although it is a premise, I think that the collaboration with Shingo that was on the end of "130 centimeters of dandy" was good, that degree of freedom or faultlessness is the same world view, or surprisingly I live in a neighborhood I am very happy as a reader with more fun of imagining etc.

2011/03/09 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 21793 Host:21961 Browser: 9366
[good point]
With laughter There are tears
I think that any person can read it I think it is easy to read

[Bad point]
Especially I can not think of it

[Comprehensive evaluation]

I think that it is a manga that a parent possesses the memory that he had been reading because of its influence but he did not get tired but had been reading for a while as elementary school student probably a small child ~ adult

Very good

2010/10/30 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 623 Host:427 Browser: 12270
A quite famous manga.
Is there anything to be found in elementary and junior high schools?
To tell the story there is too much content of the story, but as the theme is the story of fruit and takuya being a baby.
This comic is superior is not simply adding a strange thing other than merely multiplying a boy by maternity. I think that it is a framework setting for elementary school students because it is only fatherhood for young people. After all, Takuya 's father and Takuya are different from the attitude towards fruit. Ancient and east-west, a boy with maternity becomes a picture.

The talk is also excellent. Some of the story of bank robbery, such as a story of a robbery, there is not so much feeling that there is no crazy feeling, but the talk of encounter of parents and the story of a boy who dreams of dreams began to become immature and delicate adolescence It is good to draw children's mind. Takuya talked about the stomach hurts, Oh, I was made a nostalgic feeling that there was something strangely caught by people 's unnecessary words like this. Of course, I forgot it now.
It was a good writer to capture people's minds by age. There are truly characters of various ages, but everyone has different ways of catching things, the problem to face is also different, the adults 'children' s troubles are small things, there are also pre - established values Inside there was a directing ability to make me think so. In essence, it was a writer who draws psychology many.
Last was somewhat steep, but as an end it was an iron plate.

I could read it without getting tired on the whole.
Unlike love girls' cartoons, they can read without regard to age and sex.

2009/07/22 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 12213 Host:12172 Browser: 6399
I felt it was a baby only in the early stage and after that I felt it was an infant, but I guess it was funny as usual ~
Personally I liked the child of the reverse sexual harassment (I forgot the name).
Episode of father and Mrs. bag was a good story.

2009/07/22 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 43387 Host:43354 Browser: 6307
Characters are really attractive. Psychological depiction full of humanity is superb.
Some insane people will also appear ... lol That is also funny.
It was good to draw Takuya-kun of the main character (?), Harumi of Papa, Brother's fruit, episodes surrounding the three from various perspectives.
Heartwarming, tears, guts ... It was rich in content.

I cried at the end really.
On the whole, bad guys rarely come out. Without good and evil,
Each one lives by each circumstance, there is a case that it hurts at times.
I think that I would like to highly appreciate the fact that I was making such a story. Evaluation is "very good".

2009/04/24 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 34710 Host:34559 Browser: 2982(Mobile)
[good point]
Beginning with fruit and Takuya, you can have attachment to everyone in the characters.
Takuya is not just a good girl, but as a result of digesting various emotions within herself,
It is a convincing character that there is Takuya now.
There are many stories that almost no protagonists Takuya and Takuya appear,
Since the setting of each character is solid and the theme has unity,
You can enjoy a wide variety of stories without discomfort.
I draw a warm, but sharp point of view from the good side which arises in the relationship of family, friends to the difficult side,
I feel the depth that I can not finish with a good story.
There are few characters that look like they are wearing.

[Bad point]
Everybody leaves too much to care for young children (preschool children) to other people and elementary school children,
Although it is a manga more than 10 years ago, though it is on the setting to draw such cartoons,
As a parent with a child there is quite a sense of incongruity and it does not come nicely.
Even if there are adults with a lead, will they let their 3 year old child go on a trip without leaving?
Although Enoki family can not be helped, anything that is similar to Goto family and Fujii family whatever is wrong.
I feel like "childcare is what everyone does" or "big child rearing" or such level.
From the same point of view, I think that it is impossible for Ichika and Maru to go out alone with just two people.
Despite the fact that we still have such areas still, we also contradict the development of the last.
Everyday events and feelings in child rearing have very reality,
It was strange that I could not completely err in the irresponsibility of adults as above.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Even if I deducted the feeling of strangeness I wrote in a bad point, the content of the story itself was wonderful, I was satisfied with reading.
I do not get tired of it though it has many turns, but I think that the balance is also good.
There was also a story that I felt personally boring (such as a story of baseball against class)
Most of the stories had tears with laughter, troubles with warm hearted conviction, psychological depictions were able to sympathize well.
However, because it is not a type of story that is a matter of continuity, it took a period of time to finish reading from the large number of volumes.
Because people of various positions are picked up, I think that it is a work that you can enjoy even if you read it many times after years of age.
The story of 88 story is cute at its best.
A wonderful work that a child wants to read as well.

2009/01/30 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 9631 Host:9504 Browser: 8090
My family relationship, Takuya and Goku and my child's care and something were good. I was surprised at the last, real matter, but it was ok and it was ok.

2008/09/04 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 13991 Host:13981 Browser: 2983(Mobile)
A story of an elementary school boy and a younger brother.

However, there are many main stories of characters other than these two people, and no matter how many times I read it, I can not afford it.

As well as talking about families and friends, I draw the importance of childcare realistically, I think that it is a work with a high quality with laughter and impression.

Evaluation is to be "close to the highest" very good "." The quality of the work is the highest, but it is not because I am addicted.

If there is a bad place, is it that the early picture (it can not be helped) and the fruit of the climax were too selfish. Though it is a child to say selfishness.

2008/06/15 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 48725 Host:48752 Browser: 6342
I think that I will take care of my baby and my family more, a manga full of family love full of love.
It seems purely "wonderful" that the whole family grows, overcoming fighters and conflicts.
The process in which elementary school students of one parent substitute for their mothers and gradually decreasing the minor who disliked the beginning was also convincing, it makes me think that it is reasonable.

Last was a common story, I think it was necessary to describe how important Minor was to the family as a shime.

Evaluation is "very good". It is a very good quality manga that made me feel bad for children.
Housewives, those who have babies inside. Why do not you read it?

2008/05/18 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 8093 Host:8162 Browser: 6342
It is pretty tight turns, but I do not get tired of Iroiro episodes.
Although I think many people think that it is a "warm hearted" system from the title, but, of course, there are disappointing stories and frustrating things after the midfield, the inner face of adolescence such as sex and conflict is drawn deeply. (Do you dig into too much for girls' comics?)
There are dark talks and unreasonable stories, but ...,,,, That is why Ryo is a good work.
Come if you are unread. I have not seen anime version. Since it is doubtful how far this episode group could be digested in a certain cool, please also look at those who saw it. There may be new discoveries.

2008/01/26 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 14505 Host:14271 Browser: 6391
I love this manga, but ... Personally I do not like the deployment of the final stage so much .... Well it was an inspiring development, so it seems that people like it are fine though.

There was quite a shocking story besides the last one, though. There was also a story where a person died.
Among them, the story of Yumemishi who received the most impact. No way to talk about Yumeji seriously in a girl's manga ... Even though she was quite surprised when her physiological story appeared in the light blue era.

2007/11/14 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 34055 Host:34016 Browser: 4184
Since the animation was a work of contents that is quite heartwarming, I read and watched the original with interest, but ..........

[good point]

〓〓〓heart-warming atmosphere

Like an animated version, there were many things that made me readily feel comfortable. Especially the acquaintance of Harumi Papa, brother who was bad returned to the town, reconciliation with parents and the child got well safely, focused on Takuya-kun's friend (bad friend?) Fujii-kun's family Although it was full of stories and variety, if you give a good story to usual it is not that you have time to list it all at once.

〓〓〓a hero who can empathize normally

While listening to such an atmosphere, the most important point is that Takuya-kun was a very good child. I was able to study, I was blessed with my friends,
It may have been said to a girl of a classmate also "an ideal boy" such as Motel, but it is truly pure.

I told you that there were a lot of heartwarming stories, but not only that but it is bad for me to know the circumstances of marriage between Harumi and the deceased mother
(No, it was never the case.) And Haruemi tears in Papa,
Removing the mother's parent's house There was a very tasty story that flew away from the fruit of Haruomi Papa and impressive reunion in bad weather, where the son was about to adopt because his son died.

However, as well as mentioning them, the name episode that such a character again gave a glimpse is a story of a transfer student, he is a terrible disgusting guy, he is bullying for his brother to Takuya from bullshit envy, I also try to steal school lunch expenses, put on wet clothing Takuya-kun
(Although classmates said that "Takuya-kun could not do such a thing !!" showed correspondence, it was salvation.) However, in reality it has a complex family environment Takuya-kun who was married because of parents' heart diseases as well as parents and still growing up in a family without mothers talked with each other in naked hearts can do it well Because it was not such a dark story,
If I was a Takuya-kun's position I could break up and talk about it ........

I really would like to have such a friend, or child,
He can be truly respected from the bottom of my heart. When I later said to school excursion to Kyoto, I met again with him who transferred again in a short time,
It looked pretty good looking. Takuya-kun was the savior of such a transfer student, could you say "owner of the golden spirit"?

[Bad point]

There is nothing in particular.

[Comprehensive evaluation]

Anime was also pretty good, but I think that the original work was also a manga of contents that could be said as a masterpiece. In Bunko version 12 or 13, Mr. Mitsuru Miyamoto of Harumi Papa was explained, but I wanted to see the animated version again. When Mr. Kappei Yamaguchi also saw it in real time, I did not think so much, but since last summer I was told again that he was a master of the role of a boy.
Even the original cartoon will be considered as "best!" Without complaint ............

2007/08/04 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 11920 Host:11849 Browser: 4184
It is a work that crushed all my thoughts on my girls' manga.
Probably the comic that we could laugh and cry so far is about this.
Although I felt that Takuya was a bit too firm, even though weak places were also written, it was a favorable character.

Although it is a dark story setting "My older brother who has decided to take care of his younger brother (baby) with his mother died, but he did not feel the darkness at all, and this dark setting turned into such a readable work Feel the competence of the author.

Works that can be recommended for everyone. I also thought about making it the best, but there were also stories which I disliked quite often (after talking about a transfer student, since the last round is a bit heavy, I was tough to read, because it is a bit heavy), so the overall evaluation is "very good".

2007/06/23 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 19847 Host:19737 Browser: 11603(Mobile)
I love my baby and I. Actually you and Takuya's struggle were interesting. Please give me the story after that last round because it is also a special edition.

2007/04/24 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 29549 Host:29854 Browser: 8090
[Comprehensive evaluation]
Red me was when I was in elementary school. So boys coming out are cool 〓〓〓
Why is it different from the reality ... Well it often goes into the world of red red meat (smile)
Anyway it was funny. The picture was also cute and I loved it.

2007/02/15 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 13014 Host:13082 Browser: 6342
I thought it was fun when I read it when I was small. And I thought it was fun to read back now.

As this is because the hero is an elementary school student, I think that some people think that it is for elementary school students.
However, not only the main character, Takuya's story, but also his brother and dad, a relationship with his neighborhood is drawn so I think that it is a work that can be enjoyed even by adults.

It is very creative and crying works. The end is nothing but a touching thing.
I think that it is a work that absolutely does not have regrets after reading.

2006/10/08 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 36497 Host:36414 Browser: 5234
It may be my favorite in girls' cartoons.
A family whose mother died, Harumi Papa and elementary school student Takuya and a baby's fruit.
The exchange between these three people and many people involved in the three people is wonderful.
Everyone is holding various complexes and troubles, and they are burdened with one person alone,
Someone extended their hands to such characters (three leading characters also included)
I was cried many times in the depiction which became a cornerstone of my heart.
The final round was pretty much over, but it is a really good manga.

2006/09/16 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 42467 Host:42269 Browser: 3874
This manga is taking care of his younger brother (small in progressive form) since the elementary school's older brother is small because the mother is overwhelming with the two leading brothers who are 8 years old (9 years old) old .

Of particular importance in this manga is the story that calls for the accuracy and sympathy of psychological depiction.
Below is the psychology and conflict of the characters covering from 0-year-old children up to the elderly, conflicts through differences in thinking by age difference and values, superiority feeling, feeling of inferiority, feelings of guilt that everyone felt through the characters I will link it with my past.

Especially since I was a younger brother who was older, I was in a similar situation in real time at the time of serialization
(Although parents are alive and not 2 brothers), the relationship between Takuya and Fruit was very real.

When I'm reading, I recall various things and make me think. I grew up more than anything else
If I read it in one year, five years, ten years, twenty years later, will not you remember a new impression again?

I do not draw 1 to 10 of human emotions, but I think there is a part that I certainly sympathize with,
I will send you a rating of "highest" as a few comedy tears. It is worth reading.

2006/04/01 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 351 Host:422 Browser: 2409
Although it is a work that was read and recommended by people, it is warm hearted and can be likable.
And that is why Mr. Takuya about the occasional mother's absence and real fulfillment are moved.
But Takuya seems to be a bit too firm for elementary school ... I want this brother w!

Personally I love Fujii Brothers and Papan.

Even though I was a girl manga, I did not have a main axis in romance, so I was able to fully enjoy it even by a man of men.
Rather it is a work that I want men to read without prejudice.
Also, since I had this opportunity before, I read it again, when I read as a child I was able to know the various things I did not notice. Is it for adults?

This work deeply in many ways.
Including the story development which can not be described without tears of the final volume, the evaluation is made "very good".

2006/04/01 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 42607 Host:42467 Browser: 4184
I did not remember much of the contents because someone borrowed it, but there was a fun different from the animated version. There were stories that were dark and painful inside, but I think that it was quite a funny story as there were stories that I read back many times. Although the fact was saved by the story of the last traffic accident, it was quite dark. I think that Takuya 's mistake should not have caused an accident to be an infant. It is regrettable that the last story did not clog the last hint that a family member is likely to encounter a traffic accident (Takuya's father's parents and wife).

2005/10/06 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 9051 Host:8849 Browser: 6287
In girls' manga, I personally position it as the best.
There were almost one episode to be completed, so there were also disliked characters and episodes ...
Although it seems to be controversial / disappointing about the last round, I personally think that it was better not to leave as usual everyday but to have a little drama rise.
By the way this cartoon was recommended by a classmate boy and began to read,
I think whether people who are resistant to men and girls' manga can read easily.

2005/10/05 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 52238 Host:52231 Browser: 4483
I think that it is the most work in the category of "girls' manga" that I read until now.
It is not a girl 's cartoon that stands just like love love.
While being heartwarming, I am made to think about gags, seriousness and family love.
After all, the end is touched.

No matter how many times I read it, it is a work that warms me up.

2005/09/26 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 20847 Host:20698 Browser: 3694
After reading a volume with a certain reason, it was very interesting and I bought a whole paperback of the paperback book.
It is a girls' manga, but it was interesting to Fuu regardless of such a thing.

The picture is also pretty beautiful and there was a part that I could fairly sympathize with myself as having my brothers,
Please read this book by anyone who has brothers.

I have avoided girls' cartoons until now, but I thought by looking at this book that interesting cartoons do not have that kind of relationship.

2005/08/22 Favorite comment [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 14124 Host:14401 Browser: 5234
I was advanced to a friend when I was a junior high school student, but I got a lot of fun.
I thought that a man with a sparkling glitter star was the Prince of Hakuba .... It was an image of my girl manga until I read this work, but I thought that the man should not read, but the recognition was 180 It has changed.

2005/08/22 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 2688 Host:2559 Browser: 4397
It was a manga where my favorite story and disliked story were clearly separated.

Talk about my favorite story to go on a school trip Speaking about the story of Tomoko's alumni association Mr. Moriguchi, Fujii and Takenaka quarreling talk until Harumi and Yuka become married
Etc

The story I dislike is going to Hawaii (I feel like it was done) Talibani tries to make friends Talk about you
Etc




Top Page top MetaSeachJP Works