[Drama]Asa ga kita

  • Cute
  • Enjoyed
  • Interesting
  • Learned something
Drama total pnts rank Rank 1,613in 2,598 titlesTotal 0 / Deviation 48.50
Drama rank of 2015 Rank 71in 118 titles
Statics of evaluation and Ranking
Reviews' statics
Post review by myself
Voice/Actor1.62(Very good)8
Graphic1.50(Very good)8
Learned something50%4/8
Made me think38%3/8
Hot heart25%2/8
Shed tears25%2/8
Information about this title

Mika Oomori
Nishitani Shinichi
Yuki Hayashi
Aoi Miyazaki
Takeshi mazu
Shinobu Terajima
Yoichi Hayashi
Hiroshi Tamaki
Masaomi Kondo
Jun Fubuki
Tasuku Emoto
Hisako Manda
Yamauchi Takaya
Hiroki Miyake
Nono Sumika
Japan Released:2015/09/28(Mon) NHK / End:2016/04/02
Official sites
1. http://www.nhk.or.jp/dramatopics-blog/1000/215095.html (Translation)
Recently views
  Limit by opinioin
Search in this page

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post your review to English version, please click here.
2017/05/15 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 80 Host:248 Browser: 10249
[good point]
Asap artificial morning masa is a men's boy, he is a diagonally opposite maneuver, both of which are strengthened by strong efforts Asa and Shinjiro, Hatsuto and S〓〓ei, Yomi and Tanosuke , Wataru and Kamezu Each actor who often depicted a love depiction was very shiny acting with the feelings of cast such as unique and attractive wave ru and Miyazaki Aoi, Tamaki Hiroshi, Dean Fujioka etc.
The theme song of AKB echoed in my mind and it is touched with emotionally unexpected words but their girls, especially Yamamoto Aya's singing ability was wonderful

[Bad point]
None at all

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Although I looked back recently, it is also no exaggeration to say that this work, which was a very wonderful piece of work in the morning drama of recent years also is one of the best masterpieces of morning drama It is also convincing that the popularity was high enough to record the highest rating in this century Mika should be evaluated more

2017/04/01 Very Bad(-2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 11207 Host:11478 Browser: 7876
It was great praise in the morning drama, but nothing was amazing.

[good point]

I can evaluate the less conspicuous parts of the end of Edo period and Meiji, describing the circumstances of the merchants and the stuff like hidden struggle and way of life, but if it is good other than that ... I thought it was. ... ....

[Bad point]

Although hero who is peculiar in the morning Dora seems to be talking to Mr. Hana, he thought that he was a feminist to a feminist from a fierce Kagoshima birthplace of men and women, "haa?", A husband who left a shop to a shop and places it on the other side was a Meiji It is impossible to think in advance of thinking about the era of "the person who wanted to put in such a malicious contrast like" Who? In the era when a woman was trampled, a woman's big success! Whatever ... it will be white.

Even though I put it in the morning Dora because I am a female protagonist, even though I left it as a female protagonist, this episode is a terrible level, and even if I give sumo wrestlers or crawlers to male opponents, "Do you misunderstand the drama of yakuza? "I thought so much. Even if I said "I did not want to do this" in such a manner as to obey a man, it seems to me that it is complaining that it is hypocritical.

Some people grudging against the middle stage came out, but if you were such a protagonist, you will be grudged by the sky.

[Comprehensive evaluation]

I studied Hirooka Asako for a moment but I did not think that it was an attractive person to that, and watching the ladies of the youngest days of the later women's movement of Meiji and Taisho, I do not know whether the actual Hirooka Asako is, but the attitude like "Take care of a man to the habit which is more noticeable than a man," and "Attitude is like the leader, you are conspicuous Yeah 's place came to Hana. NHK's female contempt at the time of broadcasting (even now), and the part that seems to be lightly looking at women were uncomfortable.

I wanted to change the channel every time a thematic song of the national idol group flows, and I do not know whether NHK and the production team ignore the reality of the history that female civil rights were not given until after the war? I think. Even if it is not so, both morning Dora and Taiga will undoubtedly make a woman stand out strangely, and if you do not want to get out of it, it is incontinent to make things like it!

2016/11/12 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 4405 Host:4425 Browser: 5171
[good point]
Asasan's tempo is so early, the story goes to the lazy race and I will not let the viewer get bored ... the husband Shinjiro's follow-up is also wonderful. Cast was also good ... Neither did Joru received a morning drum audition many times, and I always worked brightly and powerfully all the time. 7, I did not get up 8, I increased this number, this number ... I think that it is a drama that shines like a triple cast with my sister Miyazaki-san and Shinjirou. Gin Dai also broke up and ...
Two handsome guys ...
[Bad point]
I do not think so.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
very good

2016/04/04 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 36209 Host:36373 Browser: 5173
[good point]
Deployment that linked the morning part of the early stage with a part.
Mr. Miyazaki Aoi expresses the latter with facial expressions and gestures, while the former has a flat place at the center of the dialogue, although it is large in scale.
I have answered well to the needs of both audience members seeking geekiness that is easy to understand in the "Lord of the. The Ring" configuration and those demanding deep content.

Acting as a morning role wave actor was also a little intolerable, but I got used to the extent that it goes afterwards.

[Bad point]
Unnatural developments have increased from coal mining that we shot all together from shooting costs and schedule constraints.
From the beginning, how to get involved with Godai and so on.

After the midfield, the content drawn with "Carnation" is reapplied to the speech center and the last is "Massan" as it is etc. There is no ingenuity such as "Furouso san" from another angle In recent years the feeling of dishonoring of the work becomes stronger It was.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Although it became a work which attracted attention with the start of the early Edo drama at the beginning of the morning drama, although it became a work that paid success as a viewer rating, the person who became the subject in the constraint such as consciousness to the audience layer seeking the contents of the home drama and production cost I also receive the impression that the staff did not have enough competence to make it alive.

Mr. Oiku, who took over the poison at the beginning, says at the end that "I wanted to return to Osaka!"
Most of the people born in Edo feel like the neighboring prefecture is close to the current neighboring country, so for this reason the hero will be a businesswoman who reworked the world in the modern world.
At the end of the Bakumatsu, as the range of action of Asahi remained close to Osaka, it was still good, but since the Meiji era, its actions and achievements spread to Kyushu from the east in Tokyo and the west in Kyushu, It becomes an impression that it is small and conversely conversely that it is done only by & narration.
Also, in historical fact, after the Ishinha, the pipe with the parents' home who bored into the business world & political world center was also excluded actively utilizing the part that utilized it and put the weight on the home drama-like part, so it does not convey whether the hero is struggling or not It has become a content of insufficient catharsis such as making a great achievement in various fields within.
Although the home drama part felt each character, a suitable charm, the question "I wonder whether it is to draw this person on another subject" separately, I am interested in the subject searching system, contents closer to the mold of the contemporary work of the modern thing turn into.

Among real talk based morning dramas in recent years, "carnation" and "wife of Gegege" are particularly high in completeness,
Especially "Carnation" has a plan to draw the three sisters who flapped the world mainly while doing overseas location? Lifetime, the distance between the workplace and the family such as clothed in a form that makes the mother based on Kishiwada the main character A careful meeting has been done from the selection stage of nearby subjects.
As for this work, as for the time when the Taiga and the airing were covered last year, the opinion that "this was better if it was done in the big river" was seen and the topicity such as Okawara regular actor's participation was high, think.

Evaluation is "normal".

2015/11/22 Favorite comment [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 7531 Host:7611 Browser: 5139
For now the evaluation is on hold so comment only.
At this point "worst" has a high possibility of avoidance ... but I can not get caught until the end.

[good point]

The point where the atmosphere of raising milk comes out in a good meaning when I make a mistake if it is strange to be my strong heroine.
In a certain sense of the hero couple, I think that the state "male reversal" state is drawn without disgust.

[Bad point]

Huge is too conspicuous.
It seems to be high in the world, but ... Why did you think of double heroine with this subject matter?

Theme song.
Was not there a somewhat more powerful song?

[Comprehensive evaluation]

I wanted to do with the name of Mr. Ichii 's people is also wonderful ~ Is the name of my sister increased until my name became a fictitious character?
Even a person without a name is living alive, but I think that those who left their name in history are great.
Originally, it is not a person who has many episodes as long as I do not have time to do my sister's story.

Personally I thought that Aoi Miyazaki was not good either ....
However, even an actor who was not good at all so often had a favorable feeling obediently if he saw a hammering role.
I still feel unnecessary in the story ... only the hedine like the Kawaiishokenage system seems to ....

To be honest, when I heard the setting, I felt that the heroine was too much sorry meta.
You should not put obviously poor person as another hero next to the hero.
If there is conspicuous there, it will be bought if you are unsuccessful for the hero who is a successful person.

I think that Mr. Wuru is doing his best in a disadvantageous situation.
That line "Bikkuripon", in the scriptwriter, I can not have a feeling I wanted to squid, but I say as much as possible to the nature.
It is not simply a male victory, I expect the heroine statue to equalize men without losing the peculiar elements of women.

Impression of looking is different, but fundamentally it seems to be a type close to Yumi-chan of "working man".
It is not like living perfectly like a man, but it seems that the result of work is equal to that of men.

2015/11/21 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 172 Host:337 Browser: 10316
[good point]
From the point of view of a merchant who had been rarely taken up as a drama in the past, he picked up the Tokugawa shogunate and the Meiji Restoration.

[Bad point]
〓〓〓As a model of Asako Hirooka as a model at the end of the Bakumatsu, the Meiji era and the Taisho era, she depicts a woman who has worked for company management and school establishment while fighting discrimination against women, at first glance it seems to be criticizing for discrimination against women, but " And "family home" often come out, not only criticism of discrimination against women, but also content that seems to reproduce gender one prejudice and patriarchal family instead. Actually, asa got to appear in front of Konoya's business is to fulfill the responsibility as "bride" to "for the sake of the house" to the last, not to pursue happiness as an independent person alone .
〓〓〓No respect is felt for the person who became a model. Asako Hirooka is unlikely to make a childish word like "Bikkurinponi" as a habit, and also, even if it is Toshinari Tomoyo, to explain the importance of the company organization, "big trading" to " It is hard to believe that you used English to words that are sufficiently replaced in Japanese as saying "Big transactions". Besides, cold gag descriptions are conspicuous, such as Shinjuro 's appearance as a "reminder" or asa which looks as if it is a face blushed white. It seems that there is no point in criticizing that it is playing with historical figures such as Hirooka Asako, Hirooka Shinigaro, Gomiro Tomonari as a toy.
〓〓〓Miscellaneousness is noticeable in depicting time lapse and position relation. For example, even if we only took out the lodge's night flight, we could not settle in one place because we were forced to pay debts, and we could not wipe a sense of incompatibility when Asasato was able to find it easily comparatively. Also, as Asahas go to the grand shops, considering the transportation situation at the time, it may not be able to go frequently, even if it is only a round trip even a few days. Even if we handed over a hundred steps and frequently went as described, it is natural to think that many years have elapsed in the meantime, it is not said that there was not too much depiction of that course is too lost I can not get it.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
In this work, the audience rating is unexpectedly high in recent years, and it is said that it is generally popular from the viewers and the media, but myself can not take the mind of high evaluation for the above reasons. Since the bad points are too bad, evaluation is "worst".