[Anime]Agatha Christie's Noted Detective Poirot And Marple

RSS
Anime total pnts rank Rank 5,393in 5,699 titlesTotal -16 / Deviation 44.84
Anime avg pnts Rank 2,299in 2,693 titlesAvg -0.41=Normal/39 reviews
Anime rank of 2004 Rank 162in 180 titles
Statics of evaluation and Ranking
Reviews' statics
Post review by myself
Graphic1.00(Good)2
Music0.50(Good)2
Story-0.50(Normal)2
Character/Setting-1.00(Bad)2
Voice/Actor-1.00(Bad)2
Cute50%1/2
Enjoyed50%1/2
Cool50%1/2
Learned something50%1/2
Interesting50%1/2
Sexy0%0/2
Hot heart0%0/2
Brave0%0/2
Shed tears0%0/2
Sad0%0/2
Beautiful0%0/2
Romantic0%0/2
Moral0%0/2
Scareful0%0/2
Friendship0%0/2
Made me think0%0/2
Shocked0%0/2
Impressed0%0/2
Funny0%0/2
Poll
Information about this title

Agatha Christie
Naohito Takahashi Toshiyuki Watanabe
Oriental Light & Magic Inc.
Sayuri Ichiishi Takaya Mizutani
Susumu Aketagawa
Syosaburo Kimura Gaku Iwasa
Syukichi Kannda Hisako Matsumoto
NHK-ENTERPRISES 21 NHK
Tatsuro Yamashita
Takeuchi Mariya Katsuhisa Hattori
Kotaro satomi Kaoru Yachigusa Fumiko Orikasa
Mitsuko Kusabue Masaya Kato Noriko Sakai Oikawamitsuhiro
Japan Released:2004/07/04(Sun) / End:2005/05/15
33,9974739
Recently views
4483358477
  Limit by opinioin
Search in this page

The below reviews are translated automatically from Japanese ones. To post your review to English version, please click here.
2014/09/12 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 311 Host:598 Browser: 5387
This work is an animation depicting the success of Agatha Christie 's two creative detectives, Hercule Poirot and Jane Marple (Miss.Maple). In this work we made the worlds separate in the original, and there are a few original elements of the original character including Mabel. West, which is interesting.

I am basically tolerant of the adaptation of the original and the development of the original animation, and I will not deny the work merely because it is "different from the original". However, neither Poirot and Marple are fictitious fictional figures, neither Puiro nor Maru is a proof of unrestricted modification, and whether the image is protected or not deteriorated is an important consideration factor. In that respect, in this work neither is a character that gives a bad impression (it seems that personality has become more satisfying than original work such as Poirot), it can be said that it was a reasonably good setting. Many of the stories also conform to the original, and no major collapse is seen (although that point is one of the reasons for "unsatisfactory" as described later).

The point which I became concerned was that the two world detective worlds were linked, but Poiro and Marple never co-starred, and the stories developed separately. Far from solving incidents jointly, there was not even a face match. To be honest, it can be said that Mabel is the only point of contact between the two, and it can not be helped even if criticized as planning collapse. I thought that it would have been better to separately animate with this.

Mabel of the original character is set as the daughter of the nephew of Marple, and it is becoming an assistant of Poiro detective office. It is a character that is a bridge between two name detectives in the work and aim for the future name detective, and in essence it may be said to be the hero of this work. However, unfortunately Mabel can not be said to be fully utilized in the story. This is due to the fact that most of the stories were in line with the original, and Poirot and Maple inevitably appeared on the table, and the room for a 16-year old girl was extremely limited. Additionally, because Poiro and Marple never co-starred, the standing position as a bridging role became thin. I think it is a pity that it was quite a charming character (It is not necessary to make a lot of obscurity with respect to the duck's Oliver of a pet.I think it is a kind of mascot).

I should have made a story about episodes that made Mabel the main. I believe that she could draw a growing story as a detective of Mabel if there was an original story that solved her incident on his own (not a serious incident that could not be solved unless Poirot and Marple were of course of course). Also, is not it that the relationship with Arthur Hastings, which is the first assistant, has become an element of an interesting story? Hastings of this work was set very different from the original. He was a second young man in his twenties and was a setting that thought he wanted to be a detective more than Poirot until he was superior in body skill (the third setting was not well utilized in the main part) . Because Mobel and purpose overlap to a certain extent, I think that it became a good rival relationship, it became love relationship, and various drama was able to develop. In addition, Mabel had abandoned Hastings by last name. This is too funny, it is nothing other than a flaw in the screenplay (after all "Hastings" is normal, it is only when he permits to call it "Arthur" by name).

I think that in the case of this work, I should move the story more boldly. Otherwise it is not meaningful to purposely blend different original works into one and let the original character appear. Needless to say, I almost needed the original episode, but I should have made other original episodes. In addition to the main story of Mabel as mentioned above, I think that it was also necessary to talk about how Poirot and Maple cooperate to solve the incident (at least last). For example, when Poirot and Marple confront the ambition of Big 4 (the strongest enemy against which Poirot confronted, the collective name of the four big criminals leading international criminal organizations), when the name detectives fall into a struggle by enemy's trap, If there is a story that the hard work of reversing will win victory, is not it that the entire work has become very interesting (since the evaluation of the original of "Big 4" is one more, it should have been easy to adapt).

Well, what I was interested in besides the content is casting. Mr. Kotaro Satomi role as Poirot, Mr. Yakusa Kaoru and Mr. Kaoru 8 thousand actor, and a large number of actors have been appointed to guest characters as well. However, Mr. Satomi, Mr. Yachatsugi, there were still a lot of people who had question marks on voice acting as a voice actor in other non-voice actor casts (Satomi, even for Yakuzusa, it does not reach the true voice actor) . I think that the staff thought that they wanted to gather the ears somehow, but I think that all the roles should have been left to the voice actor of the profession as well (the usual actors and voice actor technologies do not necessarily match). Also, have you had to issue a telop such as "Voice, Satomi Kotaro" etc. Honestly, I felt eyesore. Also, in the ending, the non voice actor cast was given preferential treatment, and that point was also incongruous (at least Mombel role Orikasa Fumiko should have been displayed in the same manner as Mr. Satomi and Mr. 8 thousand grasses).

Although this work was not not interesting, it was conspicuous that it was inevitable enough. I thought that the staff did not want to get out of the framework of the original excessively because I had incorporated a large number of original elements, but I wanted you to have a spirit to develop your own, while also retaining the original story. Evaluation is "normal".

2010/12/07 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 46106 Host:46143 Browser: 6300
[good point]
〓〓〓It is an animation broadcasted with NHK, but it is for soft people with a soft impression.
〓〓〓Murder and others will also appear in the story, but because they do not draw scary,
I can watch with confidence.
〓〓〓Poirot and Marple 's name detective are attractive.
[Bad point]
Nothing in particular.
[Comprehensive evaluation]
It is a very good animation work. It is recommended.

2009/12/18 Best(+3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 3868 Host:3816 Browser: 5717
Agatha with the connection of the original character 'Mabel' as an artist.This is an animation depicting the success of the two name detectives of Christie. Although there are pros and cons, I love this animation.
In this story, Mabel who saw the activity of Poirot became an assistant and included elements of growth until it was recognized and I was able to see it happily every week even if I am not good at reasoning. (The connection with Maple is Mabel's father Maybe my aunt is a marble, that is, my relative and Mabel may also have a genetics detective gene) The story I like on Poiroside is "Request a lady who suddenly entered the chef!" Although it received, it talks that it develops into a ridiculous incident. My favorite story on Maple Side is a story of a friend of Marple who witnessed a murder in the train and Mabel steals into a man of somewhat bad family members. In this story there was a little romance of Mabel and it was fun to see. It is not unusual that ORIYARA does not get in the way and animation that does not break the original interesting fun? Personally I wanted to include the story of "Oriental express".

2009/06/30 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 1957 Host:1629 Browser: 6653
[good point]
Classical and sightseeing information flowing everywhere was good.
It was a good work as it was, with all kinds of animation of type acceptance.

[Bad point]
Because it was broadcasted four times over a long period, it took one month for one incident, and I felt a slightly dull feeling.

[Comprehensive evaluation]

Watched closely when I saw a big drama that was broadcast later.
As a detective animation, I think that it was good.
Mr. Poiro who is characterized by the main beard and egg face, the drama of reasoning mainly centering on Aunt Maruple chattering, Mabel of the heroine also serves as a good supporter Agasa is active without breaking the image of Christie's work You did it.
Personally, I first thought that these three people were family members. It is no wonder that Mr. Poiro and Aunt Marple have a daughter of about her age (net 15 to 16).

2009/04/08 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 41631 Host:41654 Browser: 7637
[good point]
〓〓〓Animation for all people with little habit.
〓〓〓avoid scripting difficulty, tricks that are easy to understand, and screenplays are made based on the basis of reasoning.

[Bad point]
〓〓〓The voice of the guest character actor is bad. A voice actor is cheaper if it is a gala. Just because your favorite actor appeared, there should be few people who watch animation.
〓〓〓There are many cuts on the grounds for reasoning and the background of the reasoning (which is unique to Britain) that we made in the end.
[Comprehensive evaluation]
As Agatha Christie's mystery introduction program, it is good.
Even a voice actor better, it was better.

Looking at this animation,
Some people think that "tricks are not a big deal".
However, if you are pursuing strangeness like Dikkun car, it is easy to fall into "Bakamisu".
In that respect, I thought Christie who had many motives tend to be motivated only by motives-oriented detectives.

Instead, it can not be helped to have more one-line scenarios and motives.

Still, I think that this place is more minded than Holmes.

2009/03/22 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 8573 Host:8587 Browser: 7282
It is a work which made famous Agasa. Christie's work animated.

It is a content that can be seen with a relatively light feeling.
There is not such a tough depiction, and tricks and reasoning are not as difficult as Kanedaichi and Conan.
Also, although it is the impression I saw, I think that this work is obviously not aimed at core anime fans, but I am thinking that it is making it as an inference for all ages.
However, I saw midnight animation but I was able to enjoy it quite well.
It seems like an animation to take a break.

The grandmother named Maple living in the country detective Poiro and a rural town solves the mystery, but obviously Poirot has a lot of appearances.
I can not imagine Marole enthusiastic fans, but I wanted you to broadcast it half after all.
I liked mysterious minds who are relatively responsible for Marple so much.

For this animation I think that there is not so much about the character's evaluation.
It is not intended to attract viewers with characters such as Poirot and Marple.
Strongly speaking, is Mabel who has a role like a detective assistant?
A figure struggling to struggle to become a leading detective while helping two detectives can be likable.
I doubt why Oliver who always follows that Mabel is normal, but I think that it was good to see it as a mascot character.

Also, the actor is in charge of the voice of the guest character almost every time, but I was not particularly concerned.
Well it certainly is bad if you compare it with a voice actor, but it does not mean that the person comes out well every time.
There are certainly discrimination by credit, but I do not think that it should be added to the evaluation of the work.
I dislike posture distinguishing between voice actor and actor.

I think that it is just good animation for children and children who do not usually watch animation.
On the contrary, I can not recommend it for people who are usually watching late night animation and noisy people as voice actors.
Evaluation is good.

2009/01/31 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 31635 Host:31546 Browser: 5235
Anime of detective objects that were broadcasted at NHK. At the time I broadcasted it was broadcasting after the mystery comic boom left, so I had the impression of what I did now, but once I looked back it was content that I could enjoy so much.

Without making heavy use of too bold tricks, making it tough is one of the good impressions. It was a kind content compared to a certain Conan which uses a variety of tools, wires, ropes, etc. which are hard to understand very much. Since it was not made to hurry, I was watching this animation thought variously, such as who is the culprit, doubtful, and so I wonder if I could enjoy it as a reasoning.

Where the corpse depicted in the deductive article or the scene to be murdered is not shown or cut only in the face is truly NHK. Consideration has been given to the staff as people involved in the era and clothing materials are involved, and to allow viewing widely from children to the elderly. But what is it that the depiction of the corpse is too vague too much? The mysterious atmosphere peculiar to the reasoning was quite lacking, and it was not good that the tension on the incident was very thin. It is not bad to let the duck's Oliver appear as a mascot character, but did not anyone think that Mabel's actions that would always lead to the case are unscrupulous?

As the title also says, this work is Detective Animation that is active by Hercule of the Detective, Poirot and Jane. Although it is a translation that is a bridge of these two people to Mabel of the original animation, it was not felt like connecting the two name detectives more than I thought in the work. Although various causes can be thought of, I think that the biggest reason is that Mabel could not be used well. If it is the world where two name detectives exist, it is not amusing even if there is a reasonable change in Mabel which is sandwiched between two people. But Mabel's growth is rarely seen. Finally it is said that preparation of the report became successful from Poirot, but if you let me say from here you are watching it makes me want to pin down just as much. In fact I think that it grows big in various places, but if you do not express it in a visible form, I can not feel the main character of Mabel. If you can not taste the presence of Mabel 's character, you can not feel the world where two people' s detectives are, so it 's pretty dangerous to set the angle.

Another feature of this work is the appointment of an actor. Actors are played not only in the main characters Poirot and Maple but also in various places, but clearly speaking, treatment is too good. It is introduced at the same time as the name of the role playing the role of Choi, and in the end credit it appears to appear after the leading role and clearly distinguishes it from those of the main voice actor. Especially, when the actor who appears in the end credit was only Marpuri's actor Yakusa Kaoru, so that Mr. Yachiakusa's notation is longer than that, Mr. Orikasa Fumiko as Mabel and Mr. Masako Castle as Oliver will not be moved even in the nature I was doing. I do not know the desire to push the actor on the front to the front, but it is too blatant to see it being too blatantly, and every time the name of the actor comes up I was bitter smile.

I will leave the actors' performances to your imagination, but it seems that the protagonist Kotaro Satomi and Kaoru Yachiaki were doing their best harder than I expected. However, if I say it badly, it is honest that it was relatively better than their performance because the actors of other actors are not good. There are people who would like to say various things on the performance side, but especially about Hiroki Matsukata.
It was a real villain's voice (laugh).

Although it is somewhat less tasteful as an anime of detective objects, I was able to enjoy it personally, and it is an honest comment that it was content not so bad. However, I noticed that the main character Mabel was not using it properly and that he used a lot of actors. Especially, I appoint people of famous voice actors to appoint an actor, and I feel that it was almost impossible to say that most were a criminal. Although the actor became the culprit only once, since the acting was too bad, the actor did not become a criminal act afterwards.
It is very disappointing that I was careful about strange places such as era evidence and providing costumes materials, and I did not care about the essential contents. It looks very regrettable because it is not an eccentric like a child's detective but it is made steadily.
Evaluation is "bad".

2008/10/24 Very Bad(-2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 29983 Host:29908 Browser: 8090
If I am the original author, I am mostly angry, "Please borrow only the name of my work and do not make animation!"
There is no human taste in the characters, and there is no appeal of attracting viewers to the contents of reasoning.
Detective objects tend to be bored with little movement, so I think it is difficult to make as animation, but this work is especially tasteless dry.
In this case it would be better to make a comical route for children as plainly as Kageman.

2007/12/12 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 3381 Host:3331 Browser: 8090
I talked about Poirot and Maple, and it seems that there was almost no story of Maple with all the story of Poirot.
Regarding acting actor 's performance, I do not think anything especially because it is quality I do not mind.

I think that the contents were pretty good, but the evaluation was "bad" because there was almost no talk of Maple.

2007/09/30 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 22279 Host:22412 Browser: 4184
I just saw it for a while, but anyway, it was terrible from the first impression.
It can not be done from the guts of the project of trying to get a good point, "Name Detective Poirot and Maple".
As you all say, OP, ED, Christie travel is Mar.
Other than that it is the worst, so on average it is very bad (as the proportion of worst elements is overwhelmingly large).

Although already pointed out, from the barefoot, under the name of the person who appeared in the main part, the name of a big actor, this is the worst.
... What do you think about animation?
If it is a live-action picture, since the face of the person himself appears still, it may be important that "who is doing"
(Still, there is a feeling of incongruity even in the case of a movie on television broadcasting, even if the character name + actor comes out)
In animation, a character with a picture quite different from the person's face, must come alive with the head of the viewer.
It is a revelation at this time.

Pictures are scarce in the expression of the characters, the desire of the background, clothes, all are terrible.
I do not say "Heidi" grade background, but expression, background.Is one of the clothes, did not the quality go up a little more?

And where I am doing my work, I have no intimacy with my pet and I do not know the hardships.
What is this girl ... There is a feeling of being forced.
However, contrary to Poiro, Marple and Guest, it is saved by a voice actor.
In the latter half, it became a character with no sense of incongruity ... professional work is amazing.

Mabel seems to have put it as a partner of Hastings ... ...
First of all, Hastings is the surname, the name is Arthur.
Since Poiro has a consciousness of "colleagues" beyond being friends, it is the last name abandonment.
Likewise, it is a work colleague, Mabel who is a younger person can not be a light English-speaking country with a hierarchical relationship as to how to abandon his seniors.
As a person who likes the drama version "Murder of the Golf Course", I wanted Mabel to call it "Arthur"
(In any case, as Mabel itself became a bad character).

More than anything, although I like basics that do not know who is the hero, stories that characters are not alive are out of the question.
As far as OP and ED are seen, the leading role is Mavel.
However, with captions subtitles two detectives and actor guests.
As a result, Mabel has become a chewy role, and the voice actor is sorry.

Although the quality of the animation's picture is terrible, Mabel saw as "Mabel is talking" only to a professional voice actor.
However, the two detectives and guests are in a state that "the voice is floating" without looking at subtitles.
I thought that I should pay tribute to more voice actors.

After all, the biggest mistake was the fact that we did not fully use Mabel which we botherly made.
It was a work that I could not see the stance as to what I wanted to do.

Considering the balance of evaluation with other works, I changed the evaluation from "very bad" to "worst" by lowering the evaluation by one level (August 18, 2009).

2007/06/25 Very Bad(-2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 16636 Host:16698 Browser: 4184
Certainly, appointment as a voice actor of a famous actor may have been received by adults who do not usually watch animation.
However〓〓〓

Are not you two protagonists, were you? A decent voice actor ...
In particular Misaki Ito and Koji Tomba (I think it is wrong) were bad ...
Well, especially the former is also subtle as an actress, so to say that I can not help it.

However, maple did not appear at all in the habit of the title.
The day I was watching was what was mostly Poirot's episode.
Which way was it better to have either Poirot alone or Marple alone?
Absolutely not only I think, "Who is thinking that" Marple turns too little! "... ...

Mabel's position was also subtle.
I just had the impression that it was dangerous for Hastings' assistant's position.
Besides, it is not a bridge between Poirot and Maple at all (^ ^;)

It was good that the theme song (especially the ending) and the minicolumn which traced the last of Agasa of the last.
Evaluation is "very bad".

2006/06/24 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 19376 Host:19602 Browser: 4483
The producer is never trying to make a trash, but I understand that he is trying to make Ryosaku rather.
I understand, but it seems painful that the degree of perfection of casting based on famous degree and work is inversely proportional.

Besides (although this is a destiny if it is a deductible), I do not think I will watch it again with DVDs or rebroadcasts after I knew the criminal and trick.
The work of this hand has a real pleasure in the ninth percentage "process until the elucidation of the mystery which I have not understood until now", and it can not endure re-viewing after that neta-breaking and seed witness.

I feel charm in Japanese animeized character deza and ED.
However, it seems that there is a problem with the above-mentioned production thought rather than production technology.

In the "normal" evaluation of offset 0 of the positive side of the original and the negative side of the result.

2006/04/08 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 5320 Host:5340 Browser: 5237
It is an animation of a messy setup. From the title I felt "What's this?"

As many others are saying, if you watch this work, you better understand that the actors and voice actors are different job types. It seems like I ran into topicality after all considering why I did not use a professional voice actor.

Both "Poarot" and "Marple" already have an image in me, so I felt a sense of incongruity for my character.

2006/04/07 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 27075 Host:27146 Browser: 6812
Speaking from the NHK level, it is the finest elaborate work.
Especially, Mr. Yakusa Kaoru of the role of Marple is impressive.
Personally, I like ED songs from OP songs.

However, Agatha has started reading Christie's work, but I still can not win the original.

However, this anime is a tricky thing Agatha. I think that it is good if more people take Christie work.

2006/04/07 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 20228 Host:20345 Browser: 5234
The atmosphere and design are good impression,
I think that dubbing is a problem.
Especially when I was a criminal who was not good at singing out, I was listening and suffering.
The actor who dubbed is what I would like you to do to someone who is good at it.

2006/04/06 Very Bad(-2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 20897 Host:20887 Browser: 5234
Animation that can be asserted in one word "boring !!"
Character design has no new taste, not a voice actor, it is strange that you should not be excited by just appointing actors.
Kotaro Satomi and Kaoru Yakuza who are appearing more than anything were badly sorry, and it seems that it is only an animation for NHK's self-euphoria and self-satisfaction.

Even though "fire bird" appointed a celebrity (Takeshita Keiko, Kume no Akusono), guest voice actors were gorgeous even though, they are from insect professionals more than anything, they are conscious of Tezuka Osamu, a great influence Although it was able to leave a good impact whether it was not the manga as much as the megaphone of Ryosuke Takahashi who was receiving it, there was no such impact in this work.

It seems that the producers did not know the goodness of the work "name detective poaro", or was not a totally fans, and had no thought.
This is a way of making it much different from a one-pattern mystery novel for children, and it is too drawn too much and the case resolving was also amazed at my life as "I was scattered a lot and ...", and in such a way of making it It is the same as boys detective cartoon murder case detainees who have bought 〓〓〓after too long of a juvenile magazine.

Although the story of a real Poirot is also one pattern, the story until I came to resolving the case was pretty strained, and it was not a style that there was no feeling of tension even without the sense of urgency like this work. I guess I have to say that this work has neglected efforts to dispel such things.

The story is also not interesting, NHK thinks that it is making a difference between ryosaku and ordinary work, and it has to say that he interpreted interpretation for poaro and Christie.
Not only for the voice actors who appeared but also for Satomi Kotaro and Yakusokusa Kaoru, this work may be something I want to forget.

It is also a proof that NHK is walking a path that is not much different from the Ghibli work, it was only quoting the name deductible work in a bad form from the story of the story, and it was just broke.

Even if you do not like the detective story much, you can not avoid being bad at this content.

2006/04/06 Not favorite comment [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 33223 Host:33285 Browser: 6287
The role of Mabel, the original character, is a bridge between Poirot and Marple, but there is no point as both of these are not entangled in the first place.
As many times as it was, it would have been better to make a drama with each hero alone. Still, once NHK
It will not be far from the overseas drama version that was being broadcast at.

David Souche 's role as Poirot, as Jeremy. Bled' s Homes role was very addicted.

2006/04/05 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 11009 Host:11078 Browser: 5234
I do not understand the meaning of Orikyara at all.
Speaking of the fact that the story is calm and calm, it sounds good to hear but as a reasoning thing mystery and its interpretation did not feel the power that draws viewers.
For overseas dramas, NHK is better than this.

2006/03/31 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 38924 Host:38928 Browser: 2876
Since the theme song was flowing at book off yesterday, a bit of impression ... (why).
I liked pretty and was watching.
From the very moment I was able to laugh that Poiro taught me "I will resolve the case next week" will be a break for the preliminary election.
I have never read the original, so I do not know the difference.
Takahashi Naohito's work is nothing to be felt or I do not feel the rhythm, but this piece also has that part.
But, well, I do not mind if I do not mind.
Because it is a mystery, it seems necessary for the viewer to think about (and favorable interpretation).
I think that it was good that Mabel was set up.
If she does not exist, it probably will be a lonesome screen as animation.
However, it is still a little old type of animation.
It may be aimed at, though.

2005/11/06 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 27747 Host:27613 Browser: 5978
Why did you need to put out Oriyara ... because it's for children?

For the time being, I dislike appointing celebrities and others as voice actors, such as making topics, and there will be no more skilled people than those people as there are occupations of voice actors.

I think that the atmosphere of the work was also incomplete as a whole because there was no astringent to make it acceptable for everyone.

2005/10/16 Worst(-3 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 47481 Host:47483 Browser: 4184
Speaking of Poirot it is a certain veteran voice actor who was dubbed as a foreigner who was doing the role he played in NHK before.
Although it is bad, Mr. Satomi's Poiro says it does not fall under the feet or does not hit the mantle.

I feel like talking with air like a story.

2005/10/15 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 32756 Host:32737 Browser: 2771(Mobile)
Acting as a voice actor had some problems, but overall I do not dislike it so much. .... It is not particularly interesting to say that (bitter smile).
Would it be a calm atmosphere if it says strong? I think that it is an animation that can make a different way of enjoying it than the gaudiness that can also take pointlessness like Kaneda and Conan.

2005/06/24 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 23100 Host:23004 Browser: 4487
It is not good poison or medicine, it is too good animation in daughter.

Well, well, NHK-like taste for all tastes like Poaro is David.It makes you feel only the existence impressed on the punch for the souche that has given the presence not to be recognized except Suke. Well, as a gentleman I hope.

It seems that NHK is making animation soon, but I want you to study it for a while.

2005/05/29 Very Good(+2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 14437 Host:14245 Browser: 5234
It has ended. I have not seen all of them,
Something interesting, something interesting. There are many strange detectives recently, but occasionally I like the atmosphere of such a relaxing masterpiece theater.

The gorgeous voice actors are such an anime masterpiece theater, and I did not feel like that much. Rather, even where the name of the actor comes up, a face can come up and enjoy.
Dare to say, this is an animation that people and families see in a family fight, so I will evaluate it as a service of NHK.

After all, there are ducks too.

2005/03/24 Very Bad(-2 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 34273 Host:34262 Browser: 5234
* On October 6, 2007, it was corrected to a sentence as per the format example.

Why recruit celebrities ..........

[good point]

Tatsuro Yamashita 's Theme Song

Unique singing ability was as ever.

[Bad point]

The meaning that made Poirot and Maple compete .........

It was the first impression that 1 TASS 1 = 1, or whether there was no big difference in which one.

Celebrity voice actor appointment failed

Misato Tanaka is especially cryptic. Even though it was not wise at winter sonas ............
Mr. Tsutsui Tsutsui is also like that, but is there any connection with NHK?
If you intend to continue the work of a voice actor, I'd like you to start over from the role of woman A at least.

[Comprehensive evaluation]

Well, NHK animation is not much different from commercial, but it was one of the shoddy works. Agatha. Mistress Christy may be mourned in the other world.
Unfortunately, the evaluation is "very bad".

2005/02/12 Good(+1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 13502 Host:13517 Browser: 3874
It has been quite long since this work started.
The audience rating always shows a certain value (about 9% though it is ...) in the animation section, and it seems to be quite popular surprisingly. Certainly I think that there are characteristics such as continuing to worry about and seeing again when seeing once.
As I am, it is quite likable work. On Sunday, that time zone I thought of a week that started the next day, I feel very disgusting, but the atmosphere of this work, music seems to contain somewhat healing elements, calm down You can watch. I think that Christie traveling after the work ends is also nice.
However, it seems that the voices of celebrities who occasionally appear appear to be lowering the quality of the entire work (again, experience).
Also as NHK, it seems that the direction of expression and expression seems to be a little bit odd (but OP, ED has a sense to hire Yamashita Tatsuro etc.)
I think that it is a regretful work in various ways.

2005/01/30 Normal(+0 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 32756 Host:32733 Browser: 2746(Mobile)
Is it possible to say that there is neither possible nor impossible.
Although I like deductive things but I have not read the original at all, I think that it is so funny but casting other than Mabel can not bear to listen like anyone else, but I can see it somehow except it.
Speaking of tricks, there are no brand new ones, but I think that I can not help commenting because I think that it can not be helped to complain about a work written 100 years ago.
However, this departure from Paddington is a little ...... It is impossible for the criminal and the motive to be too simple as the word of Marple. The criminal knew in the middle of the third round (bitter smile).
Evaluation is in a safe place.

2005/01/24 Bad(-1 pnt) [Original Japanese review]
by (Skip) Provider: 31195 Host:31055 Browser: 3793
It seems that it is finished for everyone uke style because it is an NHK production,
Actually it is like a mix of overwhelming criticism of the young generation and a fairly popular reputation of the father mother generation.
In a sense it can be called a well-balanced million people Uke (laugh).
Also, should I call it even Mugen Muke Uke who only seems like a million people Uke.

In the younger generation, Nadia, Sakura, Platenes, Twelve countries, Tsubasa with the start of April
BS2 Because there is broadcasting age, it seems that the way you saw it seems to fit the price.
Even from the keywords side by side with Poiro, agatha Christie, Kaoru Yagura and Kotaro Satomi, the main target is over 40s 50s.
Episodes are more firm than the current detective Conan, and in the calm atmosphere it can be liked with things currently on the air,
"Main place cast" As it is possible to produce even a single big river "spot"
It is settled as "bad" in terms of justification.

It seems that it will end soon like a bird of fire and continues long unexpectedly.
In the episode of the four episode composition, I am afraid of missing the fourth episode even if I can see the third episode,
Once you see it, whatever you do not feel comfortable unless you go home by broadcasting time.




Top Page top MetaSeachJP Works