• Shocked
Other media: Movie:Alien
Literature total pnts rank Rank 2,243in 4,611 titlesTotal 2 / Deviation 48.73
Literature rank of 1953 Rank 4in 11 titles
Statics of evaluation and Ranking
Reviews' statics
Post review by myself
Hot heart0%0/2
Shed tears0%0/2
Made me think0%0/2
Learned something0%0/2
Information about this title

Ranpo Edogawa
Japan Released:1953/01 Shounen / End:1953/12
Recently views
  Limit by opinioin
Search in this page

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post your review to English version, please click here.
2016/06/09 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 44336 Host:44389 Browser: 9081
In the series of "Phantom of twenty-face", this work is one of the best size.
As a matter of fact, when I started reading this, I was reading it without knowing that it was a series of twenty faces, but I was surprised to see that Akechi Kogoro and Kobayashi Boys came out on the way. It was.
I wonder if the mystery blends into the Juvenile like an alien comes out. I was thinking that this was not a detective one, but it would normally be a story to make a detective a hero and stop the alien.

Well, this work is a story that a boy sees an alien, and it has become a style that seems to be somewhat similar to other monster movies later.
As a matter of fact, the situation itself that a large amount of aliens are occurring on a worldwide scale makes itself feel strange in this work, but even so to make it seem to be "such as Ali?" All this strange phenomenon I will clean up with the human task.
Again, this work makes me feel that it is a style that emphasizes the structure of "to pull back the reality that does not make sense of reality feel anyway" rather than "reality". Although it can be said commonly to the series, to say that "it is a mystery to use a trick to realize the unreality", in order to give excitement to children anyway, it said that it draws "unreality" considerably exaggeratedly It is an impression.
I myself read this too and I remember being surprised at that point that "Is not this a story of the world view where there is an aliens?" There are tricks or tricks that are being used, and there are places like special effects in movies, and it was surprisingly realistic that it was high if it was "shooting technique".

The impression that eventually is impressive is the motive behind Mr. Tokodo's doing just that.
This time it is not saying that stealing, not doing pleasant criminal revenge, it is rather a form of causing a riot for the cause. That's why he said he was not afraid of arrests only for this time.
It was the ending that makes the air feel like that the creator had exactly anti-war consciousness at this time.
As a way to end, it is distinctive to leave a lingering finish, it is distinctive that it is not bad feeling of aftertaste and aftertaste.

Evaluation is "good".
I am not reading the series in turn, but I was able to enjoy this as well.
The fact that that 'Godzilla' will be released the next year is also interesting.

2007/08/11 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 24524 Host:24609 Browser: 3875
A story that will be depicted on the largest scale among works drawn by Rampo and that is most distant from reality.

Too cryptic encounters talking to the universe Phantom.
Among them, it was somewhat crazy to be told that it was simply a witness' s Kyogen if it was expected to prove how to prove it in the final stage, as some tricks could not achieve it at all.

2007/06/07 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 18384 Host:18446 Browser: 6287
I think that the person who thought doubtful at the beginning is a culprit,
Thereafter, there was another aspect, which made it impossible to understand the existence value of the first person.
I can not say it well, but the impression is that the balance is not good.
In other words, it is to feel doubt about the existence value of the first person.

[good point]
The background of the birth of "Space Phantom" is interesting.
I think that it was such a motivation, ..., a little, I feel a bit too,
Is it somewhat changed the taste?

[Bad point]
The discovery of the universe monsters around the world and becoming news means that,
I think whether it is realistic.
As for the truth itself as it is, the example pattern is exciting.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
Because I never could not read it, I would like to go "normal".

2007/05/26 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 33223 Host:33285 Browser: 6287
A monster with a flying saucer and wings appeared, and it is amazing to people that the aliens' strikes!? It is a strange development of a SF ticky story.

Well, the blackmail was eventually the one he ended up, but this time I will denounce himself a foolish man who is doing a war of peace of reign, raising his wrong on the shelf.

But, as Akito Tantei says, it is only a criminal who has suffered a lot of people by putting the world into confusion every once in a while. First of all, you have to make a big mouth after correcting your collar.

I thought that thought well, such as a trick of a flying saucer.