|Statics of evaluation and Ranking|
|Information about this title|
- ▼Sorted by:Newness
2013/11/08 Favorite comment [Original Japanese review]
by くたばれ (Skip) Provider: 2849 Host:2859 Browser: 5870
Friendship between Gab and May
Character Anyhow Gab and May are cute (laugh). I feel that Gab first knows that May looked delicious (〓〓〓...). Personally I like Zaku and Bitches the best
Art Places are pretty clean
I particularly like the music when the music title comes out
CG honest I do not need this ....
I did not mind voice actor gabs and May, but the voice of a goat 's girl or a person who has a stick reading occasionally (probably TBS' s announcer). What I became interested in recently is this animation, a man voice actor only (laugh)
It is truly favorableism that Gab's memory returns with the word "stormy naughty" at the end
It's a work that depicts friendship between Gab and May, but occasionally it looks like gay (I think it is due to my own mind (laugh))
A fine work except save the bad points listed above. Evaluation is "I think it is good"
2011/12/17 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by 一鑑賞者 (Skip) Provider: 2495 Host:2472 Browser: 4542
The image surface is impressive.
Music is grand and wonderful.
The difference in skillful performance by voice actors is intense.
The last of the story is inconvenient
It is normal for children to watch, but the voice of Mei was not familiar with it.
As an aside, when I was allowed to see this movie in class in agriculture high school, Gab, who was losing his memory in the last, was trying to eat May, "Let me eat!" And Yaji was flying I remembered.
Were they simply boring, or were they also agricultural high school students, so they felt hypocritical in 'friendship over the food chain'?
In this case it is probably the former ....
2010/10/13 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by 白うに (Skip) Provider: 19847 Host:19734 Browser: 7726(Mobile)
It is an evaluation after looking at the picture-story version who was doing with NHK or something.
Orientation is for children, but it is a work that can be enjoyed by young and old.
Despite appointing an actor, neither acting with a voice not destroying the image, I think it was very good.
While talking well using the setting, I am depicting humorously the journey of the two who should not be able to get along well.
Serious and humorous, it is very good, but the problem is the way to end.
Sorry to the contrary, it certainly seems that the work was not a happy ending ...?
Well, it might have been modified for children. However, it seems that it gives the impression that it is not a very good scenario when seeing the whole because of that. At least I feel unsatisfactory and it is not fun.
Evaluation is "bad".
I think that happy ending is not necessarily a good way to finish.
2009/10/11 Favorite comment [Original Japanese review]
by herba (Skip) Provider: 13954 Host:14258 Browser: 7186
The wolf gab and the sheep May - The side to be supplemented becomes a "friend" thanks to the special circumstances where each other's face can not be seen. The moment of having a good impression on each other, the relationship that changed so far.
It can be interpreted as one you know on the net and meet in real ... ... supplementary food is unilateral and dangerous.
The friend relationship is confined to the relationship between two animals (although it seems to want to write "two people"), and as a group to which each other belongs, unilateral supplementary relationships continue to exist strictly. Therefore, it becomes a factor to isolate within each other's friends, but more than that, even among the two conversations, the supplementary food relationship will not be driven aside and will always be kept conscious. The taste of the conversation is quite interesting though (it completely wipes out the cruelty of nature), but it always sticks with an unstable and surreal feeling that contradiction lives together. Sense of human being's paradox being dewded in anthropomorphizing drama.
Both the wolf's gab and the sheep's May seem to be male, but mostly also in men's relations.
But it is a wolf and a sheep.
Although it is high level imagewise, the story is like a group where wolves 'group is like a yakuza organization and mixes escape in the hands' classical drama format. Although it is easy to enter if it speaks well, the sense of fantasy is also diminished.
The place where the entrance and tightening caught in the title are related to the theme.
It is an interesting work that seems to have gone into a feeling of incongruity that seems to be unusual and anthropomorphic, but it is an honest place to think as an evaluation.
It seems like the purpose of this work is that I think about it.
2008/11/04 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by mind (Skip) Provider: 29983 Host:29908 Browser: 8090
The content of 1 volume of this was on the textbook at the time of small 6.
Although the original was a fairy tale, the sentences were tasty and the tempo of development was light, so it was readable for 12 years old.
The animation was changed to a gentle and warm atmosphere rather than saying the style as lighter as it was the main subject, the picture was cute,
Even though thinking that the target is a child, there is sense of incompatibility when considering the contents (especially the latter severity).
Although it is certainly not enough to draw a wolf as evil,
If it does not draw so it will be difficult to make the story and make the line easier to understand, so well within acceptable tolerance.
I do not think the content of 'friendship of the eating side and eaten side' is likely (I can not think of anything else), I think that it is a wonderful material.
If the voice actor is a little better now ... There are many stick readings before or not fitting. It is about a gab that is decent.
2008/08/19 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by おにたま (Skip) Provider: 38670 Host:38708 Browser: 2230
The picture is beautiful.
Until you meet in the hut and walk away.
The voice actor is too bad.
Since the reunion.
This work hurts.
First, from a good point. The picture is very polite and beautiful. I think that there is not quite a work of quality that exceeds this. Next is a story. However, until the wolf and the sheep meet in the hut and walk away. Here, if it ends, it is no mistake that it was the best work without complaint. Even if the voice actor's acting ... or minus the minus side was subtracted it would have been the best work.
Then, a bad point. First, voice actor is the worst. It is fatal as a work to hit this bad voice actor to the hero, Gab and Mei. After all, it is not good unless it is a professional voice actor. In recent theatrical version animation, there is a tendency to appoint celebrities to voice actors, well, it is true that there are also people better than the main job, but it is extremely rare and mostly it is 2 ranks 3 as well as this work It also results in lowering the rank. Next is a story. At first glance, it looks like a smiley animal without any extraordinary but different. Somewhat, there is unpleasant sense of incongruity in depiction throughout. Would not it be nice to talk about replacing a wolf man with a sheep and a woman? "It is delicious though it is a friend" or ... Bad taste www. It is bad for education. A sheep is expressed quite like a woman (not a woman), and a wolf is expressed like a man. I feel strongly that the expression to say something did not work. Something, maybe it was a big hit mistake if I talked about this in Zentra 〓〓〓di as a gaudian episode of Ma Ros. Also friendships are not drawn cheaply. This is less than friendship power of the Kinnikuman. I say that it is against the food chain, because it is a promise of animals, I will not touch it. Which is evil and which is justice, it does not matter how it is a matter of viewpoint.
Unfortunately I do not want children to show this work. I feel it is worth tens of times that I showed it even in the wild and sheep times of wild 〓〓〓country.
Based on the above, we will evaluate it as the worst.
2008/07/16 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by 鯖鯖 (Skip) Provider: 45216 Host:45096 Browser: 6342
If I look licking with an animated movie for children, it is surprisingly deep. Although it is quite a long-standing place, it is indeed a long way and I do not get tired of it.
Arashi 's night is not drawn to know each other' s identity and personality, encountered, opposed to surrounding opposition and social common sense and intensified intention to overcome suffering over the new land is unimaginable from fantasy images Unlikely to have a deep proposition I will. It is this point that the original was sold.
It is apt to be a voice actor recruitment of a celebrity in this time's animation movie, but Kole is out of group and it is mostly up to sub characters. There seemed to be no strangely good person, so there was no discomfort. (Surprising Sampai ,,, Awesome His Atecko) Rather, the leading protagonists are rather good ,,, American crayfish and Takeuchi Rika were also smiling at the first voice actor challenge.
Evaluation is "very good". DOZO if you do not like to eat. It is quite powerful work.
2008/01/07 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by なおおき (Skip) Provider: 2503 Host:2501 Browser: 8090
Although I recently watched, though I felt that Mei's voice was floating at first, I got used to it on the way. Gab thought that Mr. Nakamura's voice matched. As for the last, it was good that Gab did not eat May, but when you saw the gab at the time when you remained, May was saying "May have not come out if you can eat" was a shock.
2008/01/03 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by TCC (Skip) Provider: 50988 Host:50917 Browser: 4184
This was also terrestrial broadcasting the other day ... but .........
In a stagger with a weak meal
As the title name, one wolf and a goat I came across from the evacuation to the same mountain cabin by chance at the storm blowing night, but its beautiful friendship is a group of wolves due to its "eaten or eaten" relationship Coupled with the scenes of the lucky drama and others, there was something that appealed as it was. At the end, I felt a bit surprising that the gobs of that wolf had become. Well, after all it was the final decision (?) But ... ......
I think that it was pretty real, such as the evacuation scene of the early stage, the appearance of the hut swaying in a strong wind, and boasted a high level among recent animations.
As for the voice actor appointment of the entertainer as well ........
In a recent epidemic, turnip is top form as an actor, family is subtle
Mr. Shido Nakamura (unnecessary care)? May was Hiroki Narimiya who was also showed off until then,
It was not a level to blow into the character again. Mr. Takeuchi of Mr. Gilo also personally likes that kind of actor, but .......
At least, the main character combination is a professional voice actor (in particular, May is unknown sex, but Yumiko Kobayashi or who is skilled at playing the role of a boy .....)
I wanted you to appoint.
I think that the theme was good and it is an impression such as a honorable mention that the enthusiast is unfortunately misdemeaned to have celebrities as voice actors easily with topic priority. Well, I never thought that I would like to see and see again. Evaluation is a place like "ordinary" which somewhat does not "good".
2007/07/23 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by プリキュア面白人 (Skip) Provider: 5372 Host:5531 Browser: 3874
Friendship between Gab and May
No, this is also a masterpiece, friendship is really wonderful when you see it halfway !!!
Watch out for this story again here !!!
Where Gab tried to eat May ... Ah ... definitely ...
Moreover, when Gab lost memory and was trying to eat May, it was good that Mei had not met as lonely as it was ... the memory of Gab revives ...
I cried a little with my last scene ...
No, this is also a masterpiece ...
2007/07/22 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by ヒロユキ (Skip) Provider: 40798 Host:40883 Browser: 4925
It is not bad, but how tedious it is.
Perhaps she seems to have a sense of incompatibility in the part that the leading role sheep and wolf (Gab,?) Are both male.
If you were to make it to male, I wanted a more magical production.
What are you going to do with those two ...?
2007/07/08 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by BB8 (Skip) Provider: 12661 Host:12737 Browser: 3006(Mobile)
This work was a wonderful accomplishment that can withstand adult viewing without having harm even if it shows it to children by the work which makes the story and the theme excelled, is moving, and it makes me want to see many times.
It is one work that you want children to see with their children by all means.
I was touched and watching the sheep and wolf that should not be able to understand each other and seeing how to overcome the walls such as the difference in species, the difference between predators and predators, and making deep friendships.
And it was good that I ended up suffering and finally got used to it.
In addition, Nakamura Shido and acting of May acted well for each character and it was very good.
Although this is a personal idea, how difficult it is to interact with the theme of this work, even those who repeat the dispute can understand each other's goodness and values 〓〓〓〓〓nd know if we can understand it I think that it is included in the root of this work
And that is the most important thing for us, human beings. In the present age where the international situation is intensifying and the countries are competing with each other, I think that such a work is necessary, I felt it as I saw this work.
Evaluation is the best.
2007/06/17 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by カンガルー (Skip) Provider: 10245 Host:10185 Browser: 6299
If this work is expressed in one word it is "the story of friendship of goat (herbivorous animal) and wolf (carnivore)",
From an unpopular perspective it can be said that it is a story of a beautiful thing that is made up of fiction.
Like a wolf (Gab) 's group said "You, getting friends with bait !?" As you stabbed, the carnivore' s wolf can not stop eating meat. Goat (Mei) noticed that a wolf (Gab) secretly had a carnivorous meal and can not hide uncomfortable feelings. At the end of suffering from hunger, I was prepared to expect the cruel end for adults in expectation, but eventually I traced the royal road story of the fairy tale, I drew it as a friendship story. I was forced into extreme conditions many times,
It can not be said that friendship beyond two innocent seeds can not have the view that it strikes the chest.
However, I could not empathize with myself because I was confused by contradiction.
The actions of goats (Mei) and wolves (Gab) who withdrew from the group of the same tribe and quit the relationship between predation and predation are counter to the universal nature of nature. The behavior and way of thinking of their friends,
It should be exceptional. Will it be obvious that they will not accept it as they move to new land?
I think that it is quite a good result if it sees it as a royal road of a fairy tale. I realize that I am an adult in a dirty world, but I can not help it. That is really the beginning of a tragedy,
Adults who really knead the reasons are also bad-looking and thinking that they are boring.
2007/06/09 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by ねぶそくのタカ (Skip) Provider: 458 Host:387 Browser: 5234
Were you trying not to disturb the atmosphere of the original picture book, you can give a gentle impression coupled with the story with soft drawing.
However, there are many depictions that pass through friendship and feel homosexuality, and can not go deep into the story. It may be that the manner of feeling has changed if I see it more when I am small.
And although it is slightly off the contents, it seems that the voice actor on the wolf side was better than the goat side. Because of my age it makes me feel like this ....
The subject age may be rather narrow.
2007/04/16 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by 美兎 (Skip) Provider: 18003 Host:17928 Browser: 4630(Mobile)
Although the original is a tragedy, although the movie ended with a happy ending, I felt unsatisfactory, but I was relieved at the end.
However, the scene where Gab which became memory loss remembered May with "Ararashinonori" was still a forcible pitcher, and it shook himself. I think that it was good to go to the scene of the full moon with some margin because the end was in a hurry. I think it was good until the scene where Gab fights bravely with a group of wolves.
Despite being drawn in comical, Mei, my close friend, seems delicious, and the story is surreal. That is a nice thing about this work though.
The goat eats the grass and the wolf eats the meat. On the contrary, contrasting with the casual depiction that the wolf cherishes the flower, I think that it was also good.
Although there is no weight and message nature of the theme as much as the original, there are lines that can be appealed to the heart much, I think that it was making it not get bored till the end.
Personally I like to draw characters. Especially, I think that Mr. Nakamura Shideudo (Kabuki actor) who played the gab was giving a good taste, well expressing the goodness of Gab and the goodness of people. Mei first got used to the floating impression, but I got used to it on the way. This is how I felt May 's unfriendly personality appeared. However, I was concerned about the fact that there were some voice actors who were reading sticks.
The picture was very nice picture of the touch. The scenery that Gab and May overlooked was really beautiful.
Music is also matched with video and it's complaining.
Together, I would like to make the evaluation "good".
2007/04/09 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by まつ (Skip) Provider: 5764 Host:5830 Browser: 3846
The story is neither possible nor impossible, for good or bad for children.
Two people who met each other like stormy ... Mei is pretty cute gab is cool The friendship between May and Gab is good, but depending on your view it also makes it look like romance.
The scene of the snowy mountains was good. The fighting gabs were cool.
The last memory loss was abrupt. Where to get back memories was also a forcible and this was not good.
I think that gabs were good for voice actors. There was also no discomfort.
Mei's voice does not match ... There was a time when I could not catch the words as well.
Although the image is beautiful, it is quite a lot of Tsukkomicho, so the evaluation is "normal".
2007/04/09 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by マドリディスタ (Skip) Provider: 34156 Host:34196 Browser: 4759(Mobile)
I also saw it at the cinema and watched DVD and saw it on TV, but it is still interesting. The two figures that cherish the forbidden friendships are totally inspirational. Trying to use each other to get information about each other but it was impossible to deceive the other party and both plunged into the river and the state of the conflicting gabs that can not be done with Mei who can eat themselves on the snowy mountains were drawn The scene was very good.
Also, although most celebrities are voice actors, I think Gab's Nakamura Shido is very good.
Although I have never moved to a happy ending, I thought that it was a bit of a push for Mei to say "I should have met on such a stormy night" and get back to memory as I got lost memory. I wanted you to twist a little more.
There is nothing to do with assessment but from another angle Mey gets along with the wolves of the natural enemy, betrayed herds and left along with that wolf, so that Mei 's friends (especially grandmothers, I was worried so much because there was a scene to talk about) I felt very poor.
Although there are some drawbacks, the story is wonderful, so evaluate it very good.
2007/01/27 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by エディ (Skip) Provider: 13471 Host:13344 Browser: 5234
While the children's book is the original, there is a good display,
It is certain that there was something wrong with the story description.
In the original this story was supposed to end at the point when Gab is kicking out pursuers, the wolves, caught up in an avalanche and life and death become unknown. However, taking into consideration what it shows to children, it is replaced with a happy ending, and the additional story at that time is also extra published in the original.
I do not dislike a bright ending, but I am not feeling very good if I get attached to a happy ending so far.
Mei was a bit nervous, but he liked Gab very much.
Although he seems to be weak, he is a character to do when he does it.
(Somehow suffered with Sulafuro Wolfe)
I could not stop thinking that it would be a good idea to abandon it and choose a way to protect my friends as long as there were any means to protect yourself.
I assume that it was an event on snowy mountains that was prepared to insist on that, but this is just a directing, it can not be said that there was inevitability.
Regardless of the group of goats, the group of wolves had their own arguments,
Even in the story, they showed some strength, so they liked them well.
Especially the leader Guillo was a person who stands pretty well as a character.
The place which does not lead as a work can be seen, but considering that it can be shown with peace of mind to the child, the evaluation should be "better" than usual
2007/01/27 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by 斐川 竜斗 (Skip) Provider: 15336 Host:15736 Browser: 3875
* It includes spoiler, care.
I tried to watch this animation, but it is a rice cake inside.
It is minus that there is only a homophobic part.
Whether it was better to have the girlfriend's gender all the more ...
Also, it is disadvantageous to this work.
Also, I was concerned about the favorable lives of evil.
Even wolves are hunting to live, they seem to say that wolves are evil only ...
The picture is high in level, it feels good in comics, but at the beginning the battle of goats and wolves is painful because of the cruel portrayal ...
The voice acting team can also say to Ghibli animation or something ... I wanted everyone to be a professional.
I did not want to appoint celebrities just for topics, I wanted everyone to be a professional.
It is a nice place for this work.
Although I was moved by emotion and it was a matter of fact, it was funny and something good, so friendship and determination of each was interesting.
I think that there was quite a sense of tension.
The encounter is also interesting, and the surprised scenes can also laugh, I enjoyed being lightly talking with each other in a friendly way.
I could not read everything about May.
Although it is expedient ... the snow mountain scene is the most doubt ...
It is a wall of the world of Grandia (it was a place that is certainly longer than the length) It is not easy to bypass ...
Because I understand the snowy mountains were dangerous.
Well, the scene of the snowy mountain is one of the main points ...
The fighting gabs are cool, though.
The scene of reunion of tragedy is good inside, well, I think that there are many people who understand that it is a tragedy with expression ...
The scene of "I had not met on a stormy night!" Is quite middle.
The last full moon scene was also good.
So the evaluation is "good".
There were many bad parts when thinking calmly, but it is certain that the emotions were moved as I was watching.
2006/10/12 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by ミイホン三号 (Skip) Provider: 45664 Host:45723 Browser: 5237
I used to write the name "Mihon No. 2" before.
I heard that "Great hits all over the world" "Loved by young and old and young guys" "A work that anyone can impress", I was expecting a lot.
Previously I wrote, but since I became fond of wolf in "Wolf King Robo" (I love all the animals), I told my acquaintance "Is it your favorite work?"
Also, as I was saying, "Wolf has many villains, but the wolf of this story is a good guy because it is a good guy?", He said, "I want to see it!", I tried to borrow a DVD ... .
Only the question "Why?" Does not come up, the content is also eloped, it is really boring. The setting "friendship of wolf and goat" was innovative and good, but ...
I thought that the story I imagined without permission was to tell children "preciousness of life" in the end "Maybe gabs are eaten by gabs and gabs survive." "I also thought that although wolves have a lot of images of evil, they really teach that" I care about my family and children, "" a strong ancient bond of friends ".
However, there is no such depiction in this work. "A wolf who eats a goat is a bad guy", and only a gab is drawn as "a good guy". Moreover, at the opening, "May's mother fought and fought with a wolf to protect May"
There was a scene that I was very angry.
Even human beings are killing as many animals as wolves, eating and living.
Despite this, it was disappointing because this animation only seems to be "evil wolf eating goat to live".
Later on in the story I heard, "This is a fable," it seems to be said, but I felt angry at the content that captured human beings of nature and animals' lives too much. Although it is for children, how do you draw animals living in nature like this? (It seems that the wolf acts as a goat eating 〓〓〓sexual desire)
I think that the voice actor is luxurious and Nakamura Shido is suitable. But the voice of Mr. Narimiya had a terrible sense of incongruity.
Takeshi Takeshi of Giro role played the role of "Yakuza's role", so I felt like I was making an image called "Wolf group = gang group." Actual wolf is strong family love, so I think that there is even more nobility.
Although there is certainly a terrible thing, person who individually got it to professional voice actor thinks that it is absolute good. Somehow, it feels like I decided it only by the topic, and the voice was small overall and it was hard to hear. (Music was bigger)
This animation was useless for me, because the depiction of wolves and goats other than Gab and Mei was too simple (wolf = berserk, goat = cowardly).
Although I have read both the original picture book and the novel, I felt the price was high. Although it seems that contents are different from animation, it seemed to be "money making principle work" and did not buy it. Since the related goods of this work are so numerous, "I thought that it is disgusting work because" the original is a picture book for children, feeling that he is taking a huge amount of money from the reader. "