[JP movie]Argentine Hag

Other media: Literature:Argentine Hag
JP movie total pnts rank Rank 2,472in 2,878 titlesTotal -3 / Deviation 45.92
JP movie rank of 2007 Rank 93in 120 titles
Statics of evaluation and Ranking
Reviews' statics
Post review by myself
Made me think50%1/2
Hot heart0%0/2
Shed tears0%0/2
Learned something0%0/2
Information about this title

Nagao Naoki
Yosimoto Banana GENTOSHA INC. Arisa Kaneko Noriyoshi Ikeya
Yoshikazu Suo
Norio Ishii Yasuo Hashimoto
Kouji Yakusho
Maki Horikita
Kyouka Suzuki
Aiko Morishita
Satomi Tezuka
Naoki Tanaka
Kobayashi Yukichi
Daikichi Sugawara
Kenkichi Watanabe
Yumi Sakurai
Kurume Arisaka
Mitsuyo Ishigaki
Mashita Yuki
Ishi Mitsuzo
Saeki Arata
Kawaya Sechin
Furuta Taiga
Kawaguchi Akimasa
Hsahimoto Kurumi
Fukushi Daiki
Inomata Riho
Hajime Inoue
Sawayama Kaoru
Maruyama Honoka
Japan Released:2007/03/24(Sat)
Official sites
1. http://www.arubaba.com/ (Translation)
Recently views
  Limit by opinioin
Search in this page

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post your review to English version, please click here.
2013/12/28 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 15146 Host:15289 Browser: 7858
[good point]
I feel that the set was beautiful.

[Bad point]
Suzuki Kyoka is not Baba at all
My father is too bad
Story not left in impression

[Comprehensive evaluation]
It was a movie I do not know what kind of stance I should appreciate.
Although the story advances mainly about the hero who is suffering from special family circumstances, the characters are not attractive, and their behavior is also weak because they are weak, so they can not sympathize at all.
Is this a comedy?

2010/05/16 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 30580 Host:30332 Browser: 10712
Oh, although I never read the work, there was no one who did not know the name Yoshimoto Banana's original movie ........

The wife who is to be a lifetime companion dies and knows the feeling of sadness, but leave this father and daughter at the same place for more than a year ...........
Normally "Would you like to be a parent or not as a human?" (Bitter smile)
Moreover, it was unnatural that men around other than my sister who was bitter about it were tolerated in the middle, unnatural, finally that Yuri of Argentina aya was awakened by having a child with a father,
Where I apologized to my daughter, I bought her anger as a matter of course,
It is too late. Actually, that sister (that is, my aunt as seen from the hero)
Although he was not in a position to criticize him too strongly as pointed out by a boy of a childhood friendhood of the hero, even if it was eventually blurred and it did not see the way of reflection too much, for anything for my father and Yuri First of all it was useless that the expeditionary development was conspicuous.

For the acting team, I think Diggin Maki was doing his best,
Mr. Suzuki Kyoka thinks that there are not so many soiling people. Elder brother of Tanaka of Cocorico is also a good performer as an entertainer, but ........

Tempo was bad, and I do not know the original, but it was one of the works whose contents did not catch up with the actors' faces. This too.
Well the evaluation is "bad" which is close to "very bad".

2008/06/15 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 5315 Host:5516 Browser: 6342
Evaluation may be divided, but ... I personally like it. The original is unread.
Although I went to see without first expecting, I was drawn into the story that Tintin and spinning were unnoticed and was fascinated by a gentle world view. Although I did not like Suzuki Kyoka of Yuri role, I still have a figure of dancing tango on the apartment floating in my mind.
Each reality escape, each conflict. Each solution. It is fresh and comfortable though it is a scenario for throwing to some extent, leaving the way to receive it to the hand to watch.
I also soaked the screen with plenty of music that colors the movie.
I think it is a "very good" work.

2008/02/04 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 18453 Host:18387 Browser: 5773
Yoshimoto Banana's original is unread.

Only the Suzuki Kyoka and the refreshing remarkable Horikita Maki who can not be seen as an old woman who played Argentine Babaa that remained in the honest impression.

I wrote above, but Suzuki Kyoka is still the most uncomfortable feeling.
It is obvious that Argentina Babaa who is hated, dirty, unspecified in age has a shiny skin and makeup is clearly apparent and apparently mismatches with the character.
Furthermore, it is not a good image too much different from an image, is not it?
Chigara practice is ambiguous, such as Satoru looking funny as it is called a weirdo.

Even if it is content, it is another one.
It is a person who experiences reality that anyone wants to run away, runs away, people who can accept it, people.
It is a reproduction story of a family who depicted the process how to get over it.

Honesty I can not sympathize with my father at all. Certainly I understand the feelings, but why such behavior, it is very cryptic to say what to do.
I do not understand the feeling of making my daughter lose more than half a year.
It seems unnecessary to believe that HORIKITA Maki was a very healthy character.
Just herself, too, from the girls high school girls who usually do not, human nature is not good and expression of emotion is poor.
I think that if they usually collide with each other, they will become emotional.
Although the style of the original may be so, although her own feelings are conveyed during a distinctive period ....

It is Yuri (Argentina Baba) to make a chance to get over it, but the chance is also flying a certain way.
Although it goes in a good direction as a result, it gets a little excited by the deployment which is too convenient for this too.
I would rather have twisted the point that my father and daughter can make bonds with that one too.
Human relations around us are ambiguous and drawn with comedy touch, but lack the balance between serious father and daughter's reproduction story.
Shinichi (cousin)'s character is better with uke.

Another difficulty is that the tempo is bad. I feel like I have been truncated a bit.
The atmosphere is not bad and the bad aftertaste is not too bad.
I think that you can see it conveniently if you think it is fantasy ....
It just seems that the above problem is destroying the style.

2007/11/16 Very Bad(-2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 7683 Host:7691 Browser: 4184
Make Yoshimoto Banana original film a movie. It is like a fantasy, but it is a little slow and it does not seem so.
There is no reality, it's OK with that, but it's not a comedy nor a fairytale, it's a work I do not know what I want to show. Everything is halfway, lacking excitement. Regarding casting, I feel uncomfortable that Suzuki Kyoka who plays lily is too young. It is uncanny gray hair so it can not be helped looking extra strange. Furthermore, it is inevitable that only the mysterious behaviors and actions of all the characters are visible.
It is already boring with just setting self-made Satoru Wakui (Koji Keiji) and Yuri = Argentina Baba (Suzuki Kyoka) and the people around it that properly tolerates it. Even if it comes to peaceful ending as planned, it is just ridiculous in its content. I think that Mitsuko Wakui (Horikita Maki) is gray if it is normal. Although Satoru fled from the death of his wife Ryoko (Tezuka Riomi), that way of escape is not half full. Among various hesitation settings, this behavior of him is amazingly impressive. In the history of movies, it seems that it seems that it is not likely to enter the top 10 male guys. Regrettably, I can not feel so attractive about lily character as well. Just simply a strange woman, there is no gentle aura that wraps everything up.

Perhaps it is a family renewal story, but it could only be seen at the extreme of expeditionism.