[Drama]Team medical dragon
|Statics of evaluation and Ranking|
|Information about this title|
Nagai Akira Taro Nokizaka BIG COMIC SUPERIOR SHOGAKUKAN
Sin Kouno Hiroyulo Sawano
Fuji Television Network, Inc.
|Japan Released:2006/04/13(Thu) Fuji Television Network, Inc. / End:2006/06/29|
- ▼Sorted by:Newness
2013/09/15 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by バルセロニスタ (Skip) Provider: 24937 Host:25061 Browser: 5870
I have read the original manga. An unrealistic genius surgeon is finished in a human drama based on the hero's medical manga as an original.
There are three reasons why you like this work.
One is that it is not a one-man show of Professor Asada who is an unrealistic genius surgeon, but well balanced as a work.
It is not the power of one hero but also the importance of a friend is important.
When Asada drank everyone, the scene which said "It is the best and best team in the end" is cool parenthesis.
The second one is not overlooked by the overwhelming presence of Kenji Sakaguchi who played Mr. Asuda, and he was a doctor of Professor Fujiyoshi Sasaki Kuronosuke,
Abe Sadao, an anesthesiologist's Arase role, Ijuin-in, a trainee of humanity, Ichikusei Kishibe as a villain professor of Noguchi, and each cast cast a presence.
The episode I personally liked was the scene where the sufferings of Aras of the anesthesiologist were depicted and the growth of Ijuin-in.
The former was a little hollowy. Although not related, lack of doctor at obstetrics and gynecology is famous story,
The anesthetic department seems to be quite severe as well, and I think that this work that got a sense of existence of an anesthesiologist who is unlikely to spot as much as possible in that sense was good at rhea.
The latter one was a very important element in the original work and it was okay for me to cherish the drama as well.
As a third point, I felt that I did not notice much of the evil from manga, but rather improved it.
Although there are some differences from manga, what I felt improved was the character setting by Professor Asada.
Well at first it was terrible discomfort, but I think this is all. The atmosphere of the work has changed drastically by changing the character setting of Mr. Asada.
As for this, I think it is a great success though I can hardly say it because it would be different ways of viewing individuals.
Although it is hard to express in words, I think that it turned into a work that creates a heavy atmosphere compared to the original work.
The relationship between Kirishima and Professor Kato is also not evil. The only regret was the last round.
It was not Kihara 's mother that he was brought in a state of death, but Kirishima. I have laughed at this.
Personally I liked Kihara episode, so it can be a shame or change, it's a bit disappointing.
I wish I had wanted to ask Mr. Asada to desperately ask Kimuro for tears and runny noses as full of myself ....
And I think that both the theme song of music and the inserted song were the best.
The original was long and I think that the place to put a break was not bad either.
Anyway, I think that it is all that I changed the character setting of Professor Asada as mentioned in the third point.
Relentlessly, Mr. Asada's casting was good.
It is as close as possible to the highest possible.
2009/02/13 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by 11号 (Skip) Provider: 13473 Host:13308 Browser: 4926
The content is exactly a medical drama.
Every time for surgery, it is easy for the viewer to understand, and when I explain the explanation of the surgical method with CG, the production was very good.
I thought that it was honestly cool! (Laugh) Honestly I was touched a bit (explosion)
While the Batista team is formed, [nurse], [researcher], [physician], [anesthesiologist]
In light of the trauma of doctors in various fields including the field, problems currently held,
I enjoyed it even at the part where the talk is developed ... especially the story of "Arase".
Also, another good part is a ruthless word with a fancy 'Noguchi' (lol)
Do you like crab dumpling, you like wine, do you like Yahashi?
I smiled to skip the unnecessary doctors to hospitals outside the prefecture (laugh)
Lastly, though I thought that Noguchi himself liked Tom Ye Kun, he told me that he liked it, when he himself suits the same eyes, he went crazy.
But there are bad parts in this drama ...
That is because only the doctors were picked up, and the story of the patient side was not drawn so much ... Well, I think that there is no choice but I felt something insufficient in the area there ...
Well, I enjoyed it so the evaluation was "good".
2008/01/26 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by 赤い水性のシャア (Skip) Provider: 12661 Host:12510 Browser: 3034(Mobile)
Because it is a medical drama, it is inevitable that many technical terms are entered, but it is good to understand because it will explain firmly.
This drama is good for directing and music. It is a bit too cool. There seems to be no possibility of an operation transcendence technique, but this is better because it is a drama.
Although the original is unread, since I kept watching it happily, the evaluation is "very good".
2007/12/15 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by 樹梨葉 (Skip) Provider: 32099 Host:31924 Browser: 2864(Mobile)
Because I do not know the original at all, I could see it without discomfort. If I play a villain, I immediately am addicted to Kimura Kazuki, if you do an unusual middle-aged, Ikemi Kishibe an excellent piece. I do not think that special performance is good, but Mari Natsuki who has an eye for some reason. Individualist actor Abe Sadao. Veteran, I thought that the supporting player had a presence. There are many works set in the hospital, but the next was the enjoyment since the white huge building. However, I would like to show God-level skills, I feel that there was not a depiction expression to be impressed a bit. But it was quite funny, so this evaluation.
2007/10/20 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by 十傑集 (Skip) Provider: 11009 Host:11078 Browser: 5234
The original is unread. It will be called another medical drama as a comparison subject.
Kishibe Kazunori is still a monster if you play a monster-fighting dancer's father as usual.
There was a terrible glimpse of what seemed like a villainary justice, "A selfish patient who was inspired by the massacre though the doctor was cutting his life."
(There is something like a confusion with a super-class hotel that is one of the world's leading hospitals in his concept)
However, besides his presence, I did not feel anything unique to this work.
If a medical doctor or nurse as a supporting player does not opponate with "usual ~" for the patient who complained that the chest is suffering, the heart is really bad and the hero promises to rescue with responsibility until the end I feel that it is too much.
Patients who actually have problems are often annoying to other patients
(Hospitalization and frequent troubles with other hospitalized patients)
It seems that many viewers think that viewers are self-defense of doctors alone from the professor's mouth played by Mr. Kishi.
Works such as "training interns Nanako" will be better to draw that there are various people on both the doctor side and the patient side.
2007/10/20 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by マリカ.M (Skip) Provider: 1407 Host:1250 Browser: 8090
I saw this drama after reading the original.
I was expecting how to reproduce that godlike scene in manga. . .
Personally I enjoyed the process of collecting team dragons.
Especially when I draw Mr. Arase of the anesthesiologist to the team, I can recognize that the anesthesiologist is a very important position.
It was very fresh as it is a role that never comes out in the hospital drama so far. I am sorry that I was not replacing it with other hospital dramas other than that.
The scene of the image training of surgery being done at the rooftop of Ryutaro Isuda has remembered the professor of the white big tower.
Again, the acting minute is bad.
Evaluation is normal. I think whether to see medical dragon 2 when rental starts.
2007/06/09 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by 濁流の魔手 (Skip) Provider: 3886 Host:3668 Browser: 4184
Although there were some pretty much different part regardless of the original work.
I think that it could not be helped to end it within a certain period of time.
But I think that it was a good work as a drama.
Although the manga was somewhat unrealistic, the live-action drama was becoming unrealistic.
There was not much resistance. It seemed like "such a drama."
I wonder if the role is also qualified.
I thought so.
It ended in a halfway place.
I would like to see the story from the National wearing.
2007/03/19 Not favorite comment [Original Japanese review]
by ELT (Skip) Provider: 2093 Host:2162 Browser: 6287
Since the manga is the original, it was a development that can not be done without development, but I think that manga was like the original content indeed, it was really bad
2007/03/17 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by LOVEN (Skip) Provider: 53119 Host:53240 Browser: 3874
It is not that it is not funny never, as it reproduces the original work he dreamed of faithfully.
But mistake is noticeable again.
Especially it felt that Ryutaro Asada was a member of Kenji Sakaguchi and climbing to Ijuin Tempio Koike Teppei.
Before acting, are not these two people suitable for this type of drama?
It is true that you said that you could not enjoy it obediently because you have seen the two leading characters with such eyes.
But Professor Kato, Professor Kihara, Professor Kirishima was Don Pissha.
Although including the original element, the way of tightening was so wonderful, considering the fact that the original was not destroyed,
Evaluation is normal.
2006/08/02 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by みみん (Skip) Provider: 2420 Host:2228 Browser: 4184
My house is a family line of doctors, but I think that it is somewhat put on reality. Well the original is decent though it is a drama ....
2006/07/10 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by キャンディー (Skip) Provider: 21546 Host:21654 Browser: 3874
I know the original. But, the original and the drama are different things ...
Drama, watching, it was fun, and drawing to the next time was also good.
Sakaguchi-kun's image training was also cool ...
Evaluation is high.
Because there is an original, people of the original fans may be various, but since it is an entertainment work,
By watching it if you enjoy it, seeing the original if it's not fun.
I just wonder if I can not do Batista surgery anymore if I dissolve a team that worked so hard.
2006/07/02 Not favorite comment [Original Japanese review]
by ろぎ (Skip) Provider: 45198 Host:45320 Browser: 6812
Difference between the drama "Medical Dragon" and the original cartoon work "Medicine Dragon".
Cartoon is a medical manga
Drama is a human drama
This is the difference.
It is the surgical scene that the difference appears remarkably.
In the drama, the patient's face is cut in during surgery. On the other hand, manga can not see the patient's face during surgery.
Manga is better in this neighborhood.
Once the surgery is started, neglecting the human nature of the patient, eliminate unnecessary human drama, concentrate on surgical work. It is truly a part that does not come out in the know-how of drama.
After all, the work which was made into a drama has many missing.
2006/07/02 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by たお (Skip) Provider: 45539 Host:45412 Browser: 7395
Since I have not watched the final round, I am surprised and evaluated.
It is possible to say in the recent drama in general, but the direction is not good. Or rather bad.
A lot of use of BGM, explanation of tone verbal dialogue, directing attitude to try to expand the story only with the atmosphere.
Wondering if you think that it is good to move the leading actors in slow motion over the music of BGM that presses the emotion? Progress of that kind is conspicuous. Shallow bottom production.
Feeling that it is poor in presence and summarizes the coolness of popular actors as a promotion video style.
It is a waste.
It is a pity that the material of the drama has a good story but that there is nothing appealing from the production.
Regrettable that I can not draw out an actor's guts.
By evaluating only in the last round, we make concessions to the utmost and make it "ordinary".
2006/07/01 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by 白砂 (Skip) Provider: 6118 Host:6072 Browser: 5234
It was fairly funny.
There was sometimes referred to as a medical site, and there was a sense of urgency inevitably.
Sometimes I thought about that flow of talk, but I think it is normal.
Mr. Kato was good than anything. It is weak for an ambitious woman.
Not only ambitious but also important to the patient in the second half, I did not give up the manuscript, I could not feel like being a good girl, I also liked the feeling.
Regarding love with Mr. Kirishima, I think whether it was necessary to say that Professor Kirishima is not a villain. I think that it is like saying that I am saving by Mr. Kihara and Mr. Kato for reasoning by mother's story.
Other people were also good, but the hero seemed to be slightly impacted. I thought that the presence was as it was, and I think that there was also a point of view ... ... Did you have a small number of people?
Professor Noguchi is an exception. That dubious feeling was nice and could not be said.
Lastly, Mr. Tsugawa Masahiko, president of Mr. Tsugawa, was the key point to be blown in similar lines.
2006/06/06 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by TCC (Skip) Provider: 8866 Host:9042 Browser: 4184
Although the original is a masterpiece, live-action drama version ........
Megumi Okina, a clerk at a drinker who plays, was stung by a knife and was taken to the hospital,
It is not a very good role to say that it will serve even an actress with a lower rank rating.
Mr. Kenji Sakaguchi who is a "good man" in the world also admits that he is enthusiastic,
I receive the impression that is floating. Arase who plays Akaba Sadao is also a doctor with a strange appearance that only Patzkin hair remains impressed, I do not like it much, and Mr. Inamori Izumi also seems to have expanded the entertainment areas such as period dramas recently, There is a sense of missing.
What can be praised for casting, "For the medical department you have to put an outside person in." "You liked Hachihashi, would you like to go to the university hospital in Kyoto?
Kyoto is good. It's hot in the summer, is not it. It is about Mr. Kishibe Ichinori who plays a ruthless professor role that simply truncates his men.
Although the original does not complain about inclusion of romance elements though it sees it after watching this, the impression that the cast lacking in charm is plummeting is strong. Since the original seems to be popular here in Aquapos,
Although I think that I would like to read and see the opportunity, the drama has a bad impression, so unfortunately the evaluation is low.
2006/05/30 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by トロピスト (Skip) Provider: 1791 Host:1725 Browser: 5145
I think that development of the story is interesting and good feeling. Regrettable as to role is disappointing.
Among medical topics, there is a place where you feel uncomfortable as you are looking at that feeling of death. But I feel that the production is somewhat poor ...
Also, what is the feeling of muddy inside the hospital what is it? The back circumstances and so on are good, but romance felt a little unnecessary feeling.
If it is a drama of this kind, it is quite normal and I feel like normal.
2006/05/03 Favorite comment [Original Japanese review]
by tfc (Skip) Provider: 3907 Host:3766 Browser: 6287
I do not know the original, but I think it is cool. (hero)
I do not think that the opsin is so good, but I think the dialogue that the hero says is cool.
We are looking forward to the future development.
2006/04/29 Not favorite comment [Original Japanese review]
by Reuentahl (Skip) Provider: 6812 Host:6862 Browser: 5234
I will comment as an original reader.
If you saw this program without having read the original, I think that it is reasonable for those who felt that this drama is not fun, boring, and so on.
However, since it is such a boring drama, I will say that the idea is definitely incorrect for those who think that there is nothing serious about the original work.
About the original fan fans, from the beginning live-action photography is divisible as impossible to reproduce the origin of the original. Even if there are actors who are given the excitement that is similar to the shivering in the opsin like the original, such a person is not among the actors who will appear in Japanese dramas, I think that you are in Hollywood.
But still, I expected some quality. But ... Here are some criticisms.
1. [Performance of an actor is bad!]
Especially Izumi Inamine is terrible. I think that it is what I have been living in this industry till now by a stick reading of such a line. I want to say that I can return Kato! The next point is Mizukawa. Other face-sheets such as Sakaguchi and Sasaki are not boiled down. Regarding Koike Teppei, I was worried before the drama started, but is it a good performance other than?
2. [Character of Ryutaro Asada]
One of the most uncomfortable feelings for the original fan is the main character: Ryutaro Asada is different in character. In the drama, Asada is feeling quite what it says, in addition, there is no contrast in personality.
Asakata in the original is a different person. Normally somewhere fun, sloppy, shaky (〓〓〓Ah, can not express well) But when you come to the scene, its personality will be sharp and will make you feel sublime. That change is splendid.
3. [Why incorporate romantic elements?]
The point that many original fans evaluate the original is that no extra elements are found. Would you let me say as a work that saved useless as much as possible, regardless of how many times I read it again, the fact is that the story is really straight forward. Therefore, the assertion in the work is also clearly conveyed to the reader. The original does not relate to 'promised' elements such as romance, sentimental friendship ... which can be seen in many other works. It is a feeling that we are limiting the elements to draw.
However, without thinking about incorporating various elements like other works, I think that the attitude that polishing limited elements is making the original a distinct alteration to other works I will.
Yes, I was feeling somewhere better for that altitude. Oh, but even .... It is a feeling why such lonely work should be secularized.
Of course, it seems that there is opinion whether whether it is so important to reproduce the original work whether it is the character of the character or the story. However, I think that what you do with turning such nonsense works into works that are rolling anywhere in the streets?
There are things I still want to write a lot, but I would like to turn it to the next opportunity (if there is a next one).
2006/04/29 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by ろぎ (Skip) Provider: 26639 Host:26594 Browser: 6812
What is it that the protagonist is letting bigger Sakaguchi do the big character though the actor of Kihara or Ijuin-in is doing cosplay?
I do not know if I want to faithfully reproduce the original or want to destroy it.
If it does anything, I wanted Kato's "honey dumpling. Mickey mouse" to reproduce the hairstyle.
Also, some stories have been changed.
Resuscitation scene of Professor Fujiyoshi of the second episode. In the original, I pulled the cable from the car generator and did electric shock therapy, but in the drama I had an incision.
The intention to replace is unknown.
The biggest change is the change in gender of Professor Kito.
Male by Natsuki in the drama, although it is a man in the original.
I can not grasp the meaning changed. As a result, we do not know how the drama will change at the moment.
I will hold it here, but it seems to be unfavorable.