Anime total pnts rank Rank 6,490in 6,595 titlesTotal -38 / Deviation 41.15
Anime avg pnts Rank 2,888in 2,902 titlesAvg -2.11=Very bad/18 reviews
Anime rank of 2007 Rank 200in 206 titles
Statics of evaluation and Ranking
Reviews' statics
Post review by myself
Made me think25%1/4
Hot heart0%0/4
Shed tears0%0/4
Learned something0%0/4
Information about this title

Makoto Kobayashi
Yota Tsuruoka
Yasushi Akimoto
Masaya Onishi
Il Won
Erena Ono AKB48 Junko Minagawa Kurumi Mamiya Yuko Oshima Tomomi Kasai
Natsuki Sato Eri Kitamura Akira Ishida Yoshino Ohtori Haluna Ikezawa
Japan Released:2007/05/25(Fri) Media(ex. DVD)
Recently views
  Limit by opinioin
Search in this page

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post your review to English version, please click here.
2015/11/09 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 3895 Host:3916 Browser: 5710
Writing frankly, the meaningless work that the story can not grasp.

Even if you look at the first episode, you will understand that there is a lack of sufficient explanation, the world without a man, but before that, the relevance of the characters will not be obvious unless you go far enough. Also, since there is explanation only on the "ICE" after a certain amount of explanation, there is no clear explanation, and most can not be understood unless it is necessary to join from a fine line of dialogue. In other words, if you care with care or do not review it over and over again, you will be stepping forward with indigestion, so you will remember the feeling that you are leaving behind as if you are watching. I wonder there was a reason to make it less confusing.

And, Mr. Numbers uniformly wrote, too much awkward acting of AKB 48 members. Especially Yuki who can be said to be the main character is poorly skillfully, with a voice as if the nose is stuck in a hay fever season and as it is voice-narrated, it is hard to hear anything. Although it seems not to be a voice when it is cold, it may be pollen allergy and other nasal voices, but at the very least it is necessary to make first-aid measure and make more vocal sounds, which will be an insult to the viewers, It will be.

Although it is also the Ghibli work, I do not quit understanding that it is only to lower the evaluation of the work that I do cast this much troublesome while taking a consideration. In the case of this work it is OVA, so it will be much more expensive than a movie. There is no point in paying that much money and being told by amateurs that at the level where hair grows, money can be said to return. Scenes of interactions with professional voice actors, etc. are further complemented by their misery, so this is just a weak person.

It will be a fascinating work as it is, if it makes development that is easy for the viewer to understand more and all the AKB members are switched to the main job, it will be an interesting work as it is, and music including AKB's song is good. It seems that it could be said that it was an unfortunate work that I could not imagine having an appeal to anime that would only be acting voice without reflection of the face while presuming idle, and even the intention created was not known.


2014/02/22 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 6953 Host:6894 Browser: 5958
[good point]
I think the world feeling itself is good.

[Bad point]
An amateur voice actor. It is exhausted to this.
Stick reading. Nasal voice. There is no acting skill. It is the worst.

[Comprehensive evaluation]
It became a bad case like this if a person without love in anime culture led the initiative.
Pity on people who love animation, engaged in this work.

2012/02/26 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 9800 Host:9651 Browser: 4895
[good point]

"Women 's world view" is not terribly fresh but it was not a bad subject.

The animation was as beautiful as it was, and the impression of the battle scene was expressed as it was.

"Professional" voice actor, Akira Ishida 's favorite performance shone, especially the main cast in the main cast. Just saying that it was true opposite to Mr. Saiga Mitsuki, or more than an ordinary woman,
"Feminine coolness good" was expressed well. Mr. Junko Minagawa also made sense of stability drift.

[Bad point]

The depiction of the appearance character was 〓〓 It is not said that the drunkard of Yuki and Hitomi character feeling was inadequate and was not made emotionally transferred, and it passed it without delay?
Satsuki was also a radio-based character, it was rather somewhat tasty.

However, the deciding factor was the AKB 48 frame voice actor at the time before the break.
Anyway. Of course I did not expect professional level acting skills such as Mr. Ishida and Mr. Minagawa from the beginning, but the child of Yuki role was particularly bad with a stick reading. Just playing other members, did not convey professional consciousness.

[Comprehensive evaluation]

If it says so, it seems that this time in a certain leading animation, he will perform with Yui Horie and Yukari Tamura,
In short, if the infected song is horror, this is probably because it was an AKB selling animation that pretended to face different world fantasy.
Although I was boring even if I did not like their likes and dislikes, evaluation is severe because it is a problem work that has become a bad foundation to advance to Mio also in animation,
Only "worst" is assumed.

2011/10/22 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 34710 Host:34604 Browser: 3012(Mobile)
I am irritated already in the middle of one story and it is impossible.
Just listening to your voice makes me worry too much.

2011/07/22 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 40880 Host:40959 Browser: 11947
Sekai story toward a gradual destruction.

Although the talk itself is ordinary, the first impression to say that the world view I saw was not bad.
But when you see it, it is hard to focus voice actors other than core business such as Mr. Minagawa and Mr. Ishida due to stunning readings,
I just spread out hints, but I'm very sorry that the collection did not stay.
However, I felt that the point that did not incorporate meaningless cruel scenes was positive.

If you reorganize the parts that you want to show a bit more and cast the voice actor to the core business a lot, it may have been connected in a good direction.
Although it is low in perfection, I felt it was not as bad as I thought, because there are points to look at in part, so "bad" is reasonable.

2011/04/01 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 22155 Host:22208 Browser: 9365
In a nutshell it was "awful", a work that I was sorry to borrow in 3 volumes.
Personally, the first world setting was all too lame. There is development of the talk itself, and the charm of the character is also dead.

Even so, the voice actors were terrible overall, I remember Ishida Akira is the top of the enemy or something, the hero was Mr. Minagawa. A lot of other idol appointments. But it is good to appoint, but if there is such an inexperienced person, the work is destroyed. Those who worked together as if they had taken a lot of times would have had a hard time, feeling stuck in the character with this .. .. When you saw "Kenshin in 〓〓〓〓〓〓〓〓〓quot; like a voice actor of the hero class liked I remember stopping watching without it, but this work was different in digits. It was amazing in a sense. (It became better if it was seen in the latter half because the "Kenshin in 〓〓〓〓〓〓〓〓〓quot; was long on the air)

Evaluating comprehensively, nothing has its value, evaluation "worst"

2010/01/15 Very Bad(-2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 32099 Host:31930 Browser: 2907(Mobile)
To be honest, it is more bad (using only male voice actors) to use a male voice actor as a female role than to use idle for the main cast factor that stopped watching it.
I forgot the name, but it was as bad as I was using the female voice actor as a middle-aged boy in the work which can choose whether to become a man or a woman when growing up.
Not only idols but also other characters did not match voice actors.
The characters themselves did not appeal to themselves and they made it all together.
I understand what I want to do, but I am packed too much and it is too small to be tempo bad.
Because the story development also places only what I have seen somewhere, there are many parts where abrupt contradiction of setting and absence of Tsuji come abruptly.
I can not explain the world view, so I can not explain it, I just do not know what it is meaningless just by arranging difficult things, I do not have any meaning and I think that it is convenient.
I do not have directions on how to proceed with my story and the cutting is bad and there are too many meaningless ups.
Although I wrote various things up to here, though it was not severer than I originally thought, something is shifting or something is missing or it was missing, and I felt regretfully that it might have become interesting if I fix it even there.

2009/11/07 Not favorite comment [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 22865 Host:23048 Browser: 5600
A typical "sekai" distracted story.What is a world view idly turning with depiction insufficiency.
(Perhaps you pointed out) Extreme stick reading performance by idol voice actor.
Although it is a work that seems to be unlikely if you mention only disadvantages such as visuals that can not be described as beautiful as never-ending, a strange feeling of leaving something stuck behind after watching. Needless to say, it is a work that selects viewers.

Animation from day to day, people who are deeply in contact with subculture culture are disappointed more violently,
On the other hand, I have not graduated from Ota culture, but I have not seen much anime,
The latter half of the late 20s may be seen as a bad work but may be seen up to 3 volumes.

It is quite unknown to the layer which was recently accustomed to symbolicized animation, and it seems to be a product of garbage or less, since it appears only as intentionally incomprehensible as the creator's intention.
To some extent, the animation. The layer that is going out with distance from the subcar may rather be freshly taken.

In spite of such work, introducing a semiotic lady-only view of the world easily, it is a failure to expand collaboration to depend on idol voice actors etc.
Personally, the concept of the world view.I feel that the feeling toward gradual destruction is not bad. Draw down the scale and delve into the depiction of the world view,
I think that it was about less than a honorable mention if you give politeness that the creator's intention of concept is conveyed or if it is thoroughly slimmed down and narrowed down and idle elimination is done.
I'm looking positively because some grotesque descriptions convey well the madness that the world view of this work encompasses.

The blunder of this work is due to undigested over-set and insufficient depiction of the world view,
If I solve that problem, idol.Drawing degradation etc may be a trivial problem.

It was not boring.

2009/06/23 Very Bad(-2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 4194 Host:4070 Browser: 9878
I can not see it concentrating on the first story of a strange story as reputed.

I think that the voice actor who was competing was well tolerated.

Although Hayao Miyazaki makes up a voice actor amateur as it is, after all it realizes that it is because the director is excellent.

You should not buy packaged software even if you make a mistake.
Let's borrow a continuation after renting only one volume to check your resistance.

2009/06/22 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 516 Host:257 Browser: 6399
I only watch one episode.

[good point]
Mechanical design

[Bad point]

[Comprehensive evaluation]
I knew the mechanical design was Mr. Makoto Kobayashi, but I took it.
To the severity of the voice of the character, the story and the background all blew away to the side.
After examining it, I was involved with Yasushi Akimoto and an idol group ... orz

Since I knew Makoto Kobayashi in MS Senki, I am a favorite designer.
Even with this work, I think mechanical design was good. I smashed it to pieces,
Moreover, it is a composition where commercial strategy appears outright.

I think there is no sin in idle. The one who shook such a job, the one who thought of this combination is the worst. I can not remember being betrayed so much. It is over Gedo Senki.

If I appointed a voice actor as usual it would not be such a thing. definitely.
Although I was hoping for Mr. Makoto Kobayashi's director's work very much, in that it betrayed it to its full extent,
I will strictly evaluate it more than usual. Orz

2008/09/24 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) [Good:6(86%) Normal:0(0%) Bad:1(14%)] / Provider: 8263 Host:8160 Browser: 4925
[good point]

[Bad point]
Do not appoint an idol!
Brutality depiction is raging. Nothing totally appealing to the story
Far as well as 1 volume, it is terrible after 2 volumes

[Comprehensive evaluation]
This is terrible ...
It is the worst that I contend for the 1st and 2nd place in my view
AKB's just PR work

2008/07/18 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 47090 Host:47101 Browser: 9538
OVA all three stories.
It depicts the fight of women who are unfolding in the world where men are gone.
First, the voice of the hero is stick reading. Because it adopted AKB 48 as a voice actor?
However, the theme songs were pretty good as the voices were anyway.

I was surprised that Ishida Akira played the role of a woman,
Sometimes the role is top, I was surprised even though it was surprising.

Although the CG was also used on the image side, it was surprisingly powerful,
I feel like I was collapsing with my face somehow.
Also, something old-fashioned drawing is one of features of this work.

The story was totally dark and serious (slightly gross) and interesting.

2008/07/06 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 32756 Host:32619 Browser: 2995(Mobile)
Among me, it is an impressive work as the worst anime in history.
If I can not make use of the setting at all, it is quite difficult to name a good place with both the voice actor and the story being the worst.
There is nothing like a nice place.
It was a work that regretted package purchasing for the first time.

Evaluation is of course "worst". (In the worst of the worst)

2008/04/03 Very Bad(-2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 3041 Host:3106 Browser: 3876
Yasushi Akimoto X Makoto Kobayashi XAKB 48
Looking at the propaganda claiming that it was going to be mad ... it was not wrong that I felt.
There is a background feeling that there is a background that can only be thought of as a voices with stick reading and incompatibility, paintings that I thought as the '90s? CG is an ordinary level but it was not like selling.
I tried it at a rental shop but I was deceived by the delicacy of the package illustration ..

2008/01/13 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 12661 Host:12508 Browser: 2983(Mobile)
I only saw one episode ...

Severe, too severe (sweat)
What are these harsh noises ...

I hate to use a poor actor or idol as a voice actor (ok if it's fine) but I can not afford to worry other than the worst

I'm going to use animation for the advertisement of idols, but with the opposite effect?
It is not limited to this but people who use actors such as innocent people for promotional purposes or for customer attraction do not have a pride or commitment as a creator, is not it ?? The job is uncertain just by beautiful things I understand that it is not, but is not it the end if you are discarding the commitment by the creator (is it good?).

I do not know exactly what I am thinking about Simpsons ...

2008/01/13 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 9702 Host:9807 Browser: 8090
I am surprised by the severity of the performance (really unimaginable) of the voice actors excluding some, such as Mr. Junko Minagawa and Akira Ishida. I am really surprised.

This work is an idol unit sales promotion product for geek, which Mr. Yasushi Akimoto has planned and devoted for business. It is neither over nor below.

In addition to the contents, as mentioned earlier, the performance of the actors has failed, and only the cruel depiction is full of volumes (baby shooting, girls being killed one after another, etc.).
It is garbage as one "story" package.

It is not only harmful for the animation industry as a whole that this kind of thing leaks out to the world as one of Japanimation, and there is little benefit.

I can not show this to a small child who is wrong. "It's the worst.

2007/12/06 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 5696 Host:5330 Browser: 5163
[Comprehensive evaluation]

Situations are interesting, but they are too tedious and the focus is blurred.
I want to make the story simpler and give a good evaluation if I do not draw blood.

2007/11/30 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 8983 Host:8822 Browser: 6342
The clumsiness of the voice actor of the woman was too conspicuous, and the content grazed.
It is not even one or two people.
This must be done by a muffler.
I will endure the quality of the voice, but I can not forgive my performance.

2007/10/20 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 10265 Host:10360 Browser: 7500
[good point]
After a long absence I can not wait for the next volume to come out, "What's next development?" I watched 3 volumes. Still it is not completed simply by looking at what it says to this work? It has been drawn into the world that I think.

[Bad point]
It is hard for the character to know the setting such as retro, cast. While there are many story animation works whose conclusion is easy to understand, there is no conclusion and if you look from the viewpoint of "just looking and enjoying" it lacks kindness?

[Comprehensive evaluation]
I felt newness (challenge) that does not apply to recent animation equations. There is an initiator presence. I wanted to research various things. Something starts from within there, not from the end to see. It was good and bad, it was a strong presence, it was a curious heart for me curious.